Miscellaneous An even worse nightmare?...

I was told throw away the word conductor. You are a musician in the band is your instrument. You are not a metronome. You want to control the Dynamics of each section don't worry so much about the tempo you are learning to play your instrument. when it's time for a section to play a part reach your hand out to them and make eye contact let them know you are there to lead them in. I remember in college they put all us guitar scholarship people in the concert band in the percussion section. And I got to play the timpani. That conductor made me love it. When my parts came around his hand was out there my direction and he look like he left while I was playing And that just drove me with his energy. He would raise his hand to tell me how loud he wanted that Crescendo to And then the fist to tell me to stop. And then the look of approval like I just made his day. Of course he was that way with the rest of the band and the rest of the band was always looking for that look of Approval. UC world-class conductors when they're finished with a performance their hair is a mess clothes are a mess their tie is undone. They poured everything they had into that Orchestra for that performance
 
Last edited:
If I can offer some constructive feedback: Your baton technique and conducting pattern are quite good. A common mistake made by beginning conductors is to keep their heads down looking at the score. Eye contact with the group is essential---especially when giving a cue for an entrance. I personally try to use a minimum of body movement when I conduct. The focal point for the group needs to be the tip of the baton and your facial expressions. Too much movement can be distracting. I like to see a difference in the size of the conducting pattern to reflect the dynamics of the piece. The more you do this, the more your self confidence will grow. In my formative years I spent hours in front of a full length mirror conducting Rhapsody in Blue, the 1812 Overture, and the New World Symphony and that's before I had a clue as to what I was doing.

Spending time in front of a mirror was suggested.

I did a MOOC a couple of years ago, run by Evan Feldman, on "rehearsing an ensemble" and much of the same advice and information was covered in that and on Sunday.

This video was my first attempt at conducting in practice (we conducted 2 more sessions later in the day). Huw Thomas, who ran this course, took my baton away in the afternoon! He also stopped me from tapping my foot, and encouraged me to look at the performers more, making eye contact with those playing the next solo.
He tried to get me to cue crescendos and diminuendos with my left hand at the same time as conducting with my right, but that was where the co-ordination problems kicked in - more practice needed (lots more practice). I guess that's where a mirror will help.

It was definitely a great experience and one worth following up.
 
My challenge is I am left-handed. Whilst I could just about conduct with my right hand (I think I explained the 'above the wiast left hand, below waist right hand issue I have e.g. bowl cricket ball - left (for friends over the pond, think baseball), ten pin bowling - right). I was OK conducting with left and cuing etc with right (I suspect being a stirng and piano player, i'm used to left and right doing different things).
Despite left handedness, band were OK with it saying my beat was clear - and I conduct RH beat patterns. I did try RH but it was not as good and I have less independence of arms that way too... work that one out... 🙂
 
From what I've seen, the art of conducting is more in the preparation and rehearsal. You need to have their respect and a larger than life personality, and masses of self confidence. If it's not going right, talk to them and if they don't listen, stop them and explain yourself. Rehearse each section individually.

The performance is just that, for both ensemble and conductor. I wish I had the nerve. I'd be a proper tyrant. The only band I can direct is the one in the box. :rolleyes:
 
As long as the band are all playing the same tempo with the right notes and the right time having an organic feel is good. My band Swingsation has a tendancy sometimes to speed up in the solo choruses and slow down in the vocal ones. Takes really good listening, and we do practice speeding and slowing at rehearsals as often a tempo doesn't feel quite right for the night. Its not too hard in a quartet or trio and we have been palying together for 3 years now. Larger ensembles usually end up in less stellar territory with tempo changes.

I conduct with my foot as both hands are busy on guitar in this one
 
As long as the band are all playing the same tempo with the right notes and the right time having an organic feel is good. My band Swingsation has a tendancy sometimes to speed up in the solo choruses and slow down in the vocal ones. Takes really good listening, and we do practice speeding and slowing at rehearsals as often a tempo doesn't feel quite right for the night. Its not too hard in a quartet or trio and we have been palying together for 3 years now. Larger ensembles usually end up in less stellar territory with tempo changes.

I conduct with my foot as both hands are busy on guitar in this one
are you chunking straight 4s or are you comping kinda loose? Just curious lol so when you want to take it to the 4 you use your foot ? Lol sorry I just got this mental picture going on.
 
Last edited:
In many of the songs I use the Pompe as its called. a grace note upstroke before the raked downstroke of 1 and 3 nd a muted whipped downstroke of the strings on beats 2 and 4. That forms the base but its always nice to throw in some variations when appropriate, In ballads and some other material its loose and in Out of the Woods I play eledtric fingerstyle mostly.

Unless one is a Gypsy Jazz guitarist it probably doesn't make a lot of sense. Takes a reasonably skilled guitar player several years to get it to effortless and build up the stamina. Probably the hardest single skill I have ever had to learn. I would get to the point of thinking "now Ive got it" hear myself and realize it needed more work.
 
Tempo is important, but conducting is so much more than that, otherwise a metronome could be used. Having said that , don't some bands use a click track when recording?

Yes, and on stage. Especially for example whether is additional sound from programmed MIDi or audio samples


However a click track does not need to be a constant tempo, there is no reason it can't vary. I tend to use a click rack when recording, especially as a lot of my work depends on layering something up via overdubs.

Often when writing for film/TV I need there to be tempo changes so the music fits to picture. Click tracks have been used in movie recording for probably 70 years or so. And was originally done by punching holes in the film.

However the role of a conductor is not (or rarely) to ensure a steady metronomic tempo. In fact one of the conductor's role is often the opposite: to conduct variation in tempo and make it possible for everyone to be in the same boat. Same applies to another conducting important role, to dictate/suggest dynamic interpretation.
 
Last edited:
One of the things with especially longer pieces of music is that there are time changes, ralls, rits, allargandos, rubato, accelerandos, changes of time signature and changes of tempo. This is where the conductor is most needed.
 
Last edited:
He tried to get me to cue crescendos and diminuendos with my left hand at the same time as conducting with my right, but that was where the co-ordination problems kicked in - more practice needed (lots more practice). I guess that's where a mirror will help.

It was definitely a great experience and one worth following up.

I remember those exercises in my conducting class in college. I had to work to overcome the same coordination problem (that's why I became a musician rather than an athlete). Don't worry, it will improve with practice. The more I directed groups I found that the left hand (if you are right handed) was best used very sparingly, such as starting a piece, cutoffs, and big accents. If used all the time I looses its impact. As I mentioned in a previous post, I found directing dynamics is best done by changing the size of the conducting pattern.

For marches and pop or rock tunes that do not change tempos, the conductor does not need to be a metronome. In fact it often works best on these types of tunes when the director turns the time over to the group directing only the accents and releases at the ends of phrases. "Less is more" is a good saying to keep in mind when directing an ensemble.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,066
Messages
578,482
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom