Playing the saxophone Accenting in a Slur

All great advice above and an interesting debate it seems. I guess the issue comes down to classical teaching methods for assessments but then offering alternate, non classical pieces.
My teachings have always been, if a group of notes are slurred (or legato'd) then the first note is tongued and the rest are not.
 
So ABRSM grade actually covers a musical phrase where, for example, 4 crotchets may all but slurred together, but also written as all staccato. Not something I have seen in written music before, and probably a nuanced classical thing, but it exists apparently.
Not a wind thing that’s for sure
 
All great advice above and an interesting debate it seems. I guess the issue comes down to classical teaching methods for assessments but then offering alternate, non classical pieces.
My teachings have always been, if a group of notes are slurred (or legato'd) then the first note is tongued and the rest are not.
Correct
 
My teachings have always been, if a group of notes are slurred (or legato'd) then the first note is tongued and the rest are not.
Mine too

So ABRSM grade actually covers a musical phrase where, for example, 4 crotchets may all but slurred together, but also written as all staccato
I believe this is portato which means staccato notes but played in one bow movement. Makes little sense outside of string music IMO.
 
The problem with jazz is that it's not amenable to standard notation. This is exacerbated by the fact that even in classical music there are areas (phrasing, slurs, articulation, ornaments) where notation is not standardized.

Without putting a horn in my hand I can't say exactly how I'd play that phrase, whether I would play it with a pure breath accent, or use a little tongue action.

Even the timing - in that measure, the "swung quavers" - the first two eighth notes I'd play more evenly, then the third one would get a little MORE length, then that accented dotted-quarter. Of course, if this were in a sax section, or with a lead trumpet playing the same thing, you'd follow the lead player.

Different bands would play that phrase differently. Different players, too. Consider Louis Armstrong, Chet Baker, Ben Webster, John Coltrane, Johnny Hodges, Arthur Blythe playing that phrase. Each one would phrase it differently. Ellington's sax section, Basie's sax section, Billy May's sax section, or Buddy Rich's sax section would phrase it differently. There IS no standard interpretation.

Once again, jazz is NOT a strictly notated music; you have to learn it like a language, learning how it should sound and then learning how arrangers and copyists typically represent that with the classical notation that was developed for different purposes.

In truth, classical music isn't fully represented by the dots and marks either, but it's closer.
 
Even the timing - in that measure, the "swung quavers" - the first two eighth notes I'd play more evenly, then the third one would get a little MORE length,
I understand what you mean but without a backing or musical context hard to say. A blues at that tempo could well have a 12/8 triplet feel in the rhythm section in which case so called “swung” notes would like have a strict triplet feel.

But if not then the “swing” feel is open to being varying length eighth notes based mostly on the player’s interpretation of how to make something gave the best swing feel. Abd there is a lot of leeway with slow tempos.
 
I believe this is portato which means staccato notes but played in one bow movement. Makes little sense outside of string music IMO.

So this is quite a frustrating aspect of the graded journey. At grade 5 theory, there has still been no mention of a saxophone - muddies the waters a little bit in terms of relevance.
 
So this is quite a frustrating aspect of the graded journey. At grade 5 theory, there has still been no mention of a saxophone - muddies the waters a little bit in terms of relevance.
I'm not sure how often the ABRSM theory book is re-written, and to what extent. Written notation/score writing has evolved/continues to evolve and, much like spoken language, things either get abbreviated or simplified over time.

Much has been written on this site, and doubtless others about how jazz education is stuck in its allegiance to Bebop language as a default, and I wonder just how stuck traditional theory is with regard to common practice these days.
 
One of my books has this:

Accents
The sign > means that the beginning of the note should be played louder. This is achieved by a slight 'kick' of the diaphragm, similar to what happens when you cough.
That's what we call a "breath accent". Creating the flow of constantly varying accents in a melodic line is achieved by interactions amongst breath, tongue, and voicing, as well as vibrato on longer notes. There are multiple ways to start a note, multiple ways to manage the sound once it's started (swell, diminish, terminal vibrato, etc.) and multiple ways to end a note.

You can't communicate this with some ink on a page. The best the ink can do is to remind you how you figured out it was supposed to sound.
 
This is achieved by a slight 'kick' of the diaphragm, similar to what happens when you cough.
Not a great analogy because a cough closes your throat. But I do understand where the are coming from because I suppose a cough may also involve the diaphragm. I always think the important part of an accent id the attack by combining loudness with tongue.
 
That's what we call a "breath accent". Creating the flow of constantly varying accents in a melodic line is achieved by interactions amongst breath, tongue, and voicing, as well as vibrato on longer notes. There are multiple ways to start a note, multiple ways to manage the sound once it's started (swell, diminish, terminal vibrato, etc.) and multiple ways to end a note.

You can't communicate this with some ink on a page. The best the ink can do is to remind you how you figured out it was supposed to sound.
This is in reference to a particular piece in the book which is a Jazz arrangement of Humoresque by Antonín Dvořák, there are audio tracks for accompaniment - I wouldn't want to breach copyright by posting written arrangement or audio.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom