Tone or Sound All you Growlers out there…

1. The amount/type of growl effect produced by singing a certain interval away from the note played stays constant if that interval is maintained as you move around the horn
Maybe but who wants to do that. May when I am playing again I'l do a recording of some playing with growl, and adda mic at my throat to pick up the singing. Could be a good experiment.

But I'm absolutely sure that if you are supposed to sing a constant interval, ie min parallel with your playing, then I couldn't do that. Unless it's a case of:
Unconscious competence
However in my case it could well be incompetent competence, or even incontinent incompetence
2. The harmonic series plays a part;
Maybe but maybe not.
3. Difference Tones ("3rd notes") must come into it too - we know about humming/playing on brass instruments to produce chords...
As it's a very different method of tone generation I would not jump to that conclusion.
 
An extreme growl is almost flutter throat,
Flutter tongue and growling can be combined. First flutter tongue and then add growl. Nothing I did. I can't do flutter tongue. I don't growl so often. I have a rather, gritty/raspy sound so the growl didn't make so much difference. But for 20-30 ago years growled a lot.
 
Last edited:
I learned to growl as a teenager when I joined a band and had to play Shotgun by Jr. Walker. I was aware that he was actually flutter tonguing, not growling, but I can’t flutter tongue very well because my jaw is narrow and my tongue is wide.

But like @Pete Thomas I don’t know if I am singing a particular pitch, and if so which one. I think of it more like an inarticulate scream rather than a specific pitch. Playing flute, I have in the past been able to get that sing-along sound, by humming an octave or two below the note I’m playing, but that’s different than growling on saxophone.

Hope this helps, I don’t have specific techniques to describe - frankly I’ve never thought about it much, I’ve just sort of done it.
 
The solo and growl is good. It's Rock & Roll Saxophone.

Would you play it in the same live?

A slow R&B, blues .... ballad, would you growl in the same way?

R&B Saxophone and Rock & Roll Saxophone is not only about growling, flutter tongue ...... . It was very much a live act in the beginning that was brought into the studios. Lots of the live feeling got lost when the recording sessions and the recording technique took over.
 
The solo and growl is good. It's Rock & Roll Saxophone.

Would you play it in the same live?

A slow R&B, blues .... ballad, would you growl in the same way?

R&B Saxophone and Rock & Roll Saxophone is not only about growling, flutter tongue ...... . It was very much a live act in the beginning that was brought into the studios. Lots of the live feeling got lost when the recording sessions and the recording technique took over.
That’s my problem Thom, I can’t vary it. Works great for Rock but not necessarily for much else - too heavy.

Can’t flutter tongue, can’t roll my “R’s” either.

I need to experiment and see if I can modulate it at all.
 
That’s my problem Thom, I can’t vary it. Works great for Rock but not necessarily for much else - too heavy.

Can’t flutter tongue, can’t roll my “R’s” either.

I need to experiment and see if I can modulate it at all.
Your growl sounds great to me. But to make it more versatile I would just try some different long notes while varying both pitch and loudness of the “hum” but without overthinking, ie not trying to think about what the pitch is - just vary it randomly.
 
Your growl sounds great to me. But to make it more versatile I would just try some different long notes while varying both pitch and loudness of the “hum” but without overthinking, ie not trying to think about what the pitch is - just vary it randomly.
Thanks Pete.

Previously it hadn’t occurred to me that you could vary it - more a case of “you have what you got” thing. My bad..
 
Can’t flutter tongue, can’t roll my “R’s” either.
Pete, here are some old notes from another site that may or may not help;

The Flutter Tongue/Tone​

I do not know when the flutter effect started being used on the saxophone. An explanation of the technique appears in a 1926 publication titled SAX-ACROBATIX by Henri Weber

Pete Thomas;

Saxophone Effects

I first became aware of it in 1956 when I heard Honky Tonk Part 2 by Bill Doggett. Clifford Scott used it in his 4th solo.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MxFiSrZRo4Y


It was also featured on the 1958 recording of Tequila when Chuck Rio used it while repeating the main melody.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDWmM0_CWMI


In 1965 Jr. Walker performed the effect in Shotgun.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FI7CtxlisCk


Joel C. Peskin added it to the end of his solo on a more recent 1989 Top 40 hit titled With Every Beat of My Heart by Taylor Dayne.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xibP5rRotMY


Also listen to the second phrase of Bobby Keys’ solo on Brown Sugar by The Rolling Stones.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0bxMWdOMbs


Perhaps it was developed and introduced by blues artists when they wanted to play a real “down and dirty” sounding solo. It really lends itself well to blues and rock music. A combination of the growl, flutter tone and note bending will put you well on your way to playing some very effective sounds!

The flutter technique produces the same sound that is made by singing close to a desk fan. It causes the tone to flutter by separating the air stream.

To learn this effect, I suggest that you use only the neckpiece and mouthpiece in the beginning to get control of it, and then attach the neck to the horn.

Before you play the neckpiece, try to make the sound that is similar to a small motorboat engine by blowing lightly and at the same time raising the tip of the tongue gently against the front portion of the roof of your mouth just behind the front teeth. Although you can lightly touch the roof area do not press the tongue into the roof. Just raise it enough to make a rapid flutter between the tip and the skin of the roof. The effect is also similar to the sound of a “cat purr.” However, there is no need to make a sound or hum anything while fluttering the tongue. Once you learn to develop this sound it will transfer to the m/p.

● Courtesy of a sax message board member; “A “HEEEEEE” formation of the tongue shape puts your tongue in a high arch and will draw the tip of your tongue away from the mouthpiece. Many players consider variations on the “EEE” vowel shape to be preferable for general tone production. Vowel shapes such as “Uhh” and “Ooooh” leave the tongue in a low position that does bad things for your air stream.”

Using JUST the m/p do the same thing as above but DO NOT TOUCH THE REED while the tongue flutters back and forth towards the roof of the mouth. The tip portion of the tongue should flutter in the roof area in front of the tip of the m/p. If your tongue touches the m/p tip opening it will stop the effect.

If you continue to have a problem getting the sound, try doing the flutter without using the m/p. Try to get a good strong sound then use just the m/p with the neck without the horn attached. Remember that the tongue does not go up and down. It is normally very close to the roof of the mouth and the upper side of the tongue (just behind the tip) is making the motions which indent the air stream to make the flutter sound. And you can do this with a small amount of m/p in the mouth. It may take time to find the physical action that works best for you. You may also experience a problem in loosing too much air while blowing. This is normal because some people have to exhale very fast to get the flutter effect. This causes a quick loss of air. However, in time you will develop more control and will use less air.

Everyone has a different jaw structure and tongue shape. What works for me my not work for you. Experiment with all of the basic ideas and the technique will eventually develop depending on your own physical structure.

And another approach; Without the saxophone, say and sustain a rolled “rrrrr.” Some people will find this very easy, others may find it very difficult.

Several examples can be heard on YouTube. Copy and paste these titles;

REBEL ROUSER—DUANE EDDY—GIL BERNAL—TENOR

1958 HITS ARCHIVE: Rebel Rouser - Duane Eddy

TWISTIN’ THE NIGHT AWAY—SAM COOKE—JACKIE KELSO—TENOR

1962 HITS ARCHIVE: Twistin’ The Night Away - Sam Cooke (#1 R&B hit)

URGENT—FOREIGNER—JR. WALKER—TENOR

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pVe4nMDr8VY

Other links for the flutter tone;

Saxophone Effects

Rock & Roll Sax - Book/CD Pack Hal Leonard Online+

Amazon.com

Star Licks Saxophone Tutor: Beginning - Rock Sax [VHS] : Scott Page: Amazon.co.uk: DVD & Blu-ray

http://www.amazon.com/Blues-Saxophone-Depth-Styles-Masters/dp/0634026208

Also check YouTube for illustrations.
 
Last edited:
The "Rolling - R" is not apart of my dna. "Tongue root - R" is. Maybe I can learn flutter tongue (?) but I don't want to lose my "burring R" produced deep down. That is also nasty.

Sax Gordon is playing the flutter tongue together with a heavy vibrato and he is not relaxed. Maybe a growl as well? Rock & Roll sax is lots of volume, sweat and of course the things we calls "Rock & Roll Sax effects".
View: https://youtu.be/pbpf3dGYgOE?si=tiWg-0PCazzS0wgF
 
Pete, here are some old notes from another site that may or may not help;

The Flutter Tongue/Tone​

I do not know when the flutter effect started being used on the saxophone. An explanation of the technique appears in a 1926 publication titled SAX-ACROBATIX by Henri Weber

Pete Thomas;

Saxophone Effects

I first became aware of it in 1956 when I heard Honky Tonk Part 2 by Bill Doggett. Clifford Scott used it in his 4th solo.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MxFiSrZRo4Y


