Reeds A little tip on reed care.

Hmm...What's a long time? 2 or 3 years doesn't seem to be a problem. How do you detect a reduction in elasticity? As far as I can tell the old reeds are much the same as new ones. They'll take me up to G4 on a tenor and react properly to all I try to do. Anyway, I am a sample size of 1 and I realise some folk are more sensitive to these things.
Sorry for being nosy are you the same Nick W running the marathon to support refugees?
 
Hmm...What's a long time? 2 or 3 years doesn't seem to be a problem.
If you keep your reeds a few years in alcohol at room temperature they will sound very dry and lifeless. Keeping a reed for the same time in a dry storage doesn't affect the sound much. Last week I played on a reed from 1950. It was ok.
 
Always willing to take advice but on this particular discussion there is no clear path some remove their reeds after each session, clean them and store them in a case. Others leave them on the MP till they rot whilst still others give the reeds a wipe over with alcohol or leave the reed in a tub of Vodka until the next session. i really can't be dealing with Vodka, no offence to the Vodka drinkers. My favourite form of Alcohol is Jack Daniels so thought I'd give it a try. if anybody wants to take my advice it would be not to! JD is best left in its tumbler. :thumb:
I disagree. There is a very clear path. The fact that some (not most) choose not to follow it is inconsequential, and in fact is a testament to both stubbornness and idiocy.

Over the years I have played next to several hundred saxophonists, in various ensembles, jam sessions, street corners and schools. The majority of them a) keep their reeds in reed cases b) do not leave the reeds on the mouthpiece c) rotate their reeds; that is, they play a different reed or reeds every day.

Some do keep reeds in listerine or vodka, some use humidity packs, I knew one guy that soaked his reed (singular, he only used one at a time) in instant coffee every day; he thought the coffee particles helped seal and preserve the reed. I myself have tried the humidity pack approach and abandoned it after several months because of mold. I think of this time as a side trip from the main path.

Follow the main path. It is the road to true happiness!!! Once you have worn a groove in it, take any side trips as you see fit, but my experience is that most people return to the main path.
 
I aprove of the iItalian aproach to the starbucks in Rome, but I didn't know the word coifeca.
To stay on the subject, it is not impossible that the man who used coffee to seal his reeds has a point .
Personally I think that shellac on reeds is a better seal than starbucks espresso.
It also smells better.
 
Well coffee aside.
TLDR; I'm learning Nay - a reed flute, edge blown so no mouthpiece at all and it gets pretty soggy at the top. Regular treatment is essential both to avoid drying & cracking; and to suppress mold and fungus. There are as many opinions about this as sax reed treatment. I've used both almond oil and parafin oil. I'm more confident in the latter. So I'm wondering...

... Why not almond or parafin oil treatment for sax reeds? Maybe I'll sacrifice a reed to experiment... Or just stick to the mainstream which works.
 
Well coffee aside.
TLDR; I'm learning Nay - a reed flute, edge blown so no mouthpiece at all and it gets pretty soggy at the top. Regular treatment is essential both to avoid drying & cracking; and to suppress mold and fungus. There are as many opinions about this as sax reed treatment. I've used both almond oil and parafin oil. I'm more confident in the latter. So I'm wondering...

... Why not almond or parafin oil treatment for sax reeds? Maybe I'll sacrifice a reed to experiment... Or just stick to the mainstream which works.

I'd be mindful of any potential reactions with hard rubber mouthpieces and neck cork etc. It may be fine but would procede with caution.

Also you're putting the reed in your mouth so will ingest some of whatever you apply to it. I don't think paraffin is particularly toxic but still something to think about.
 
I'd be mindful of any potential reactions with hard rubber mouthpieces and neck cork etc. It may be fine but would procede with caution.

Also you're putting the reed in your mouth so will ingest some of whatever you apply to it. I don't think paraffin is particularly toxic but still something to think about.
The paraffin oil I use on the flutes says Food Safe - and easy to use, which is nice - as the flute rests on the lips.
I'm not that fussed, really... Just following the logic of the thread
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,578
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom