Saxophones £850 for Selmer Supreme Super Pads?

But not as long as those on my Conn 10M . The whole set is still going strong after 35 years. The hand written name on every pad probably makes them the most valuable set of (old) pads in the world. I'm sure adds £850+ to the value of the horn.

He was a cantankerous old devil, but did amazing work. RIP Freddie.
I often work on horns that were fitted with Gordon Beeson pads back in the '60s...with many of them still going strong.
 
It seems as though these new Selmers really do need a full overhaul/repad to play their best according to Getasax (US dealer) discussing the Supreme.
 
Last edited:
It seems as though these new Selmers really do need a full overhaul/repad to play their best according to this experienced/knowledgable US dealer discussing the Supreme:

There exists a great difference between replacing pads and a full overhaul. Did Getasax comment about refacing tubes and resetting posts, or having to swage keys? I do wonder what Getasax thinks about the current pivot configuration.
 
I’ve spoken to a couple of guys who have/had the supreme and they all said they wish they kept their ref 54 , but again this is all down to their personal preference
 
I’ve spoken to a couple of guys who have/had the supreme and they all said they wish they kept their ref 54 , but again this is all down to their personal preference
You have to wonder why they buy it in the first place, presumably they bought it (without trying) on a gamble that it might be better than their ref 54. But then after buying it and finding out it isn't, whey would they then sell the Ref 54, ie the one they prefer
 
I bought
You have to wonder why they buy it in the first place, presumably they bought it (without trying) on a gamble that it might be better than their ref 54. But then after buying it and finding out it isn't, whey would they then sell the Ref 54, ie the one they prefer
I bought my MkVI tenor in 1979 (for £450) from a professional who had just upgraded to a Mk7.

Rhys
 
Is it because we believe the newer model is better and we give in to the hype perhaps
I myself have done it in the past , but I did change from a Yani A880 to aA992 which was bronze , now I’m lucky enough to have both in my collection , although I play my mkvi mostly
 
You have to wonder why they buy it in the first place, presumably they bought it (without trying) on a gamble that it might be better than their ref 54. But then after buying it and finding out it isn't, whey would they then sell the Ref 54, ie the one they prefer
I'm not sure how good a player the Supreme seller, Andy Scott, is but his credentials are good: Andy Scott: saxophonist composer educator

I'd have thought a pro player would have taken whatever his favourite horn was along to try them side by side, or if bought mail order, sent the Supreme back if not the better sax?

Could be a financial thing. That's a lot of money tied up in a horn whereas he may have one not quite so good, e.g. a Ref 54, which will only bring in £3,000. Or he's tried both for longer and found he prefers the 54 (or whatever), or he's mainly a tenor player, was given the Supreme by Selmer, and has no real use for it? Or a bit of everything!!
 
Is it because we believe the newer model is better and we give in to the hype perhaps
I myself have done it in the past , but I did change from a Yani A880 to aA992 which was bronze , now I’m lucky enough to have both in my collection , although I play my mkvi mostly
True, it can sometimes take some time to realise whether or not you prefer something - but still seems like getting rid of the Ref is bit like burning your bridges.
 
… or got drawn by the hype into paying for the SuperPads, only to find that he didn’t like them, and would rather cash out than pay another pile of money to remove the SuperPads.

Projecting here: I did much the same thing with a King Super 20 alto many years ago. My tech wanted to put in some black Roo pads, and I let him. The horn was terrible afterwards, so I sold it, and never used that tech again.
 
I bought a King Zephyr Special that came already fitted with black roos, I wouldn't have chosen them because when they wear out I've got to find somebody with black roos to hand, but they play well, I think the tech was the problem not the pads.
 
I bought a King Zephyr Special that came already fitted with black roos, I wouldn't have chosen them because when they wear out I've got to find somebody with black roos to hand, but they play well, I think the tech was the problem not the pads.
Tech and pads were the problem - as I wrote, I never went back to him.

He could never get all the leaks out, and when I could play it, I hated the loud slap of the pad on the tonehole, as well as the feel. Never again. Thank you, no.
 
Slightly odd review from Wally Wallace. He talks about Selmer saxes having somewhat variable build quality out of the factory, but also refers to his own Selmer Mk VI. Selmers have had a reputation for variable quality going back to at least the time of the Mk VI (I've never played a Selmer of the pre-Mk VI generations).
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,646
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom