- Messages
- 8,133
- Location
- Near Evesham, Worcestershire
OK, so you see a sax half it's value and quiz the seller why? He says "Hi, there are a lot of scratches on it and my daughter has stopped playing it. Yes, I can send it to you. I just need your address. You can pay via Paypal."
OK, no worries then. If it's a scam I can claim on PayPal buyer protection.
You log into PayPal, enter the seller's account name and it's verified.
You see this (example) screen:
You absent mindedly click on "Send money now" at the bottom of the screen (not shown) and you've lost £270.
What is missing is the prompt to change the transaction to "goods and services."
As an experienced PayPal user I was looking for this but was stumped by its absence.
You'd normally see the screen below. Note the blue "Change" to the right of "Sending to a friend or to family."
Clicking on "Change" brings up the normal transaction change screen, as under:
I phoned PayPal and spoke to a very experienced lady who repeated the transaction and she too couldn't get it to offer the change to goods and services. She'd never seen this before. Like me, she could bring up the "change" option with any other known payee, but not this one. I tested four other known accounts where I could change the transaction type.
So, you have a half price sax for sale, no option to buy with buyer protection, AND PayPal confirm the first name of the seller doesn't match their records. Assume it's a scam.
You message the seller: "The problem is that when paying your account there's no option to change from "friends and family" to "goods and services" in order to give buyer protection. Orla at PayPal has been there years and never seen this issue which she can repeat on her system also. If I try and pay anyone else I DO get the option for goods and services. This, coupled to the cheap price and the PayPal account not belonging to a XXXXX makes me question the transaction. If you are genuine I suggest you call PayPal, sort out the issue, and get back to me later today so I can try again. Regards, David."
Seller replies: "Okay."
Two days ago I reported a similar ad, same sax, same price, different seller, different location to Gumtree as it was obviously a scam. That seller also said "This is my daughter's saxophone, she didn't use it much." They removed the ad. That seller had been a Gumtree member for 9 years.
So had this one. 9 years gives a buyer confidence as opposed to one month. So how do scammers immediately get 9 years shown when first posting on Gumtree? I've reported this ad to Gumtree and asked that question.
OK, no worries then. If it's a scam I can claim on PayPal buyer protection.
You log into PayPal, enter the seller's account name and it's verified.
You see this (example) screen:
You absent mindedly click on "Send money now" at the bottom of the screen (not shown) and you've lost £270.
What is missing is the prompt to change the transaction to "goods and services."
As an experienced PayPal user I was looking for this but was stumped by its absence.
You'd normally see the screen below. Note the blue "Change" to the right of "Sending to a friend or to family."
Clicking on "Change" brings up the normal transaction change screen, as under:
I phoned PayPal and spoke to a very experienced lady who repeated the transaction and she too couldn't get it to offer the change to goods and services. She'd never seen this before. Like me, she could bring up the "change" option with any other known payee, but not this one. I tested four other known accounts where I could change the transaction type.
So, you have a half price sax for sale, no option to buy with buyer protection, AND PayPal confirm the first name of the seller doesn't match their records. Assume it's a scam.
You message the seller: "The problem is that when paying your account there's no option to change from "friends and family" to "goods and services" in order to give buyer protection. Orla at PayPal has been there years and never seen this issue which she can repeat on her system also. If I try and pay anyone else I DO get the option for goods and services. This, coupled to the cheap price and the PayPal account not belonging to a XXXXX makes me question the transaction. If you are genuine I suggest you call PayPal, sort out the issue, and get back to me later today so I can try again. Regards, David."
Seller replies: "Okay."
Two days ago I reported a similar ad, same sax, same price, different seller, different location to Gumtree as it was obviously a scam. That seller also said "This is my daughter's saxophone, she didn't use it much." They removed the ad. That seller had been a Gumtree member for 9 years.
So had this one. 9 years gives a buyer confidence as opposed to one month. So how do scammers immediately get 9 years shown when first posting on Gumtree? I've reported this ad to Gumtree and asked that question.
Last edited:

