Reeds A little tip on reed care.

Reference, please
I have never seen a written text on this subject, but you can try this experiment.

During a lecture in Diest (Belgium) around 2010, Francois Louis told the story that there was a substance in reeds that came out visibly when you brushed the reed in a stream of hand warm water. The material itself was slightly colored and a bit sticky. After such a treatment he described the sound of the reed to become lifeless.

He didn't know the chemical name of this substance but I assumed that it was lignin by its solubility and amount present in reeds. It works as a glue that keeps the fibers together so when you remove it the material becomes more brittle and loses elasticity. Alcohol is one of the best solvents for lignin.
 
It used to be an effective laxative
Many years ago when I was in my early teens I worked in the local newsagents and one Sunday morning a man came in and although the shop was empty leaned over the counter and asked 'sotto voce' did we have any liquid paraffin.
Being rather naive in such matters I said 'no but the garage over the road has a machine which sells it for 2/6 a gallon'.
After he left rather hastily the boss who had overheard explained it to me.
 
Very late to this party and - as an amateur - I'm nowhere near in the same 'reed' league as previous posters. Somewhere along the line (via the cafe), I learned that:
- it was good practice to 'work in' and 'grade' reeds in any box and to adjust different reeds where appropriate and where possible.
- it was good practicice to rotate reeds

I've read tales of dipping reeds into Vodka, Alcohol (or some other substance) to prolong their life and vibrance. TBH (as an amateur) I really don't have time for this. Recently my reeds have - for some reason - become chipped or split within a few weeks of playing. So I now plan on replacing a reed every 2-3 weeks.

No 'out of the box' new reed is perfect. But IMHO sax players need to be able to play with 'less than perfect' reeds. Depending on the 'out the box' reed I play, I do moisten the reed and mpc. I also conciously adust both the reed position on the mpc and the ligature position on the mpc to make the reed as 'playable' (and vibrant) as possible.

Bottom line: yes, you can prolong the life and vibrancy of your selected (favourite?) reeds. Always worth doing! But getting used to playing with new, 'out of the box' reeds could perhaps be useful too.

In my case, it's (become) essential. I've also read that some professional sax players use new reeds for every performance.
 
Thank you

A technical paper that does not support the quasi-scientific breadcrumb trail of factoids which starts with, 'soaking reeds in alcohol is bad for the reed' and ends with, 'because the alcohol dissolves lignin'

The paper shows lignin is poorly soluble in ethanol and insoluble in water. So if you dilute alcohol in water to, say the 40 percent ABV of Jack Daniels, you further reduce the lignin solubility. So drinking spirits are very poor lignin solvents. Also the paper describes experiments on pure lignin extracted from pulped wood, not on lignin still bound into the complex structure of the original material (in this case, cane) where a solvent would be even less effective
 
The fractionation of lignin using ethanol-water solvents was investigated. It was found that the maximum solubility was achieved at 60 wt% ethanol. The lowest average molar masses were achieved in the soluble fraction when either pure water or absolute ethanol was utilized.31 jan 2019
 
You can always give synthetic a go - I'd recommend trying Legere American Cut say 1.5 or 1.75- they have an exchange program if you find that you've bought a strength that doesn't suit you.

For someone just starting out synthetics take away a lot of variables and bring consistency and you just put them on the mouthpiece and play - no faffing required!
I think maybe the strength required depends on mouthpiece characteristics btw. Tip opening/curve/resistance etc.
Incidentally this might be of interest... On tenor sax, I have a strength 2 Legere American Cut on a Lawton 7*B mouthpiece, and I found that it was initially slightly too hard (I normally use Java 2.5 green box). However, I was surprised to find that after a total of about 20 hours blowing over the course of a week, it took on a slight curve from which it doesn't recover. This has reduced the effective strength to (I suppose) around their 1.75, so the next one that I buy will be a 2.25. The Legere 2 is still great to practice on and use in a restrained live situation, but where the band volume is louder, it does close up somewhat in the higher range.
 
I think maybe the strength required depends on mouthpiece characteristics btw. Tip opening/curve/resistance etc.
Incidentally this might be of interest... On tenor sax, I have a strength 2 Legere American Cut on a Lawton 7*B mouthpiece, and I found that it was initially slightly too hard (I normally use Java 2.5 green box). However, I was surprised to find that after a total of about 20 hours blowing over the course of a week, it took on a slight curve from which it doesn't recover. This has reduced the effective strength to (I suppose) around their 1.75, so the next one that I buy will be a 2.25. The Legere 2 is still great to practice on and use in a restrained live situation, but where the band volume is louder, it does close up somewhat in the higher range.
I think that's already taken into account. OP plays a #2 cane reed, so 1.75 Legere was the suggested match, which I agree with.

However, unless you're an absolute beginner, I urge anybody still playing a #2 on anything besides a massively open piece to work on embouchure strength and breath support. Such a soft reed is easy to play, but your high end tone and intonation will suffer in the long run.
 
The inimitable YouTube threw this old vid up, probably because of earspasms Vandoran reed review.

On topic, i guess.

Everything is up for interpretation; but you could see this as "no big problem"

View: https://youtu.be/TyEnX2Afga0
Keep your mouthpiece clean and dry. Clean/wash it after you've been playing. When it comes to bacteria metal mouthpieces is much better. Dry and polish your mouthpieces. A smooth and even surface prevent things to grow on/in your mouthpiece. It's not just the outside of the mouthpiece, the chamber and the bore should be smooth and even as well. Mouthpiece cushions is hard to clean. So replace them often. And yes, it's just me that are playing my mouthpieces and reeds.

Dry and clean your reeds after you've been playing and store them in an "airy place". Don't store them in your saxophone case. You can clean and take care of your reeds in many ways. First it's just to get rid of the moisture and other stuff that can be on the reed outside of the reed.
 
Last edited:
While storing reeds outside your instrument case is ideal, it’s not really practical for people who play every day. Of the thousands of musicians I’ve interacted with over the years, I don’t recall a single one that does that.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,578
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom