Saxophones Yas 62 G neck on a YAS 32

yeah i think if the g1 neck is any good for you you’ll have a good deal.

I think I might try the newer custom necks at some point (probably on tenor first) as I really don’t get on with the G1 necks still!

I dislike how difficult it is to get a classical sound out of my Custom Z even with a really small mpc compared to my 32/62 alto/bari so hopefully the neck change probably to a C1/E1 would help! (I know the Z is a jazz horn😉!
Yep the ex is a better bet fot classical..the g1 on my z tenor is much raunchier..I play the c1 that came with it..its a bit mellower..
 
many a pro player use Yamaha 32’s, i’m sure leo P would be confused to know his sax is mediocre…

they’re good saxes and while i think selling a horn in need of total overhaul for £400 is out of order this is a bit ??
You're talking to a guy who played a YAS21 on pro gigs for years. It worked fine, but if I had Eddie's budget, I'd aim a little higher. Point is buying a low end horn and spending a lot on repairs is not preferable to putting the same money I to a better horn that's not in need of repair. My advice would be the same for any item like a car, lawn mower, whatever.

Interesting about Leo P playing a cheap alto. I've only ever heard him on bari which appears to be a nice horn.

Regardless, my view is clearly in the minority, so I'm fine dropping it.
 
You're talking to a guy who played a YAS21 on pro gigs for years. It worked fine, but if I had Eddie's budget, I'd aim a little higher. Point is buying a low end horn and spending a lot on repairs is not preferable to putting the same money I to a better horn that's not in need of repair. My advice would be the same for any item like a car, lawn mower, whatever.

Interesting about Leo P playing a cheap alto. I've only ever heard him on bari which appears to be a nice horn.

Regardless, my view is clearly in the minority, so I'm fine dropping it.
His bari is a 52 (american version of the 32)!

I’m just defensive as i’ve got a 32 alto 😉
 
You're talking to a guy who played a YAS21 on pro gigs for years. It worked fine, but if I had Eddie's budget, I'd aim a little higher. Point is buying a low end horn and spending a lot on repairs is not preferable to putting the same money I to a better horn that's not in need of repair. My advice would be the same for any item like a car, lawn mower, whatever.

Interesting about Leo P playing a cheap alto. I've only ever heard him on bari which appears to be a nice horn.

Regardless, my view is clearly in the minority, so I'm fine dropping it.
Hey all opinions greatly received..I didnt really have a budget and wanted a half decent alto for one reason or another..I think the 32 is a decent horn the only difference between that and the 62 aside from engraving is the crook ( and pillars)..Tbf it seemed a better deal to get the sax repadded than return it..I should have a sax for £890 overhauled. A good horn at that..A 62 would ve at least £1400 plus a service..
 
Proven fact or internet 'knowledge'?
Who knows it's only common consensus I think..Maybe one of the techs may be able to answer..Anyway when done I think it will be all the sax I need..Next one up is 500£ more and may need work if bought used..At least this way i have a few years playing before anything is needed..Not planned that way but the best outcome from a bad situation..
 
Proven fact or internet 'knowledge'?
from a 2014 thread in here:

“
The YTS32 comes in 4 versions and the reverse of 62s in that they actually get better as they get newer as they get more 62 features along the way - the earliest with the Crimson logo are actually closer to a 23 than a 62 in features and fittings (though retain the 62 bodytube, bow and bell) , the last versions have most of the 62 mod-cons including adjustable guard stops, movable thumbrest and other adjustery bits etc - the unique thing is that they retain the strapless pillar mount system of the 61 and 21/23 (good or bad, who knows) sadly they all (bar maybe the rare E model) have the less robust neck receiver too (even old 62s have a tougher one)
All 32s are basically Mk1 62s and have that sound (you can use a 32 neck on a 62 Mk2 to give it the "pruple" sound) .. I directly compared a late Revision 3 32 to a 2012 Mk2 brass laquer 62 belonging to a mate and the playability was very close, the action on the 32 was lighter and looser and a touch less smooth (not surprising being 20 years old and in need of a service) , the laquer was thicker and nicer on the 62-II than the 32 also (though it`s also nicer than the older 61/62s too) .

Soundwise the 32 spanked the 62-II until the necks were swapped when it opened up the 62-II to almost the same sound , even with the same neck, you can hear that 10% SH mentions in his review, it`s a hard to describe extra bit of organic "aliveness" . I`d happily have a late 32 instead of a 62 Mk1 or II to save money but I`d want it to be the later one with more 62 stuff on .the posts above detail the comparsions I could find out between the 4 revisions but notes about the 4th rev (E) are sketchy as it would appear to be very uncommon and I couldn`t find much, it seems to be a missing link to the 475 and may have had the G1-esque neck
the Revision-4 YTS32s I`ve been told are very rare and are 100% 475s with 32 stamped on - there have been a few Yamaha "Prototypes" about, Griff has a YTS61 like this .”

so is even more complicated than thought! I think people should probably not worry about this stuff and just find whichever sax is their favourite!

as much as i find intonation a challenge on my g1 custom z it really is amazing and to me creates quite a vintage sound but may just be my jazz clarinet training and embrochure😉
 
^^^
The above is very interesting, but appears to opinion rather than hard fact.
Is there any evidence that "a 32 is essentially the same as a 62 with a different neck" is anything other than an (apparently accepted) internet trope?
Has anybody from Yamaha confirmed it?
 