It was also featured on the 1958 recording of Tequila when Chuck Rio used it while repeating the main melody.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDWmM0_CWMI


In 1965 Jr. Walker performed the effect in Shotgun.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FI7CtxlisCk


Joel C. Peskin added it to the end of his solo on a more recent 1989 Top 40 hit titled With Every Beat of My Heart by Taylor Dayne.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xibP5rRotMY


Also listen to the second phrase of Bobby Keys’ solo on Brown Sugar by The Rolling Stones.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0bxMWdOMbs


Perhaps it was developed and introduced by blues artists when they wanted to play a real “down and dirty” sounding solo. It really lends itself well to blues and rock music. A combination of the growl, flutter tone and note bending will put you well on your way to playing some very effective sounds!

The flutter technique produces the same sound that is made by singing close to a desk fan. It causes the tone to flutter by separating the air stream.

To learn this effect, I suggest that you use only the neckpiece and mouthpiece in the beginning to get control of it, and then attach the neck to the horn.

Before you play the neckpiece, try to make the sound that is similar to a small motorboat engine by blowing lightly and at the same time raising the tip of the tongue gently against the front portion of the roof of your mouth just behind the front teeth. Although you can lightly touch the roof area do not press the tongue into the roof. Just raise it enough to make a rapid flutter between the tip and the skin of the roof. The effect is also similar to the sound of a “cat purr.” However, there is no need to make a sound or hum anything while fluttering the tongue. Once you learn to develop this sound it will transfer to the m/p.

● Courtesy of a sax message board member; “A “HEEEEEE” formation of the tongue shape puts your tongue in a high arch and will draw the tip of your tongue away from the mouthpiece. Many players consider variations on the “EEE” vowel shape to be preferable for general tone production. Vowel shapes such as “Uhh” and “Ooooh” leave the tongue in a low position that does bad things for your air stream.”

Using JUST the m/p do the same thing as above but DO NOT TOUCH THE REED while the tongue flutters back and forth towards the roof of the mouth. The tip portion of the tongue should flutter in the roof area in front of the tip of the m/p. If your tongue touches the m/p tip opening it will stop the effect.

If you continue to have a problem getting the sound, try doing the flutter without using the m/p. Try to get a good strong sound then use just the m/p with the neck without the horn attached. Remember that the tongue does not go up and down. It is normally very close to the roof of the mouth and the upper side of the tongue (just behind the tip) is making the motions which indent the air stream to make the flutter sound. And you can do this with a small amount of m/p in the mouth. It may take time to find the physical action that works best for you. You may also experience a problem in loosing too much air while blowing. This is normal because some people have to exhale very fast to get the flutter effect. This causes a quick loss of air. However, in time you will develop more control and will use less air.

Everyone has a different jaw structure and tongue shape. What works for me my not work for you. Experiment with all of the basic ideas and the technique will eventually develop depending on your own physical structure.

And another approach; Without the saxophone, say and sustain a rolled “rrrrr.” Some people will find this very easy, others may find it very difficult.

Several examples can be heard on YouTube. Copy and paste these titles;

REBEL ROUSER—DUANE EDDY—GIL BERNAL—TENOR

1958 HITS ARCHIVE: Rebel Rouser - Duane Eddy

TWISTIN’ THE NIGHT AWAY—SAM COOKE—JACKIE KELSO—TENOR

1962 HITS ARCHIVE: Twistin’ The Night Away - Sam Cooke (#1 R&B hit)

URGENT—FOREIGNER—JR. WALKER—TENOR

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pVe4nMDr8VY

Other links for the flutter tone;

Saxophone Effects

Rock & Roll Sax - Book/CD Pack Hal Leonard Online+

Amazon.com

Star Licks Saxophone Tutor: Beginning - Rock Sax [VHS] : Scott Page: Amazon.co.uk: DVD & Blu-ray

http://www.amazon.com/Blues-Saxophone-Depth-Styles-Masters/dp/0634026208

Also check YouTube for illustrations.
Thanks John. I really like the Joel C Peskin solo - especially over very much a pop song and funky Jerry Hey horns. Works great.
 
I’ll report back once I’ve deep dived into this - I never have, so I need to adopt a proper practical approach with it.

I’m fairly sure that the flutter tonguing isn’t going to happen but I need to analyse what I do at the moment - pitch-wise - for one. Am pretty sure that I don’t vary the volume of my hum, and this is the most immediate interest for me, along with pitch.

Watch this space.. well, the space below..
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,571
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom