Tech/maintenance Will these dings come out cleanly?

DavidUK

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,133
Location
Near Evesham, Worcestershire
Just debating getting a few dents sorted. One bow, one bell.

I have Matt Sheward and Paul Carrington nearest to me.

Difficult to know from photos I realise, but there's no damage to the lacquer and both have no crease in the centre. What do you reckon on an invisible fix?...

Bow:

20221006_144926.webp


Bell:

20221006_145059.webp

20221006_145131.webp


Thanks for any opinions. :thumb:
 
Is that horn a Yamaha YAS-62?

Regarding your question, have you ever had a go on a not so valuable instrument? You maybe presently surprised how easy it is. (Not that I am a pro at it. Still many years to perfect what I still need to learn... )
 
It's a YAS-62 yes. Actually I do have part of an old tenor (Orsi, Karl Glaser) which is incomplete. I could bash it about a bit! It's not so much that as the cost of the tools to try dent removal.

As I see it I'd need a well secured bar and dent balls to attach to it?
I wouldn't recommend it.
The cogent phrase in John's post is 'skilled repair tech'. And yes, invisible dentwork really is a skill.
Have a go at a couple of beaters by all means, but either leave the Yamaha alone or take it to someone who knows what they're doing. Shouldn't cost more than twenty quid.
 
I wouldn't recommend it.
The cogent phrase in John's post is 'skilled repair tech'. And yes, invisible dentwork really is a skill.
Have a go at a couple of beaters by all means, but either leave the Yamaha alone or take it to someone who knows what they're doing. Shouldn't cost more than twenty quid.
Fully agree with this statement in this context.

But I noted over a long time that the OP was a serial horn flipper and over the years to come, would be able to learn the dent art of repair by teaching one self.

But I need to reinforce that this is a high skilled craft and NOT a DYI idea for the average punter.

If I was the OP in this instance, I would take it to a Pro On such a high value horn.
 
Yes, already contacted Paul Carrington...

I think Trevor Head does a specialist saxophone repair course. I'd like a day on dent removal.

I have a great car dent man, Ray. 18 years as a panel beater at the Jag before he started his own mobile business. He was removing a dent in my car when he noticed one in the door of my business partner's Merc. He took a long bar with an angled bit at the end, stuck it down inside the door skin next to the window, and with one twist the dent completely disappeared. Experience is everything! :thumb:
 
I think Trevor Head does a specialist saxophone repair course. I'd like a day on dent removal.
Here's the thing about instrument repair.
When I first started in this business I took a two year full-time course in it. I came away with a nice piece of paper and set off out into the world to make my name as a repairer.
I quickly discovered that the two year course was less about teaching you what to do as it was teaching your what NOT to do - and the intervening 45 years have been about honing those skills.
And after all this time, could I absolutely guarantee to get those dents out without leaving a trace? Nope.
I can give it my very best shot, and if the wind's in the right direction I might well do a perfect job - but there are so, so many things that can go wrong. Maybe the metal is uncharacteristically hard or soft, maybe the first push with the dent ball is a touch off-centre, maybe there's a discrepancy in the wall thickness.

I'm always keen to dispel any notions of 'the black arts' when it comes to horn repairs - but there are certain techniques that really do require a LOT of practice...and dent removal is right up there with neat and tidy soldering.

If you really want to know what can go wrong, just take a peek at the Black Museum section on my site. It's full of examples from folks who thought "Yeah, I can do that" - some of whom are 'professionals'.
 
Stephen Howard said it best. In my experience dent repair is a combination of visual, tactile, and intuitive skills combined with years of practice. The best saxophone dent repair in my area is done by techs who also do a lot of brass instrument repair where dent removal is perhaps the most common repair they do---especially when they work on school instruments.
 
Stephen Howard said it best. In my experience dent repair is a combination of visual, tactile, and intuitive skills combined with years of practice. The best saxophone dent repair in my area is done by techs who also do a lot of brass instrument repair where dent removal is perhaps the most common repair they do---especially when they work on school instruments.
Absolutely. If you want first-class dentwork a brass repairer is the person to go to. For them, every day is a dent day.
 
I just idly Googled "brass repairs" locally and up popped a local woodwind repairer I'd never heard of. Anyone know of them?:



As for brass, Paul Mourant, but again I don't know him. Anyone?:



Always nervous about new repairers. I've been to a couple of shocking ones in the past.
 
I just idly Googled "brass repairs" locally and up popped a local woodwind repairer I'd never heard of. Anyone know of them?:



As for brass, Paul Mourant, but again I don't know him. Anyone?:



Always nervous about new repairers. I've been to a couple of shocking ones in the past.
Can always be nervous going to someone new,with anything...but you live and learn,then die and forget it.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,135
Latest member
Recursive
Back
Top Bottom