^^^
The above is very interesting, but appears to opinion rather than hard fact.
Is there any evidence that "a 32 is essentially the same as a 62 with a different neck" is anything other than an (apparently accepted) internet trope?
Has anybody from Yamaha confirmed it?
Hey i don't think it will natter to me..only for a couple of songs a great sax in it's own right and probably more than ill need..
 
^^^
The above is very interesting, but appears to opinion rather than hard fact.
Is there any evidence that "a 32 is essentially the same as a 62 with a different neck" is anything other than an (apparently accepted) internet trope?
Has anybody from Yamaha confirmed it?
Excuse my ignorance but what does trope "mean"
 
Who knows it's only common consensus I think..Maybe one of the techs may be able to answer..Anyway when done I think it will be all the sax I need..Next one up is 500£ more and may need work if bought used..At least this way i have a few years playing before anything is needed..Not planned that way but the best outcome from a bad situation..
I don't think you are making a bad choice: you will end up with a solid alto with new pads that will last you many many years and with Dawkes' guarantee so if you're not happy about the repad you can always go back to them. That's my take.
 
^^^
The above is very interesting, but appears to opinion rather than hard fact.
Is there any evidence that "a 32 is essentially the same as a 62 with a different neck" is anything other than an (apparently accepted) internet trope?
Has anybody from Yamaha confirmed it?
That's a good point and one I have always assumed, so I looked back at some old Yamaha brochures.
I can tell you that on the Yamaha brochure for the first series (purple logo), other than the usual differences (no engraving, plastic finger pearls, thinner non tapered neck receiver, no adjustable thumb rest, weight (the 32 being lighter by 200gr.), etc.) a difference noted is that the 62 was annealed and the 32/23 not. This reference to the annealing process disappeared in subsequent Yamaha brochures (I have about 3 different ones): make of this what you will.

So: an improved 23 rather than a dumbed down 62?
Of course this may have changed over different revisions as the 62 was no longer their top end model (although still referred to as "professional") and the 32/23/25 were also tweaked.
Maybe someone else can add some more facts.
 
On consideration I may have misunderstood what's being said about the 62/32.
It appears that people are saying that putting a different neck on a 32 improves it to almost 62 levels, rather than that the 32 is a dumbed down 62. While the misunderstanding doesn't reflect too well on me, it does emphasise my point that it's easy to misinterpret what people write, and even easier for that misinterpretation to morph into internet fact.
 
I yield on the 32. Sounds like this beloved horn is worth any amount of money one wants to put into it.

Regarding necks, from my personal experience, the G1 was difficult to play in tune around high G/A, but the V1 was not. So I got rid of my G1 neck. I've never bought into the idea that necks make a huge difference. Yes they do make a small difference, and some are just plain terrible (like the G1 IMO), but your money is much better spent on a different mouthpiece or reeds. Or you can just practice to get the sound that you want, and that's absolutely free. If you expect a different neck to transform a bad sound into a good sound, you're going to be disappointed.
 
I yield on the 32. Sounds like this beloved horn is worth any amount of money one wants to put into it.

Regarding necks, from my personal experience, the G1 was difficult to play in tune around high G/A, but the V1 was not. So I got rid of my G1 neck. I've never bought into the idea that necks make a huge difference. Yes they do make a small difference, and some are just plain terrible (like the G1 IMO), but your money is much better spent on a different mouthpiece or reeds. Or you can just practice to get the sound that you want, and that's absolutely free. If you expect a different neck to transform a bad sound into a good sound, you're going to be disappointed.
Dont get that tbf @lydian..bought the sax as adverised i.e. very good condition..didnt think it would need a repad..on assessment it did so got cash back of the seller..Don't know what all the fuss is about really..
 
I yield on the 32. Sounds like this beloved horn is worth any amount of money one wants to put into it.

Regarding necks, from my personal experience, the G1 was difficult to play in tune around high G/A, but the V1 was not. So I got rid of my G1 neck. I've never bought into the idea that necks make a huge difference. Yes they do make a small difference, and some are just plain terrible (like the G1 IMO), but your money is much better spent on a different mouthpiece or reeds. Or you can just practice to get the sound that you want, and that's absolutely free. If you expect a different neck to transform a bad sound into a good sound, you're going to be disappointed.
So did you swap the g1 for a v1 because it was easier intonation wise?? Seems ironic..seriously tho i wasnt going to spend 370 on a new neck but will chance 190 i can get that back. I concur the c1 on the tenor is a better blow ill just see how it goes as the g1 is meant to be an improvement. Also agree on reeds but can only play a legere in the van so sticking to those. I'm a bit gutted as i wholeheartedly agree cane reed choice can really make a difference..
 
I already surrendered on this argument. But in my defense, all I was trying to say was that I think buying a thing for 400, then spending 700 to make it function is a worse idea than spending that total amount on something better that already functions. Everyone who responded disagrees, and I'm ok with that. You all win. The whole situation changed midstream anyway, so the point is moot.

Enjoy the new horn.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,578
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom