Mouthpieces Aligning the mouthpiece on the neck

Messages
367
Location
Malaysia
Level
Beginner
This is probably falling into the stupid question category, but I feel like I need to ask anyway or else it will just keep bugging me to no end.

So when I put the mouthpiece on the neck, maybe or maybe not with a freshly-lubed cork, I push it in with some twisting until it gets to the position where I want.

But! It's a little slanted to the left. So I try to give it a bit of twist clockwise. It moves! But now it's a little slanted to the right. Gotta twist it anticlockwise... and it moves! And now it's a little slanted to the left again. And so the process repeats a few times until I get it perfectly flat/level/aligned.

I can't believe that I'm the only one that has to go through this ritual almost all the time, can I?

I don't think my neck is too tight, the mouthpiece generally slides in easily and smoothly; it's just the twisting motion that it wants to resist (unless I'm twisting while pushing in or out).

Maybe I'm babying the thing too much? Every time I twist the mouthpiece I'm always worried about damaging the neck octave mechanism, so I'm too gentle on it and not gripping/twisting with enough force? Maybe that's my problem?

Or maybe I'm just too particular with the angle?

Your thoughts?

Edit: better explanation in post #8 below...
 
Last edited:
I reckon the MP - Cork interface has to have a "Stick–slip" interface otherwise the MP would move around while playing. If it doesn't slip; cork grease. If it doesn't stick; new cork. If it sticks too hard a little bit of sanding?
 
Somethimes I remove the cork grease with heat and afer most of the cork grease is "oozing out" i place the neck with the cork in a small glas of waterr. Just so much that it cover the cork. Cork is an organic material and needs water or mosture to work well.

Make sure the cork is straight. A mouthpice bore is straight, the neck is tapered. If the cork is glued on a neck it shouldn't be tapered. Then the contact area is just 4-5 mm instead of 2-3 cm. I attach the mouthpiece to the neck before I attach neck to the sax body. Just to avoid to much bending.
 
But! It's a little slanted to the left.

Seems normal. The tenon requires a tight fit so it is wise not to put too much strain on it.
I take off the neck before positioning the mouthpiece.
So is it the mouthpiece that's that's slanted to the left or the neck that's slanted to the left?

If it's the mouthpiece then the cork is not fixed properly. If it's the neck then maybe the tenon may be too loose. But I agree should not have pressure put in it, either up/down or laterally.
 
Ah so the problem is the rotation.

I've never considered that but I would adjust it it once it is in your mouth. perhpas it is too tight in the cork making the that adjustment difficult.

Or you could find the correct position (in regard to the rotation) and make a mark on the cork and a corresponing mark on the mouthpiece. maybe put some tape on the shank so you can mark it without permanently affecting the mouthpiece.
 
I've never considered that but I would adjust it it once it is in your mouth. perhpas it is too tight in the cork making the that adjustment difficult.
Yeah, the annoying thing is that pushing the mouthpiece in or out isn't really that difficult since the cork isn't tight at all. Making big rotations, no problems either. But trying to make tiny little changes... the thing refuses to budge until past a certain "torque threshold", then it just shifts more than I want it to.

I guess marking the cork and mouthpiece, and then just straight up inserting the mouthpiece without rotation, works... but that's how I see a lot of people on Youtube do it (push and twist), but they somehow manage it fine.
 
The thing with Stick–slip is that once its moving you can move it smoothly where you want.
I think what I do is move it round and back/forward together rather than first one then the other. So, like put it on, twisting and sliding together to the right place. Too flat/sharp? Twist and pull it in/out - almost a looping S shape.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,376
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom