Saxophones Alto for warm tone

See, now this is interesting; Jaye says "Conn 6M" for warm round tone. I think of the 6M as brash, bright, and with a certain hoarseness that I always associate with Conns.
Interesting, I hear none of those attributes in a 6m. Not brash nor bright compared to most other vintage horns as well as modern. I consider them quite dark, round, and spread.
 
Let me walk it back. I think "warm" usually means the fundamental frequency is prominent in all registers. (The octave vent does not completely eliminate the fundamental; it reduces it to less loud than the octave.) A largish chamber mouthpiece helps.
I read that four times and still cannot get what it means, exactly. I wanna understand it, tho...

But your train of thought is one we should probably pursue.

Can we come up with a generally-agreed-upon definition of what a 'warm sound' means ? If not a definition, then...

What are the attributes ?
 
To me, a 'warm' tone tends towards dark, spread, lush...a bit 'horn like' as in French horn, trombone....

So reediness and 'treble' are subdued, while lows and low midrange are boosted...to oversimplify it a bit.

Then the tonality is 'spread', wide...so, the opposite of 'focused', if that helps any...
 
I've been waiting for "someone" to mention SML in this thread. Gorgeous horns
Argument can certainly be made.

I had it on my list then removed it...only because to me, yes they are dark, and wide as a house, too... but they do have some edge and 'bite' to the upper harmonics, sorta like a Martin Comm 3 or King Zeph or S20 (two other models I also initially wrote then revised off...also removed the 'Crat in favor of thr THC 400, because the former has a more focused sound, the latter a wider spread in tone).
 
I read that four times and still cannot get what it means, exactly. I wanna understand it, tho...

But your train of thought is one we should probably pursue.

Can we come up with a generally-agreed-upon definition of what a 'warm sound' means ? If not a definition, then...

What are the attributes ?
There is no agreed upon definition that I know of. I don't think it would help anyway. Describing sound with metaphors is never going to work very well.

How can I clarify what I wrote that you cannot get?
 
The mouthpiece matters most, along with embouchure. There are mouthpieces available that are marketed as being like Desmond's. I don't know if he was "dark" though. What does that mean? He said that he wanted to sound like a dry martini. There's a metaphor that I understand.
I never understood that metaphor. What is the sound of a dry martini? Does the choice of distilled product matter? I used to enjoy drinking Hendrick’s - don’t care to play alto. Now that I’m on immunotherapy, I cannot drink gin and still have no interest in playing alto.
 
@Pete Thomas there’s nothing in the glossary on this subject. As a composer what are your thoughts ?
I thought about it but couldn’t think of descriptions. We already have. Couple of resources published:


And


I’ll quote part of that one to help demonstrate the complexity of the topic:

I write a lot about saxophone sound, but there seems to be some confusion over terminology, which got me thinking…Dark can be used to mean the same as warm, which some people think of as the opposite of bright.

But when I say dark I mean the opposite of light rather than bright (but you might think the opposite of light is heavy). As far as I’m concerned the opposite of a bright sound is a warm sound, but you might well think of a warm sound as the opposite of a cold sound. But then I call a cold tone what some people call a clear tone .

On the other hand some people might call that a focussed tone (or a tone that projects). But to some a focussed tone could be an edgy tone, a compact tone, or maybe even a centered tone, (which are surely two different things) and then again to others it might be thin, the opposite of which you might say is fat, however it could be argued that this is unfocussed, which is the opposite of what some people call bright. Or you might like a big fat warm dark round sound, the opposite of which is…
 
Last edited:
I think what this really comes down to is a saxophone setup that allows flexibility of tone. Some seem to dictate the tone a bit more than others so you have to work harder to get a warmer tone on some instruments. I say "setup" because the mouthpiece IMO is actually way more important than the instrument in this regard for setting the tone. And obviously the player is even more important for both the tone and the sound concept.
 
I think it is so difficult using terminology to describe sound, we are all different and one persons bright is another's dark, a player needs to listen to what's in their head and try to replicate this using their horn, mouthpiece and reeds of choice not forgetting to practise in order to get where you want to be.

I have mentioned this before that i went to see another player who i thought sounded similar to me, but my wife said he sounded way brighter than me, so it's all subjective.
 
Last edited:
There is no agreed upon definition that I know of. I don't think it would help anyway. Describing sound with metaphors is never going to work very well.

How can I clarify what I wrote that you cannot get?
at the danger of looking like a fool, your "fundamental frequency"...
to me, the term applies to the note being played.
Beats me. I never understood that one or "focused" at all.
Well if you listen to a VI, and many modern Asian horns, vs. you listen to a Keilwerth or Conn, you can hear examples of that. One seems focused in tone, pinpoint, narrow....while the other seems 'wide', 'fat'.

Thus, to me, a spread tone has the fundamental frequency still prominent, but it has other harmonics that are audible above and below. A focused tone has a narrow scope of those accompanying harmonics.

But maybe 'overtones' are a better term than 'harmonics', here...
 
Now that you mention it I am curious if it's physically possible for a non-overtone played saxophone sound to have sub-harmonics. Understanding that we might be talking about two related but separate things, what is actually sounding and what it sounds like.
 
Ok, a bit of basic physics. An air column in a tube has a resonant frequency which (with a bunch of provisos that we'll skip over) determines the "fundamental" pitch. So, in the case of a saxophone, if you finger a low D, the length of that air column, determined by the distance from the tip of the mouthpiece (with certain physicist arm waving, hereafter just referred to as "huminahumina") determines the pitch of that low D. But an air column of that length can resonate at other frequencies. The first one to consider is at twice the frequency. I expect most of us have made a middle D without the octave key, but if you push the octave key while fingering a low D, you will get a D in the staff. That is the first overtone, or second order frequency resonance (huminahumina) of D. So when you play that D in the staf with or withour pushing the octave key, the FUNDAMENTAL is D below the staff, and you're playing the first overtone or the second order frequency.

Now the flutists amongst us will say "but what about the third octave?" and some of the saxophonists will say "but what about altissimo?" and I have to say that it depends, note by note, whether you're playing the third order, fourth order, or etc. to get a note that responds reasonably and kinda sorta in tune (huminahumina).

Now here's the freaky thing. When that air column that you're creating by fingering low D (back to Saxophone) is resonating at a nice solid xx Hz, giving you a good solid low D... There are also what we might call "subsidiary frequencies" at which it's ALSO resonating (huminahumina). So if you were to chart air pressure fluctuation magnitude (huminahimina, sorry but I don't know how else to name it) versus distance down the tube, you would see a nice sine-ish wave, but with minor deviations which would resolve (huminahumina) to second order (an octave above), third order (octave and a fifth), etc. vibrations. It is THESE additional resonances (huminahumina) that give a particular instrument its tonal color. Not the presence or absence, but the relative amount. If you get a chance to mess around with a traditional drawbar Hammond organ, you can get an idea.

So, no, the note being played is not necessarily a fundamental. It can be a first harmonic (second order, an octave above) a second harmonic (third order, octave and a fifth above, as per the entire clarion register of clarinet) or what have you.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,056
Messages
578,171
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom