kevgermany
ex Landrover Nut
- Messages
- 19,857
- Location
- Just north of Munich
Have been trying to get to grips with the Kohlert alto since I bought it earlier this year. Lovely instrument, but I was struggling to play it. As I wasn't having the same poblems on the tenor, and there were no leaks on the alto - and my teacher had played it with an identical mouthpiece, I put it down to me.
The old Brillhart Tonalin personalin that came with it has a good reputation. I tried the Kohlert with the cheapo mpc. that came with the chinese alto, and I tried it with a Rico Graftonite B7 (got a wide one to match the PPT8* I'm using on tenor). Same sorts of problems. Reed locking up, too much resistance.
Had similar problems with a cheap chinese alto that I bought to practice repairs on, with all the moutpieces. So it's languished, not unplayed, but not really gladly played. I thought that alto wasn't really for me.
Another cheap chinese alto came up on ebay recently with a low buy it now price and the attaction of a Selmer mouthpiece (type unspecified), so I took a chance intending to split and sell on. They arrived yesterday. The Selmer turned out to be an S90 C*. So nothing special. The alto didn't play very well - neck's loose and it hops octaves around G as a result. So there was I thinking same old problem, perhaps I should sell the Kohlert. But..... I thought I'd try the Selmer on the Kohlert and see what happend. What a revelation - effortless from bottom Bb to top F... Sounded good as well... Not quite as rich or mellow as the Brilhart - but playable...... Very playable.
I think the Brilhart problem is that it's a short facing. But it doesn't work for me. The Graftonite seems to be too wide for me on alto. So the Brilhart's going to my music teacher who wants it as a backup. The Graftonite will be tried with much softer reeds (was using a 2, and a 3 on the Slemer), but may end up on ebay.
Now to ty the selmer on the Buescher 20A I'm fixing at the moment. Maybe some of the poblems I'm trying to fix are mouthpiece related.....
So to the points of my long winded ramble...
I'm happy with the 8* on tenor - why would such a narrow tip work well for me on alto? AND - how many guys post problems here that are mouthpiece related and we never realise it?
The Kohlert played perfectly for my teacher on an identical Brilhart... Is it that he's such a good player he doesn't notice the difficulties we mere mortals have to battle with? And how do we identify whether problems are with the equipment or the player?
One thing's for sure - the Kohlert is going to get played a lot more now... And I'm starting to wonder if getting another PPT with a slightly smaller opening will make the tenor easier to play.
The old Brillhart Tonalin personalin that came with it has a good reputation. I tried the Kohlert with the cheapo mpc. that came with the chinese alto, and I tried it with a Rico Graftonite B7 (got a wide one to match the PPT8* I'm using on tenor). Same sorts of problems. Reed locking up, too much resistance.
Had similar problems with a cheap chinese alto that I bought to practice repairs on, with all the moutpieces. So it's languished, not unplayed, but not really gladly played. I thought that alto wasn't really for me.
Another cheap chinese alto came up on ebay recently with a low buy it now price and the attaction of a Selmer mouthpiece (type unspecified), so I took a chance intending to split and sell on. They arrived yesterday. The Selmer turned out to be an S90 C*. So nothing special. The alto didn't play very well - neck's loose and it hops octaves around G as a result. So there was I thinking same old problem, perhaps I should sell the Kohlert. But..... I thought I'd try the Selmer on the Kohlert and see what happend. What a revelation - effortless from bottom Bb to top F... Sounded good as well... Not quite as rich or mellow as the Brilhart - but playable...... Very playable.
I think the Brilhart problem is that it's a short facing. But it doesn't work for me. The Graftonite seems to be too wide for me on alto. So the Brilhart's going to my music teacher who wants it as a backup. The Graftonite will be tried with much softer reeds (was using a 2, and a 3 on the Slemer), but may end up on ebay.
Now to ty the selmer on the Buescher 20A I'm fixing at the moment. Maybe some of the poblems I'm trying to fix are mouthpiece related.....
So to the points of my long winded ramble...
I'm happy with the 8* on tenor - why would such a narrow tip work well for me on alto? AND - how many guys post problems here that are mouthpiece related and we never realise it?
The Kohlert played perfectly for my teacher on an identical Brilhart... Is it that he's such a good player he doesn't notice the difficulties we mere mortals have to battle with? And how do we identify whether problems are with the equipment or the player?
One thing's for sure - the Kohlert is going to get played a lot more now... And I'm starting to wonder if getting another PPT with a slightly smaller opening will make the tenor easier to play.
Last edited by a moderator:
