Saxophones A Beast of a Tenor Saxophone

I'd like to know how the hammered effect was realised and at what stage of the manufacturing process. My guess is that adds a lot to the cost and is purely decorative.

If it's made in China, then a hand hammering process is cheap because labour is cheap. I think it was Martin Walker (of bauhaus fame) who first mentioned to me after a visit to China he was impressed by everything being hand made. The factory owner explained that hand making is cheaper than robot or CNC machinery as used a lot in Japan.

I would imagine hand hammering a bell could be done before or after forming - but if before you'd need to deal with the seam. I can't imagine it would take more than an hour to do a bell, so in China it may add about $25 to the process. (But obviously a lot more to the end consumer..

That hammer look. It reminds me of those hammered copper, coffee muggs. Seen those?
You see lots of decorative kettles, but also round pub tables done like that.
 
The real question is what would be the masses opinion if Selmer or Yamaha had released it ,
Remember when Jody jazz released its hand hammered mpc and a lot of people wanted one !
Fair play to him he has a idea of what saxophone he wants and makes him want to play it more
We all have dreams of finding the ultimate saxophone so good on him following his dream
Remember it’s easy to criticise and put someone down , something that social media is very good at !
 
I'm a little confused, what exactly did he "design"? The hammered pattern? That's not a design, that's an embellishment. He talks about how the keys are "snapping" in his design, am I missing something or were they hammered in place after padding?

I used to be a blacksmith by trade and the idea of a few guys sitting there, dinging some dimples into a sheet of brass and calling it a "design" curls up my toe nails. If it had been a Zildjian cymbal or gong that was transformed into the bow and bell I would start paying attention but this coolaid thing .... pardon my jadedness
 
I'm a little confused, what exactly did he "design"? The hammered pattern? That's not a design, that's an embellishment. He talks about how the keys are "snapping" in his design, am I missing something or were they hammered in place after padding?

I used to be a blacksmith by trade and the idea of a few guys sitting there, dinging some dimples into a sheet of brass and calling it a "design" curls up my toe nails. If it had been a Zildjian cymbal or gong that was transformed into the bow and bell I would start paying attention but this coolaid thing .... pardon my jadedness

I don't know the answer but I would guess that the "design" choices made by the Ian T. will have included such things as:
  • Materials and finish for neck, main tube, bow and bell (a mixture of standard and quite unusual)
  • Finish for keywork (looks standard)
  • Style of some functional items such as thumb hook, strap ring, neck octave key, bell support ring, pearls (a mixture of fairly standard and some bespoke)
  • Branding on the bell, body and neck (seems to be not engraved but does have plates added with a specific "Beast" logo / name)
I would imagine that the bore design, action, case, pads etc. are pretty standard from a given manufacturer, but possibly there would have been options to choose from.

So in summary, the "design" is largely about choosing a mixture of options in discussion with the manufacturer and getting the bespoke finish he wanted and some specific branding added.

Rhys
 
Last edited:
I rather suspect that when someone orders / commissions a classy custom instrument - for good ¥€$ - who ever is on the profitable end will ensure that everything is 110%; whatever horn its based on. Good rep and future sales depends on it... And whatever is under the custom finish is probably top notch to begin with - who'd spend cash like that on a G4M, £300 horn?!

If so, i should think everything is well set-up - as if it had left the workbench of a top tech - nothing to do with the custom designs, as such.
 
Last edited:
I don't know the answer but I would guess that the "design" choices made by the Ian T. will have included such things as:
  • Materials and finish for neck, main tube, bow and bell (a mixture of standard and quite unusual)
  • Finish for keywork (looks standard)
  • Style of some functional items such as thumb hook, strap ring, neck octave key, bell support ring, pearls (a mixture of fairly standard and some bespoke)
  • Branding on the bell, body and neck (seems to be not engraved but does have plates added with a specific "Beast" logo / name)
I would imagine that the bore design, action, case etc. are pretty standard from a given manufacturer, but possibly there would have been options to choose from.

So in summary, the "design" is largely about choosing a mixture of options in discussion with the manufacturer and getting the bespoke finish he wanted and some specific branding added.

Rhys

I get it, it's mostly cosmetic, or like in the fast-food industry the "build your own burger"
#1: burger with salt
#2: burger with Himalayan pink salt
#3: burger with Hawaiian black lava salt
#1a: burger with salt and pepper
....

A friend of mine designed his own Yamaha Custom, having it top to bottom encrusted with faux diamonds. he was so proud of it but in the 7 years since he showed it to me first I have never seen him play it again on any gig

Presumably the design is the combination of different things. Like an interior designer might specify two different paint colors without actually having to design the paint.

Oh tempo'a oh mo'es said the Nubian pirate in Asterix

Sorry, I am actually laughing my ass off about these follies but by the end of the day, whatever works ....
 
Er, OK.

I just thought that it was a very different look and was interested to hear what other saxophonists think.

BTW Ian Trewhella is a good player and an enthusiast for all things saxophone rather than some dodgy salesman. I don't have any commercial or other relationship with him.

Rhys
Agree. I've been following Ian since his very early days with his purple logo 62 tenor. He's great to see live!
 
I didn't realise I designed my Mercedes.
Chose the colour and optional extras and had it 'de-badged'.

If only you had got Mercedes to add a few plates on the outside with your name and personal logo, then you would have really been designing.

Would you like me to come round and hand hammer selected bits of the bodywork for a truly bespoke look ?

My Ford has been personalised with gaffer tape that holds on the front bumper. When we met up with some friends last year, they went looking for my car in the agreed car park but didn't find it - they had seen my car but thought the tape looked too new, because I had recently replaced it.

Rhys
 
Last edited:
The thing I was wondering about the most was "how does it sound?"
If he likes the way it looks, or the way it plays, thats good. But for me, in the end the sound is the most important in choosing a saxophone.
 
Ian Trewhella seems to be a player that's doing his thing and he developed his own sound with his sax and equipment. I saw on another video that he was using something like a Klangbogen. Maybe a Mass friend as well?
 
The thing I was wondering about the most was "how does it sound?"
If he likes the way it looks, or the way it plays, thats good. But for me, in the end the sound is the most important in choosing a saxophone.
Ian sounds like Ian.
I saw another video once where he re-added an early MKVI. Did the snappy popping of the pads closing thing again which did sound quite huge in resonance in its self.
Then out came Ian when he played it.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,509
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom