A logic express/logic question

crazydaisydoo

Member
Messages
39
Hi,

I have just explained my recording set up in the soundclip thread, and also a limitation

"I might upgrade to logic express or full logic soon, as garageband is a little limited. (on backing tracks I cannot import one mono track at a time from a CD, for exampe aebersolds have split bass/piano L+R, and I cannot switch off the piano and bring the bass to centre, which I could on my zoom multitrack, it treated stereo tracks as two controllable mono tracks) "

Does anyone know if this is possible in Logic Express or just full Logic?

My zoom multitracker would treat each "half" of the imported stereo backing track as seperate tracks, with panning and eq for each half.

Basically, this meant I could just run the bass part of an aebersold, but panned centre.

The only way to do this in garageband is to pan the stereo track left, and therefore the bass is only coming fro one side (hmmm not great)

Any ideas?

I suppose I could do some kind of workaround, pan left, export it as n mp3, re-import as one track, do the same with the piano, but that would be a royal pain.....
 
Hi,

I've just tried this for you in Logic 8 with an Aebersold track. Pete's suggestion is equally valid but this is perhaps a little easier to setup:

1. Import your track to a stereo channel. Pan it to the Left so only the bass and drums are playing.
2. On your output (Master) channel insert the 'Gain' plugin from the 'Utility' folder. On this you will find a Mono switch, which will bring the Left hand channel to the centre. It's that simple!
3. Save the setup as an "Autoload" so the Gain plugin is always setup ready to go. You could even save a project with all your Aebersold tracks already loaded and just flick through them with Solo selected. Straight into instant practice without any hassle.

Hey presto you're done....I'm just loading up GarageBand to see what's available there. I never use it so bear with me....zzzz......

Okay two solutions which might save your wallet for a little longer.

Solution A for Garageband:
1. Download and install these freeware plugins from MDA.
2. You will find a Stereo Simulator in the plugin pack which you just need to apply to the Master Output track in Garageband. You don't even need to make any settings - the sound will immediately become centred.

Solution B for Garageband:
1. Well it's more a question really. How are you listening to the audio output from your Mac? Is it straight through headphones or via an audio card into a Hi-Fi or such? If it's the latter and you have a balance control on the Hi-Fi, you should be able to simply use that.

I know that sounds like I'm assuming you don't know what you are doing but I know from painful experience that these simplest of things can often be overlooked. :blush:

Hopefully, you will find a solution there that works for you.

Good luck!
 
Thanks Pete and Colin,

Colin, great tip on the plug-in, I'll try that first. It is for mastering, so the balance idea doesn't solve anything.

Here is an example I did a while ago using just the aebersold bass:

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=ty7NyePdWTM

Garageband is all I need, it is surprisingly good, and lets me concentrate on playing, especially as my music time is limited.

Thanks again
 
Actually you don't even need to put the gain plugin on the output, just click on the stereo symbol to make it mono.



mono.webp



My original suggestion involved doing the same thing but sending the output of your Aebersold track channelstrip to a bus and then monoising that bus in a similar way, which would keep the main output stereo in case you wanted that.

NB. The Dirmixer plugin is very useful./ You can actually pan the stereo, instead of just balancing left and right which is what the so-called "pan" control does on stereo tracks.
 
Last edited:
Hi Pete,

Questions....

I only switched from Cubase to Logic not so long ago, so I'm still playing catch up.

When I tried switching the main output to mono it didn't appear to work (for playback/monitoring at least), that's why I didn't suggest it. It's bizarre really, as it obviously should make everything arrive dead centre but I still get anything that's panned left coming out of the left speaker and as there is no pan/balance control on the output bus the only way seemed to be to add a plug-in. Why would this be?

I had similar problem the other day too, as I was creating a live backing track for a function band ("New York, New York") and they needed a mono mix so that the drummer could use the other channel for his cilck track. I got around it in the end but again when I switched the main out to mono I still had some degree of stereo information going on - I could verify this by hitting the Mono button on my mixer to A/B it.

I couldn't find a way to Bounce to a mono file either (at the time) but playing around now I realise that you need to hit the Bounce button on the Output channel strip, rather than the one on the toolbar.

That's Logic!

C :?
 
Ahh....got it!

For anyone that's still interested....In Logic if you set the playback channel itself (with the Aebersold track) to mono and then click and hold on the Mono/Stereo button (the circle at the bottom of the Channel Strip in Pete's lovely screenshots), you can select whether a stereo file plays the Left side only, Right side only, or a mono mix of both sides. This will also send the signal straight down the middle provided you don't touch the Pan control.

Still confused as to monitoring a stereo mix in Mono though?!? I always just do this via the mixer but it would be useful to know.
 
Thanks you guys... top stuff.

This why I need Logic......... one day. I guess I am actually more advanced than I thought I was, garageband has some limitations if you are coming off a decent hardware multitrack set-up.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,429
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom