Saxophones Yas 62 G neck on a YAS 32

Mouthpiece changes will make ten times the difference of neck changes - that is, if the new neck is close enough to play in tune.

Personally I think all the neck swap business is faintly applicable to virtuosi who have spent decades developing and fine tuning their sound and are deeply into experimentation, and largely inapplicable to the rest of us. Twenty hours a week in the woodshed will do more for the vast majority of saxophone players than all the neck swaps on earth.
It's a little bit more nuanced than that.
Just as there are tonal differences between any two apparently identical horns, the same applies for the crooks (and it's often the case that that's where the major difference is). I've found that swapping out crooks can alter the 'spread' of the tone, much more so than a mouthpiece does. To put that in some kind of perspective a mouthpiece could be considered to be like a piece of rough sandpaper - and the crook a piece of fine grade wet & dry. They both do the same thing, but one is finer than the other and creates a finish.
Every once in a while I come across a horn that doesn't respond as well as it ought to - or at least in the manner that's common to that particular horn. In almost every instance where I've had access to another crook of a known quality, it's proven to be an effective remedy.

But I suppose this ties in with your comments about virtuosi in a way. In both cases there's a very specific reason for wanting to try a different crook - and one that perhaps reaches beyond what's capable with woodshedding. Beyond that, though, I agree that practice, practice, practice is going to yield far more benefits.
 
@eb424 -I think the only thing you can do is try for yourself. Aside from knowing whether it's mechanically possible (which has already been confirmed) everything else is opinion -but there's only one opinion that counts -yours!

Go for it and let us know how you get on.
 
@eb424 -I think the only thing you can do is try for yourself. Aside from knowing whether it's mechanically possible (which has already been confirmed) everything else is opinion -but there's only one opinion that counts -yours!

Go for it and let us know how you get on.
Thanks, its done 190 for a used 62 G1 neck and 680 for a very good condition yas 32..if the neck doesn't make a difference it can go back on e bay..thing is the only difference between a lot of the earlier and later 62s (aside from tilting tables etc) was the neck..who knows...they were all meant to sound different..have you listened to the video is it just me who thinks difference can be heard..
 
Problem is Eddie this is the wrong place to ask this question because anyone that responds won't be you and if someone gets a big difference it may be down to that players experience that he/she can evaluate that difference.
So really at your level with a £200 to £300 budget for a new neck you would be better spending that on more lessons than gear, but if you must buy a new neck then go and try at a music shop first rather than buying blind.
 
Last edited:
Thanks @jazzdoh i can tell the difference on a tenor tbf..Im not looking for massive differences but looking at research the g1 is an up grade on the 32 neck..post veered a bit of course..lol
The only way you will know is to go and try it, but it may be an an upgrade in one area but not in another, like it could give you a slightly different sound that you might like but throw your intonation out.
 
The only way you will know is to go and try it, but it may be an an upgrade in one area but not in another, like it could give you a slightly different sound that you might like but throw your intonation out.
My hope is that as the bore and things on the 32 are the same as the 62 the neck will be an upgrade..all a bit of a gamble tho..not expecting great changes..
 
The sax itself wasn't in great condition..I took it to Dawkes for an assessment and not good news...Requires a complete repad...or £490 as it equates to...Possibly not the neck then but hey ho....Ended up getting the sax for £400 so all not lost....onto a mouthpiece
 
I think the 1200 you’ll have in thing mediocre horn in the end would be much better spent on the next model up, already in good nick. If I were you , I’d flip it and keep looking.
 
Plus 200 for the neck, tax, shipping, etc. You don’t have a mouthpiece either. Just makes more sense to put the same amount of money into something better. Didn’t you have a nice alto before that you got rid of. How much was it?

Regardless, I paid about the same for a pro quality tenor that didn’t need any work at all. Just saying’.
 
I think the 1200 you’ll have in thing mediocre horn in the end would be much better spent on the next model up, already in good nick. If I were you , I’d flip it and keep looking.
many a pro player use Yamaha 32’s, i’m sure leo P would be confused to know his sax is mediocre…

they’re good saxes and while i think selling a horn in need of total overhaul for £400 is out of order this is a bit ??
 
many a pro player use Yamaha 32’s, i’m sure leo P would be confused to know his sax is mediocre…

they’re good saxes and while i think selling a horn in need of total overhaul for £400 is out of order this is a bit ??
I think that it is probably a bit expensive. However the horn is in really good condition bar a few scratches . I think 890 with a complete repad and the g1 neck fitted is a good price..theyre up for 1000 ish without so its good value really..m
 
I think that it is probably a bit expensive. However the horn is in really good condition bar a few scratches . I think 890 with a complete repad and the g1 neck fitted is a good price..theyre up for 1000 ish without so its good value really..m
yeah i think if the g1 neck is any good for you you’ll have a good deal.

I think I might try the newer custom necks at some point (probably on tenor first) as I really don’t get on with the G1 necks still!

I dislike how difficult it is to get a classical sound out of my Custom Z even with a really small mpc compared to my 32/62 alto/bari so hopefully the neck change probably to a C1/E1 would help! (I know the Z is a jazz horn😉!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,578
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom