Miscellaneous Artificial intelligence, or lack thereof

Selmer10G

Member
Messages
130
Location
East Sussex, UK
Sigh.
this from Google today when I open a new tab:
1666856693840.webp

no, google. that's not a clarinet. must try harder.
 
I know nothing about clarinets but I was tempted to google too. It seems that there are many (older and current) types of clarinet. And also many images comparing the clarinet to other instruments (e.g. oboe). Why Google picked this 'selection' I have no idea. I suspect that it's more to do with explicit (by users) or automatic (by Gooogle based on text) 'tagging' rather than AI. But I could be wrong. Google (and other platforms) are certainly capable of searching for 'similar images' based on image AI.

I'm a member of a photography forum too and AI is often touted as 'the next big thing' in photography. Not only in AI-based post-processing of individual photos but also in generating new photos from a text description. One of the leading 'photo generators' (but by no means the only one) is DALL E 2.

Could this take off? Some 'generated photos' (for example of President Obama's inauguration) look pretty authentic. Others contain visible faults. And other apps just create simplified 'Micky Mouse' photos of people and objects.

Personally, I believe that AI will eventually become an ever more sophisticated tool for 'real photographers' to post-process images. We've already seen a (minority) 'retro' backlash against the perfect digitally shot and Photoshopped photos. So 'film cameras' are again becoming more popular, especically amongst younger photographers. I suspect that a similar 'retro backlash' may appear against AI processed and generated photos. There's still a fundamental belief (for obvious reasons) that photographers need to continue to take 'real photos'. But I also believe that this applies to media outlets and viewers too. There's something about 'real' (current, taken on the spot from a personal perspective) photos that has a stronger appeal than 'manufactured' (and often relatively bland) photos.

Rant over 😉

Mike
 
An AI generated 'photograph' isn't one, it is a picture or an image, so therefore if sold as a photograph it is a fraud.
@Targa My example of 'AI-generated photos' probably wasn't the best one. More relevant, I think, is how various 'photo post-processing' are introducing 'Artificial Intelligence' (AI) functions to help users post-process photos with less manual work. Not by 'generating photos' but (for example) by:
- selecting areas of photos to edit
- applying AI filters to apply 'styles' to (parts of) photos
- extending 'backgrounds'
- applying various filters to photos in the 'best' way

This may not seem like 'rocket science' but these kinds of 'AI' functions do reduce the amount of 'manual work' that photographers previously had to do. All of these 'AI' functions are later manually adjustable. So they just provide a 'good (automatic) starting point' for manually editing photos instead of working from scratch.
 
@Targa My example of 'AI-generated photos' probably wasn't the best one. More relevant, I think, is how various 'photo post-processing' are introducing 'Artificial Intelligence' (AI) functions to help users post-process photos with less manual work. Not by 'generating photos' but (for example) by:
- selecting areas of photos to edit
- applying AI filters to apply 'styles' to (parts of) photos
- extending 'backgrounds'
- applying various filters to photos in the 'best' way

This may not seem like 'rocket science' but these kinds of 'AI' functions do reduce the amount of 'manual work' that photographers previously had to do. All of these 'AI' functions are later manually adjustable. So they just provide a 'good (automatic) starting point' for manually editing photos instead of working from scratch.
Which looks like a more 'advanced' way of doing what 'standard' photo manipulation packages do.
So the question is when is a photograph so manipulated it is no longer a photograph but a picture.
 
Which looks like a more 'advanced' way of doing what 'standard' photo manipulation packages do.
So the question is when is a photograph so manipulated it is no longer a photograph but a picture.
Haha, I'm a member of the Photo.net community where your question regularly appears on the discussion forum. I recently posted a Youtube video there in which British photographer Sean Tucker explains (with historical examples) how photos have always been manipulated. One example he gives is of landscape photographer and environmentalist Ansel Adams, famed for his spectacular black and white (film) photos of the American west from the 1920's onwards. In the video, Tucker talks about how Adams sometimes went through more than 30 'manipulation' steps to create his famous photos.
 
Haha, I'm a member of the Photo.net community where your question regularly appears on the discussion forum. I recently posted a Youtube video there in which British photographer Sean Tucker explains (with historical examples) how photos have always been manipulated. One example he gives is of landscape photographer and environmentalist Ansel Adams, famed for his spectacular black and white (film) photos of the American west from the 1920's onwards. In the video, Tucker talks about how Adams sometimes went through more than 30 'manipulation' steps to create his famous photos.
Well, now you get into that hairy line between "acceptable manipulation" and "fake". And pretty soon you're creating new theories of aesthetics, to try to replace the thousands of failed past theories, and which will also be useless.

So just how many angels CAN dance on the point of that pin?

African, or European?
 
Well, now you get into that hairy line between "acceptable manipulation" and "fake". And pretty soon you're creating new theories of aesthetics, to try to replace the thousands of failed past theories, and which will also be useless.

So just how many angels CAN dance on the point of that pin?

African, or European?
Yeah, it's all part of the same discussion. But I do like your very appropriate metaphor of 'how many angels can dance on the point of that pin?' 🙂

There are certain genres of photos (forensic, news, documentary) for which viewers (rightly) expect 'realistic, unmanipulated photos'. The truth is that almost all photos are 'manipulated' in some way. That doesn't mean that that the basic content (=information) has been changed. Just that the out-of-camera photos have been 'manipulated' to correct exposure, colors, contrast, etc.

A second type of 'manipulation' might be to target photos towards printed and/or digital media. Both in terms of 'cropping' to the available size and also in terms of other adjustments that favour either printed media or digital media.

Media photo-editors (and their teams) also provide a 3rd level of 'manipulation' based om the photos submitted by photographers.

Other than these 3 genres, both professional and amateur photographers are free to 'manipulate' their photos as they see fit.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,432
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom