Tech/maintenance 10M strap ring repositioning

Comparison with my Buescher (left) which is from same time (early 50s). Ergonomically very similar to the 10M other than the strap ring which quite different, making it much more comfortable to play.
 

Attachments

  • 99043C8F-8A13-4FC3-A860-C7BD387F2B13.webp
    99043C8F-8A13-4FC3-A860-C7BD387F2B13.webp
    32.4 KB · : 188
  • 72AD182A-32F4-4978-8BE9-111ED72C4961.webp
    72AD182A-32F4-4978-8BE9-111ED72C4961.webp
    39.1 KB · : 106
I'm not an expert on Conn Artist saxes. But I believe that changes on saxes were made when the music industry changed. Sitting or standing? With the smaller jazz combos and R&B bands the music industry changed. I'm tolerant when it comes to strap rings -, keys/keytouches - placement but when it comes to mouthpieces and necks I'm more picky.

I compared to Martin Committee tenors. A Martin Handcraft -38 and a "The Martin Magna" -59. They are different when it comes to ergonomics. The Magna suits me better. But the HC is a little bit better built.

The strap ring on the HC is c 31,5 cm from the neck joint. The strapping on the Magna is c 33,5 cm from the top. So two cm!
IMG_4892.JPG

The necks changed as well. Different angles. More compact on the HC? The HC is better playing sitting.
IMG_4888.JPG

We shall keep in mind that Conn more or less through in the towel , so did Buescher as well, in the 50's. From top saxes to more student saxes even if they made Artist sax line to mid 60's. The music industry changed!!
 
Last edited:
Well, the truth is that YOU DON'T KNOW why Conn located the strap ring where they did. For that matter, Selmer King Buescher Martin and Buffet were all selling and designing saxophones for the same markets. Why did they locate their strap rings differently? Again, the only accurate answer is WE DON'T KNOW. Just as many people were standing, or sitting, playing Selmers or Kings as Conns.

But the idea that sitting and standing somehow require drastically different strap ring positions is simply demonstrably false by observing the multitudes of players from the earliest days of filmed performances till now, who make no adjustment from when they're sitting to when they're standing. And therefore the likelihood that the designers at Conn, one of the most innovative saxophone manufacturers, would have believed something (that you need a different strap ring location when you're sitting than when you're standing) that their own experience would have told them simply wasn't true, and would have designed the horn accordingly, is vanishingly small.

There was SOME reason why they located the strap ring where it is. If I had to GUESS I would GUESS that it's because the closer the horn hangs to playing orientation, the less force is required by the right thumb to bring it up into playing position. Less force on the non-operating fingers reduces the chance of excessive gripping on the operating fingers. (Try to clamp hard on something with your thumb and then wiggle your other fingers without tension in them. Not so easy.) This would be a basis for the strap ring position that would have been based on actual reality. I don't know that this IS the reason, but it makes more sense than the made-up "playing while sitting/playing while standing" rationale.

And for that matter, how do you explain outfits like the Sousa band, who at one time were an all-Conn organization, and who played sitting OR standing, way back in the teens and twenties?
 
My HC Committee is better to play sitting compared to the Magna. It's not only the neck strap ring .... even the shape/design of the neck, palm keys the changed. Maybe they did changes without knowing what they did?
 
Last edited:
Great entertaining thread so thank you for this. I have an old Conn tenor and a C melody Wurlitzer from a similar period (1930's) and both have the ring placed higher than a "modern" sax with the result that they swing in. I've been considering adapting them to make it feel more "natural" for me so appreciate the discussion here. Thanks again
 
Great entertaining thread so thank you for this. I have an old Conn tenor and a C melody Wurlitzer from a similar period (1930's) and both have the ring placed higher than a "modern" sax with the result that they swing in. I've been considering adapting them to make it feel more "natural" for me so appreciate the discussion here. Thanks again
Exactly!πŸ₯΄
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,502
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom