Saxophones Are the yamaha pro models MUCH better?

I still haven't found it...at least not for a price that isn't silly money (Inderbinen).

Regards,

Stephen, it would be great if you were able to do a back to back challenge on a Inderbinen and a Mk VI, the Inderbinen looks good value for money compaired to the ridiculous prices Mk VI's are being advertised for!! And that is if you are lucky enough to find a good one which is very rare.

Malcolm
 
Those Inderbinen horns look rather nice.He puts Yamaha keywork on his horns,great choice.As for MK6's give me a modern horn any time,Yamaha Z,Mauriat 66RUL, Yani 992,Borgani
 
Stephen, it would be great if you were able to do a back to back challenge on a Inderbinen and a Mk VI, the Inderbinen looks good value for money compaired to the ridiculous prices Mk VI's are being advertised for!! And that is if you are lucky enough to find a good one which is very rare.

I'm not sure there'd be much point to such a test. You could do the same with any pair of decent horns, and the only conclusion you could come to is that both horns are great but one will suit some players better than the other.
Thing is, the Inderbinen isn't a MKVI. If it was, I wouldn't be interested in it. As good as the VI is, it's not really what I'm looking for in a horn.

Regards,
 
I'd love to get one for review, but I think it's unlikely...unless a client comes in with one.
My experience of them thus far has been playing/examining them at Frankfurt Musik Messe for the last three years.
They're built with Yamaha keywork - so no problems there.
The body is hand built, and is full of ripples from the hand burnishing. Given the fuss over how important the bore is and how dents and suchlike can have an impact on the tone, you'd think these horns couldn't possibly work...but they do. And they work extremely well.
There are a lot of great horns out there, but the majority of them tend to stamp themselves on your sound. The Inderbinen doesn't seem to do that - it's by far the most 'transparent' horn I've ever played.

Regards,
 
If I but a YTS-275 I get an instrument of a certain description. It will work well, look good and probably last for many years with regular services.

Now, I have an 82z which is rather more expensive. It comes with additions that have no effect on the way it plays. For example, it has more upmarket engravings, comes with a 4CM mouthpiece rather than the 4C, a metal mouthpiece cap, and the case looks, and is, quite expensive.

I imagine that for the extra money I get some improvements that I as a layman am unlikely to appreciate, but that would be readily obvious to people like Stephen Howard, Griff and others. For ought I know, these differences mainly have the effect of lengthening the period between replacements and services. Others may put the instrument into a different musical category.

I cannot imagine that Yamaha would produce the 275 if it wasn't up to scratch. After all, a dissatisified customer will turn to some other brand. A satisfied customer will look at the 475 to 875 range if an upgrade is deemed advisable.

My initial decison to purchase will depend on a range of assumptions, some of which almost certainly cannot substantiated. Important among these is the view that a more expensive instrument of the same brand is likely to be better. Frankly, since the day I bought the 82z I have become older and wiser. Part of that process has been the purchase of the Phil Barone Vintage Tenor. Now I would start with something like the PB or the BW M2. In fact, I could get both for the price of an 82z. Either way, my playing would sound just as good.
 
Another way of looking at this question is this:

Assume that you are a beginner with the aim of reaching grade eight and that you own a 275 in good order. The time it would take you is Time. Now consider whether, if you upgraded to another Yamaha instrument and maintained the same rigorous practice routine, your time to reach grade eight would now be Time minus x. If you can foresee no change in the time required, would there be other benefits that would make the upgrade worthwhile?

Just a thought.
 
The YAS 61 I was watching on ebay went for a silly price (it needed repairs and still went for about £545, too much...) so this is all academic at the moment. But many thanks to everyone for your posts - I have decided I like my 275 - it seems to do everything I want - so that'll do!
 
The YAS 61 I was watching on ebay went for a silly price (it needed repairs and still went for about £545, too much...) so this is all academic at the moment. But many thanks to everyone for your posts - I have decided I like my 275 - it seems to do everything I want - so that'll do!

Agreed, silly money for a dented "project", i was bidding to 450 but after that too much... Still good luck to the guy, wonder what he paid at his antique auction, 100?
 
I tested a load of top-end saxes one time at sax.co.uk and picked up a YAS62 assuming it was a Custom. It was only after playing it and thinking how good it felt and how well it played that I realised what it was. Definitely lots of bang for the buck, certainly a pro horn. The Customs did have something else for sure but the YAS62 is such a fun horn to play - similar scenario with the Yanagisawa 901 versus the 991 etc horns - definitely pro standard and the slightly lighter build makes for a brighter horn that is great to play. In my opinion, the 62 and Custom horns do have quite a lot more to offer than the 275 although that is a great horn that could earn its keep in professional work if you are a doubler or if you just like it as it is.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,557
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom