Saxophones Alto quandary.

I've recorked the palm keys and side keys to adjust the amount they open. Lowered B Bb and C cups. Easier to play and better intonation. It's starting to sing.
I had a blow on the old G4M for a reference. I can't believe what I've been putting up with. The 508 is much lighter too.

I've got an alto/clarinet gig thursday. If it goes to plan the G4m can go on the bench for a strip down and clean. I think it used to be nickel plate. :confused:
 
Gig went well with just an occasional fudging round the palm keys.

While trying to get more familiar with the layout, a strange problem has cropped up.

I was feeling the intonation was out around the palm keys, so like a fool I got the tuner out. Bad idea.

Palm notes are spot on as is the whole upper register. The lower register however is up to 40c flat. Pushing in doesn't help without throwing the rest of the horn out.
I never noticed at the gig or playing at home.

I've had the old G4M out and it's the same. I thought it must be the tuner. Checked the settings. No. Got the clarinet out. Fine. Nothing wrong with the tuner.
Got the Ekhart out. Same. 30 to 40c flat in the lower register.

Is it a mouthpiece mismatch? Tried the Link 5* and the Yam 7C. Similar. Flat in the lower register.
I can't hear it when playing with backing tracks. What's going on?
Should I have taken my own advice and left the tuner in the drawer?
 
Gig went well with just an occasional fudging round the palm keys.

While trying to get more familiar with the layout, a strange problem has cropped up.

I was feeling the intonation was out around the palm keys, so like a fool I got the tuner out. Bad idea.

Palm notes are spot on as is the whole upper register. The lower register however is up to 40c flat. Pushing in doesn't help without throwing the rest of the horn out.
I never noticed at the gig or playing at home.

I've had the old G4M out and it's the same. I thought it must be the tuner. Checked the settings. No. Got the clarinet out. Fine. Nothing wrong with the tuner.
Got the Ekhart out. Same. 30 to 40c flat in the lower register.

Is it a mouthpiece mismatch? Tried the Link 5* and the Yam 7C. Similar. Flat in the lower register.
I can't hear it when playing with backing tracks. What's going on?
Should I have taken my own advice and left the tuner in the drawer?
Thats a strange one, low D, C and B can be flat on some altos but its usually ok when you get to low F.
I have not come across a horn where all lower register is flat compared to second register being ok.
Another way to find out would be to visit a woodwind shop and try different altos with your mouthpieces and see if you have the same problem, I know this would mean you would have to travel but it could give you answers to help you sort this out.
 
Last edited:
Gig went well with just an occasional fudging round the palm keys.

While trying to get more familiar with the layout, a strange problem has cropped up.

I was feeling the intonation was out around the palm keys, so like a fool I got the tuner out. Bad idea.

Palm notes are spot on as is the whole upper register. The lower register however is up to 40c flat. Pushing in doesn't help without throwing the rest of the horn out.
I never noticed at the gig or playing at home.

I've had the old G4M out and it's the same. I thought it must be the tuner. Checked the settings. No. Got the clarinet out. Fine. Nothing wrong with the tuner.
Got the Ekhart out. Same. 30 to 40c flat in the lower register.

Is it a mouthpiece mismatch? Tried the Link 5* and the Yam 7C. Similar. Flat in the lower register.
I can't hear it when playing with backing tracks. What's going on?
Should I have taken my own advice and left the tuner in the drawer?
I'd guess it is your embouchure, I had the same when I looked at a tuner. I tend to be very relaxed at the lower end and have to tighten slightly at the top, so if I hold that position the lower end is nearer.
 
Coming from a complete amateur here:

I have struggled with a similar problem -but being sharp in upper registers (I suppose it's down to where the mouthpiece is on the cork as to whether sharp at the top or flat at the bottom). I'm retraining myself using a Theo Wanne Water ART mouthpiece which has a 3 opening (yes really): squeeze too hard and the reed stops vibrating. The mouthpiece is more flexible than you'd give credit and sounds rather good to boot.

Interestingly: I've started playing tenor in the last few weeks and having to learn a new embrouchure: I'm using a Yamaha 4C and intonation is spot on top to bottom. I do find it's a bit of a different technique and far more mouthpiece in mouth required. So length of mouthpiece facing curve may be coming in to play.
 
@Colin the Bear , I think @Targa may have a point. You've tried three separtate altos with two different mouthpieces with the same result. The one constant is bear shaped.

If you haven't noticed it before, don't sweat it too much. May be that you're doing something different when checking against a tuner compared to actually playing a tune.

I leave my tuner in my case most of the time. I tend to use it when I first get a sax to set a reference point for the mouthpiece on the cork, which I then mark with a pen. Then it goes back int he case.

I used to use the piano for this, but the piano hasn't been tuned for ages..........
 
What's also doing my nut is, if I overblow in bottom register, octave, 12th and double octave and occasionaly higher, are bang on.
Tuner is now in the drawer. I may take the batteries out.
3 different saxes with three different mouthpieces. It must be me.
I hate saxophones. It's why I have so many. :confused:
 
It's pretty normal I think, but can be improved. I tend to tune the horn to itself rather than to a tuner. i.e you get the mouthpiece on so that octaves are in tune.
It's typical of clarinettist to use too much pressure on the reed so the upper register gets too sharp. If you can get the low notes you're probably relaxing so it is going flatter. The instrument is naturally out of tune i.e flatter in the bottom end and sharper up top. If you just get the notes out you'll experience this. Using a different embouchure can help a great deal. Taking a bit more mouthpiece in and having the bottom lip in front of the teeth help in making the intonation more even.
Mouthpiece position on the cork makes a difference to the overall tuning. People often don't get the mouthpiece on enough. Pushing it on a bit more sharpens that bottom end. Then you need to relax up top so you don't oversharpen it.
This stuff can drive you mad - you're probably right to chuck the tuner away !
I like to play along to Hal Leonard playalongs with the sax part audible so you can hear if you're tuning is out. Then you get the track again without the sax and can play it with the backing. You might hear odd notes like the C# being a bit off which may be an indicator of the mouthpiece position on the cork being wrong. Generally it's something you shouldn't sweat about too much. Tuning tends to get better as you play more.
 
40 years not enough then? 😉

Maybe it's a lockdown hang over. I haven't busked for over a year. Roll on summer.

My solo gig with backing tracks seemed to go ok. I got rebooked.

Same with the NO band I've started playing with. Sounds ok to me and no complaints, in fact compliments.

Perhaps they're all tone deaf.

I do wonder how far out the players I hear playing off key are if I can be 40c flat and not notice. I'm quite puzzled. Maybe I'll stick to upper register solos or look for a vintage conn. 😉
 
I think when we play to a backing track we will lip up to be in tune, but when you play to a tuner maybe not lip up so much, so you're flatter than normal(?) It tends to point towards needing the mouthpiece pushed on a bit more.
The lower end tends not to sound as bad, if it's out, as the top end where small changes make a big difference.
 
Reputation is yesterdays horn. If the build quality slips what are you buying for a premium price? I don't want to play postal ping pong till a decent one turns up. Sure I won't get the one in the pictures. However that's the one they chose to use for promotion purposes.

I'm sure the ali express horns were proffered tongue in cheek.

My G4M punches way above its weight but I don't know where to get another.

The Startone Bari is turning heads and ears and feels great. Why wouldn't I consider their alto?

I've had many dealings with Thomann and never been disappointed.
30 day no quibble return policy, 3 year guarantee and way cheaper than any one here.

Spare parts? The only spare parts for a saxophone I've needed is pads and springs. I'm not resurrecting anything. Just wear and tear from my own use.

The Thomann 580 is in the post. Due any day. Fingers crossed.

I'm in the mood for an Egg Foo Yung now. 😉
did I say my mate has a pucker one in his loft plays a treat, no dinks or dents, not played since he upgraded to a Hansons.....just saying....lol
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,705
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom