Great Players Arggh! What's that horrible noise?

Me too, and his brother.

His Brother (who I normally rate pretty highly) was perpetrator of one of my all time crimes against sax.... There's an album where he plays with John Lee Hooker- on one track, after Hooker sets up funerial and hugely atmospheric guitar groove the sax kicks in with a 100 notes a second, frenzied bebop solo which pretty much redefines missing the point of the song you're playing on! Miles Davis and JLH however meshed superbly on the soundtrack to the movie Hotspot, Miles totally playing off the spooky minimalism of Hooker's guitar......
On a different issue I totally agree about revisiting more indigestable music- Coltrane makes far more sense to me than he did a few years ago.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
...and talking of revisiting Benny Carter, that is just what I did after hearing the BBC radio3 Jazz library prog on him last year. It got me to buy Carter's 1961 Further Definitions album. There are some great arrangements of numbers for the four sax ensemble - Carter, Phil Woods, Charlie Rouse and Coleman Hawkins, backed by a terrific rhythm section that included Jimmy Garrison and Jo Jones (a later similar album had slightly different personnel); Cotton Tail especially is superb. Great as a bandleader and arranger and blessed with lovely tone and technique, it is strange that the original liner notes tried also to talk him up as one of the top alto jazz improvisors of all time :"Carter's real originality shines forth perhaps most boldly of the three" (ie against Hodges and Parker). For me though, despite all the good things about him, he just is not up there with them.
YC
 
I'm reminded of a story concerning Lester Young, who in latter years played big jazz festivals and jazz supergroup tours to make ends meet.
at one such festival, he was standing backstage and a young saxplayer who was gaining a reputation as a lightning fast improviser,
spotted Lester and decided to show what he could do, launching into a blisteringly fast set of runs interlaced with high pitched squeals, Lester Young smiled and said "nice now play me a tune"
 
I'm reminded of a story concerning Lester Young, who in latter years played big jazz festivals and jazz supergroup tours to make ends meet.
at one such festival, he was standing backstage and a young saxplayer who was gaining a reputation as a lightning fast improviser,
spotted Lester and decided to show what he could do, launching into a blisteringly fast set of runs interlaced with high pitched squeals, Lester Young smiled and said "nice now play me a tune"

Can't remember who said it but the quote "how many notes do you really need to say what you have to say?" springs to mind...
 
Interesting about not liking Stan Getz. I thought I was alone in finding most of his "West Coast Cool" playing vapid. I don't much like the stuff he did with Astrud Gilberto and Antonio Carlos Jobim, but his work with the Woody Herman Herd is superb. Take a listen to their 1947 recording of Four Brothers.
 
...and talking of revisiting Benny Carter, that is just what I did after hearing the BBC radio3 Jazz library prog on him last year. It got me to buy Carter's 1961 Further Definitions album. There are some great arrangements of numbers for the four sax ensemble - Carter, Phil Woods, Charlie Rouse and Coleman Hawkins, backed by a terrific rhythm section that included Jimmy Garrison and Jo Jones (a later similar album had slightly different personnel); Cotton Tail especially is superb. Great as a bandleader and arranger and blessed with lovely tone and technique, it is strange that the original liner notes tried also to talk him up as one of the top alto jazz improvisors of all time :"Carter's real originality shines forth perhaps most boldly of the three" (ie against Hodges and Parker). For me though, despite all the good things about him, he just is not up there with them.
YC

After reading this,had to look it up on the the tube and found Benny playing Again and Again.Now that is fabulous sax playing,you can forget all the Jazz thing,to me this represents alto sax playing at it's ultimate finest,it's just so luscious

View: http://youtu.be/QTte2B8YIto
 
After reading this,had to look it up on the the tube and found Benny playing Again and Again.Now that is fabulous sax playing,you can forget all the Jazz thing,to me this represents alto sax playing at it's ultimate finest,it's just so luscious

View: http://youtu.be/QTte2B8YIto

Agreed. Beautiful playing (not sure I want to forget the jazz thing, though ;}). I'd definitely settle for being able to play the sax half as well as Benny could play the trumpet.
 
Another vote for Kenny G here. I agree that he is a very good musician but my God, too much cheese that grates so badly! Another good point on coming back to a musician you don't initially like. I've found this with Coltrane too as my own playing has progressed, I've understood his music a bit better.
Regarding the comments on Branford, I'd say that he was my favourite player for some time until I started listening to Coleman Hawkins, James Carter and Joshua Redman, all of whom seem to be having more fun with their playing without noodling too much! I still really like Branford but he seems more clinical and serious, as in his playing doesn't seem very playful.
 
Who has found that they set out to sound like their favourite player, but over time actually sounded like someone else - perhaps someone they didn't actually like, musically? There may be a player who has an incredible tone, or a way of phrasing, which you cannot deny, and it creeps into your playing - for me, I have always wanted that swinging, soulful, gospel sound of Cannonball Adderley - but as time goes by I hear more and more Paul Desmond in my playing (or so I think - check with my neighbours) - I think one of the most exciting things about sax playing is feeling that you are not really in control - that your sound just emerges, and often surprises you....? If only I had the talent / practice time...
 
Me i like listening to any sax players,dont care what it is,alto tenor,bari ,soprano,i admire the time they have put in to play the chosen instrument,even saw Kenny G at symphony hall and i enjoyed it,people may not like what he plays,but he can play,loads of people choose to play what they like and that keeps it interesting,be how so boring if everything the same...good post Nick.Dave.
 
I was having that kind of discussion today with my sax teacher (who is principally a clarinetist) and wants to get a better soprano sax sound so is listening to Kenny G.
I think almost nobody knows the actual sound of Kenny G. Only his personal sound engineer and his three secret wives are allowed to hear it unfiltered.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KfpL9mrRCg4
It is the worst offender at the moment. I even tried to listen to the whole cd.
 
'I think almost nobody knows the actual sound of Kenny G. Only his personal sound engineer and his three secret wives are allowed to hear it unfiltered'.

could say that about lots of players, sorry to admit i like west coast jazz, not all of it but the really slow melodic stuff, because I'm slow and melodic, or because thats the speed a may be able to play at!!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,677
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom