Reeds A little tip on reed care.

I went mad today and opened a new box of tenor reeds (Jazz Select 2M). I compared a new one with one that’s been soaking in vodka for at least two years and played now and again. Very little diffence really. The new required a bit more control than the old one which behaved impeccably. They both sailed up to G4 without whinging. I won’t bother to start any more new ones.
 
Then there's that moment, when, dissatisfied with your sound, and being convinced it's the mouthpiece, you find an opened box of reeds that you rejected months, maybe years ago, to find joy, pleasure and relief that no new mouthpiece is needed,
deleting browsing history and playing with renewed inspiration and wonderment.

Again. Doh!:rolleyes:
 
I must admit the tub idea is not really working out. Having read through some posts on here this morning about chest infections, (I've had a bit of a cough and a rattle since starting to play) storing reeds in a JD soaked sponge may not be the best idea after all! I've put one 2.0 out to dry before today's practice and one still in the juice. I'll see if anything makes any difference but TBH I'm only a few weeks in on this journey and with so many other issues to keep an eye on maybe reed condition is a mute subject for me. At my first lesson last week my teacher suggested going back up to a 2.0 from a 1.5 as it would help build up my breath and strengthen my embouchure quicker and not to worry the impact if had on high and low ranges as it was still early days for that part of the instrument.
You can always give synthetic a go - I'd recommend trying Legere American Cut say 1.5 or 1.75- they have an exchange program if you find that you've bought a strength that doesn't suit you.

For someone just starting out synthetics take away a lot of variables and bring consistency and you just put them on the mouthpiece and play - no faffing required!
 
Some interesting news regarding Jack Daniels and a soak tub. I took all the reeds out of the Jack Daniels a week ago and those that I do not use (1.5 and 2.5) I left in their plastic protective sleeves out in the open to dry out. I tried the 1.5 a couple of days ago and could not get it to play at all where as just a couple of weeks back it was my favourite reed. I don't think it's my ability by any score. I think it could possibly be the sugar or other additives in the Jack Daniels that has crystallised in reed. No matter what i tried I could barely get a note out of it and when at last I could it was only in the middle range and sounded awful. I think I've killed a few reeds off. wonder if anybody else has suffered a similar experience. settling happily into my Rico Royals 2.0
 
Some interesting news regarding Jack Daniels and a soak tub. I took all the reeds out of the Jack Daniels a week ago and those that I do not use (1.5 and 2.5) I left in their plastic protective sleeves out in the open to dry out. I tried the 1.5 a couple of days ago and could not get it to play at all where as just a couple of weeks back it was my favourite reed. I don't think it's my ability by any score. I think it could possibly be the sugar or other additives in the Jack Daniels that has crystallised in reed. No matter what i tried I could barely get a note out of it and when at last I could it was only in the middle range and sounded awful. I think I've killed a few reeds off. wonder if anybody else has suffered a similar experience. settling happily into my Rico Royals 2.0
Use vodka. You know it makes sense. 🙂
 
Some interesting news regarding Jack Daniels and a soak tub. I took all the reeds out of the Jack Daniels a week ago and those that I do not use (1.5 and 2.5) I left in their plastic protective sleeves out in the open to dry out. I tried the 1.5 a couple of days ago and could not get it to play at all where as just a couple of weeks back it was my favourite reed. I don't think it's my ability by any score. I think it could possibly be the sugar or other additives in the Jack Daniels that has crystallised in reed. No matter what i tried I could barely get a note out of it and when at last I could it was only in the middle range and sounded awful. I think I've killed a few reeds off. wonder if anybody else has suffered a similar experience. settling happily into my Rico Royals 2.0

Letting the reeds dry without constraint usually results in warping. That’s where reed cases work to preserve flatness and prevent warping.
 
Letting the reeds dry without constraint usually results in warping. That’s where reed cases work to preserve flatness and prevent warping.
They were in their cases so warping wasn't an issue I tested both the 1.5's I have that were both in the "brew", both flat with no sign of damage they just wouldn't blow!
 
Letting the reeds dry without constraint usually results in warping. That’s where reed cases work to preserve flatness and prevent warping.
This is true but I find as soon as you wet them they go crinkly as an opposed to warped. But then after a little while they settle down to being flat. Maybe it’s just me.
 
They were in their cases so warping wasn't an issue I tested both the 1.5's I have that were both in the "brew", both flat with no sign of damage they just wouldn't blow!
The holders reeds come packaged in are too soft to keep them from warping. The Dr was talking about an actual flat, rigid reed case.

It’s great that you like to experiment, but the years of experience behind our advice can save you a lot of time and money if you’re willing to follow it. Your current path is doing more harm than good.
 
I don't noticed any warping, just crinkly then flat. Of course there may always be a bit of a bend due to facing curve, but that is all part of life's rich pageant.
I think crinkling happens because the very end of the reed is thinner and can expand a bit. Not all cells react to moisture at the same rate so some swell quicker than others. All settle down within a minute or so.
 
Some interesting news regarding Jack Daniels and a soak tub.
Reeds get a part of their rigidity from lignin, a sort of glue that keeps the fibers together. A new reed contains up to 20% of lignin. Soaking in alcohol for a long time dissolves the lignin and the reed becomes less elastic. Cleaning with alcohol is ok, soaking has the risk to lose too much lignin.
 
The holders reeds come packaged in are too soft to keep them from warping. The Dr was talking about an actual flat, rigid reed case.

It’s great that you like to experiment, but the years of experience behind our advice can save you a lot of time and money if you’re willing to follow it. Your current path is doing more harm than good.
Always willing to take advice but on this particular discussion there is no clear path some remove their reeds after each session, clean them and store them in a case. Others leave them on the MP till they rot whilst still others give the reeds a wipe over with alcohol or leave the reed in a tub of Vodka until the next session. i really can't be dealing with Vodka, no offence to the Vodka drinkers. My favourite form of Alcohol is Jack Daniels so thought I'd give it a try. if anybody wants to take my advice it would be not to! JD is best left in its tumbler. :thumb:
 
Reeds get a part of their rigidity from lignin, a sort of glue that keeps the fibers together. A new reed contains up to 20% of lignin. Soaking in alcohol for a long time dissolves the lignin and the reed becomes less elastic. Cleaning with alcohol is ok, soaking has the risk to lose too much lignin.
Hmm...What's a long time? 2 or 3 years doesn't seem to be a problem. How do you detect a reduction in elasticity? As far as I can tell the old reeds are much the same as new ones. They'll take me up to G4 on a tenor and react properly to all I try to do. Anyway, I am a sample size of 1 and I realise some folk are more sensitive to these things.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,578
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom