Saxophones Alto for warm tone

OK guys...... Y'all lost me at the end there to be honest.... Straight over my head with all that terminology....
Let's get back to the question huh....
Yes I agree that it's definitely subjective...
Warm means to me the same as.. Dark... Fluffy... Soft.... Fuzzy.... Mellow... Laid back... Relaxed... Chill.... Etc, etc
You get my meaning.
As opposed to something sounding bright.. Focused... Hard.... Not chill... Not relaxed.... Not mellow... Etc, etc...
This is just what I think of when I ask for a warm sounding tenor.
And yes, I think that the mouthpiece and reed setup does definitely give drastically different sounds on the same horn but... Inherently that horn will.. Perhaps... Still have an underlying warmth or brightness depending on its design etc.... 🤔🤷☺️😉
Thats what I hear when listening to horn comparisons using same mouthpiece /reed setups. 😉
 
Sometimes I have a mind to rotate through the altos on my saxwall. Same mouthpiece (usually a JJ HR* or Brilhart Great Neck Ebolin), same reed (Hartmann Carbon), same me. Just play one, pull the mouthpiece and put it on another, back to back to back.

To my ear the 6M (1937) is the brightest and the Comm3 is easily the darkest. The Big B (1945) is very dark as well but the Comm3 has an extra smoothness to the tone that makes it very distinct.

The only modern keywork horns I have are a Selmer (USA) AS100 and my daughter's Yamaha 475. The Selmer is definitely the darker of those two.
 
Ok, a bit of basic physics. An air column in a tube has a resonant frequency which (with a bunch of provisos that we'll skip over) determines the "fundamental" pitch. So, in the case of a saxophone, if you finger a low D, the length of that air column, determined by the distance from the tip of the mouthpiece (with certain physicist arm waving, hereafter just referred to as "huminahumina") determines the pitch of that low D. But an air column of that length can resonate at other frequencies. The first one to consider is at twice the frequency. I expect most of us have made a middle D without the octave key, but if you push the octave key while fingering a low D, you will get a D in the staff. That is the first overtone, or second order frequency resonance (huminahumina) of D. So when you play that D in the staf with or withour pushing the octave key, the FUNDAMENTAL is D below the staff, and you're playing the first overtone or the second order frequency.

Now the flutists amongst us will say "but what about the third octave?" and some of the saxophonists will say "but what about altissimo?" and I have to say that it depends, note by note, whether you're playing the third order, fourth order, or etc. to get a note that responds reasonably and kinda sorta in tune (huminahumina).

Now here's the freaky thing. When that air column that you're creating by fingering low D (back to Saxophone) is resonating at a nice solid xx Hz, giving you a good solid low D... There are also what we might call "subsidiary frequencies" at which it's ALSO resonating (huminahumina). So if you were to chart air pressure fluctuation magnitude (huminahimina, sorry but I don't know how else to name it) versus distance down the tube, you would see a nice sine-ish wave, but with minor deviations which would resolve (huminahumina) to second order (an octave above), third order (octave and a fifth), etc. vibrations. It is THESE additional resonances (huminahumina) that give a particular instrument its tonal color. Not the presence or absence, but the relative amount. If you get a chance to mess around with a traditional drawbar Hammond organ, you can get an idea.

So, no, the note being played is not necessarily a fundamental. It can be a first harmonic (second order, an octave above) a second harmonic (third order, octave and a fifth above, as per the entire clarion register of clarinet) or what have you.
Thx....so....extrapolating your comment here...

Would it be fair to say the subsidiary frequencies creating the additional resonances are more plentiful on a horn sound considered 'spread', and less present on a horn sound considered 'narrow' or 'focused' ???
 
Sometimes I have a mind to rotate through the altos on my saxwall. Same mouthpiece (usually a JJ HR* or Brilhart Great Neck Ebolin), same reed (Hartmann Carbon), same me. Just play one, pull the mouthpiece and put it on another, back to back to back.

To my ear the 6M (1937) is the brightest and the Comm3 is easily the darkest. The Big B (1945) is very dark as well but the Comm3 has an extra smoothness to the tone that makes it very distinct.

The only modern keywork horns I have are a Selmer (USA) AS100 and my daughter's Yamaha 475. The Selmer is definitely the darker of those two.
That's interesting because I consider the Comm 3 brighter than a 6m.
Hmmm....maybe I will revisit that, unless someone knows of an online comparison soundfile or vid ??
 
I know not a 6m, but my 14m did have "dark" qualities, but compared to the CommIII, it was harsh and bright. The CommIII is lush and very full bodied. The 14m felt like it would fit perfectly in a mostly rock setting (so more "focused"?) . The CommIII I feel can stretch way more either way, but it always has a lot going on no matter what direction you take it. The 14m always felt harsh and bright.

Low-end notes between them are vastly different too. The 14m sounded good, but you FEEL the CommIII.

Compared to a VI, the CommIII is also way darker sounding(all things being equal) and IMO has more going on in the timbre department then any other horn I've tried.


Another good example is in violins. My wife has an early 20th century German violin which is a wonderfully made and sounds great. But then she got a handmade short-neck early 1800's violin that looks not so great and it blows it out of the water. The German violin is focused but the timbre of the 1800s violin is just unlike anything else I've ever heard. All with the same strings, bow, etc. It oozes character, is the best way I can describe it.

This is how I think of a CommIII compared to everything else I've tried. Oozing character that isn't replicated even with the same equipment on another horn.

The issue with these terms is that they are mostly subjective. I actually like lush vs dark and harsh vs bright. Because, for example, the CommIII can be "bright" but it isn't harsh and still retains that lush/dark quality.
 
The issue with these terms is that they are mostly subjective. I actually like lush vs dark and harsh vs bright. Because, for example, the CommIII can be "bright" but it isn't harsh and still retains that lush/dark quality.
Yes, it’s a big issue too. I would have thought that lush goes with warm, rather than dark. But.. And you have me wondering about the useage of the word bright - I don’t think of it in a bad way , but harsh is harsh.
 
When it comes to judging the different tonal qualities of Saxophones, best to ask a Guitarist, as some claim, that they can hear the difference in tone, between an electric guitar's various fretboard material.
Gaboon
Macassar
Rosewoods
Maple
No mention of fret material or size of bead. 🧐
Hopefully, pitch discrimination, will be on their, todo, list. 🙉
 
When it comes to judging the different tonal qualities of Saxophones, best to ask a Guitarist, as some claim, that they can hear the difference in tone, between an electric guitar's various fretboard material.
Gaboon
Macassar
Rosewoods
Maple
No mention of fret material or size of bead. 🧐
Hopefully, pitch discrimination, will be on their, todo, list. 🙉
Yes, this is also known as 'Hogwash'....
 
Thx....so....extrapolating your comment here...

Would it be fair to say the subsidiary frequencies creating the additional resonances are more plentiful on a horn sound considered 'spread', and less present on a horn sound considered 'narrow' or 'focused' ???
I don't know that. I think blind jury testing would be required, to determine whether the vocabulary words' usage correlates with certain aspects of their acoustic out put.

We see that a lot of people use the term "large bore" when they have exactly zero measurements, just driven by playing a particular instrument and experiencing a response that they think, with not a shred of evidence, correlates with being "large bore". And the dimensions of a saxophone bore can be objectively determined with rather simple equipment and methods. Yet no one EVER actually refers to actual measurements! Think how much more complex it would be to look at sound spectra and try to determine which features might correlate with certain perceived tone qualities.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,341
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom