Saxophones worst ergonomically designed sax?

Conn bari are much worst.

My Conn 12M (#239,xxx) baritone is overall pretty good and comfortable with a couple of exceptions that stop me really enjoying it.

Firstly the left hand thumb rest is tiny and awkward, and also makes the octave lever dig into my thumb. Secondly the bis Bb key is located strangely compared with modern saxes and is a long slide to reach. The LH pinky keys which some people don't like are actually fine for me as is the spacing on all the other keywork.

Rhys
 
Apart from a chinese no name alto that a student let me play on saturday (left palms keys all wrong). I had an old Selmer Pennsylvania Bari that had the D and Eb palm key at exactly the same hight, so when I played D I played the Eb as well! Paul Windridge Braised a small extension on the D for me and you couldn't see the join. Excellent work
 
To me... the left hand key work of Mark VI soprano has always been tricky (I'm talking about the high palm keys).

Once I tried a Dolnet "Imperial" tenor... wonderful horn (Selmer BA vibe, but "softer" tone)... I cannot reach the LH pinky keys, I should have figers 3/4" longer... maybe in 40ies in French they have huge hands, who knows?
 
Once I tried a Dolnet "Imperial" tenor... wonderful horn (Selmer BA vibe, but "softer" tone)... I cannot reach the LH pinky keys, I should have figers 3/4" longer... maybe in 40ies in French they have huge hands, who knows?

Incidentally I have a Dolnet hanging around.
The problem about LH pinky is not about the keywork: it is about the neck! Like SML, its angle puts your hands in an uncomfortable position. I am getting used to it.

Friuli o Venezia-Giulia? saxophone-wise it can make a difference.
 
I always liked more long/low profile neck design over high/short neck design (Mark VII, Series I/II).
I remember the Dolnet neck profile as a somewhat lower than a BA neck.


Onestly I don't remember if the LH pinky key discomfort was due to neck profile.


 
Last edited by a moderator:
... anyway I think this can be the best ergonimical sax ever made.
🙂))
Keyless1.1.jpg
 
Really? I think the Martin thumbrests are great.

My Handcraft Searchlight Alto is fine and I tested an Indiana with an adjustable thumb-rest which posed no problems (apart from the fact that it was attached with superglue by the seller and fell off after a couple of days!) - still these were Altos and different models are designed differently - so some Martins are ok some aren't (simple).
Let's say that the Martin Handcraft Standard's thumb rest is the worst ever designed?! (my thumb and palm took a month to recover...enough said).
 
My Handcraft Searchlight Alto is fine and I tested an Indiana with an adjustable thumb-rest which posed no problems .

Agreed. I had a Martin Indiana with the adjustable thumbrest at one time, and I found it very comfortable to play. A good sax.
 
My right thumb and palm are back to normal now (at long last) and just re-started playing the Martin Handcraft Standard - still, I'm just too wary of playing this sax for more than 1 hour in one go and using all sorts of diy solutions to overcome the thumb rest problem...
Found out about this product from Runyon:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Runyon-Rubb...MJZ2/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1335898637&sr=8-1

any feedback?

OK, I think I've found a quick solution....forget about de-soldering and re-soldering, here's a plasticine like material which might work just fine:
http://sugru.com/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sugru

I've just ordered some...let's see.
 
just an update about that Martin Standard thumb-rest:
The Sugru does work - I've placed a completely new thumb-rest made of Sugru about 2cm above the original one (I've used other tenors as a reference); it stays in place nicely and it's far more comfy than the old one...
In the end the root of the problem wasn't the shape of the original thumb-rest (though still a bit small for a tenor) but the positioning of the same.
 
There's an old thread on here somewhere which talks about sling hook ring postion and shows a removable mod to add an extra one. It was metal strip with holes in it, fixed to the old ring and I think to the body by straps. Looked neater than it sounds. I think something similar could be done for the thumb rest - or once you're sure where you want the thumb rest, but y a spare and glue it on with epoxy. Seems to last well. And done properly is really neat.
 
There's an old thread on here somewhere which talks about sling hook ring postion and shows a removable mod to add an extra one. It was metal strip with holes in it, fixed to the old ring and I think to the body by straps. Looked neater than it sounds. I think something similar could be done for the thumb rest - or once you're sure where you want the thumb rest, but y a spare and glue it on with epoxy. Seems to last well. And done properly is really neat.

A neat job would require the removal (de-soldering) of the original thumb-rest...then soldering a new one in a new position (about 2cm above old one works for me).
Think about it...I could have brought this sax to a pro for replacing the thumb-rest with a modern one...for then discovering later on (after injuring my hand once more) that the real problem was the positioning of the thumb-rest - then I would had to have the modern thumb-rest removed and replaced about 2cm above the original spot (thank to sugru I'd avoid all that troubles).
Then soldering/de-soldering is a bit problematic on this sax cos' toneholes have themselves been soldered....dunno, maybe one day I'll get this sorted in a more professional way...right now, I play!

The Sugru removes the need for any glue (epoxy or whatever) - isn't that great? Work this putty like stuff for 30 seconds, apply and shape it the way you like - then wait 24 hours and job done. The grip is also excellent - the only downside is that it looks a bit rough but my Martin Standard is no beauty either (lots of ding and bumps removed by many previous owners).

Sugru recommended all the ways...think about palm keys adjusters, left thumb rests and other bits which sometimes aren't in line with our hands...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Fully agree. I suggested the epoxy for two reasons - one was the risk to the other soldering if one was to solder a new rest on, and the other was the possible damage to lacquer if soldering is used, maybe not here, but on other saxes where someone may be thinking of doing the same thing...
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,686
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom