Mouthpieces Where to start with mouthpieces when moving around the sax family ?

cjR

Sax via Horn, Trumpet, Guitar, Bass, Music Tech
Messages
91
Location
London, UK
Looking for advice or the established wisdom on where to start with mouthpiece selection when moving to a new type of horn. Ie. From Alto to Tenor or Soprano.

Is a starter piece like a Yamaha 4C the way to go to start with or can most dive in a little closer to something likely more suitable and more likely to last ?

For example, I'm an Alto player playing on a Tone Edge 6 or a Selmer D. So starting out an Tenor would a Link 6 be a safe bet and similar Soprano a Selmer D ? Or does it depend, really need to try etc.

My intention isn't to move away from Alto but dabble in the background on a reasonable setup that doesn't need changing for some time.
 
My intention isn't to move away from Alto but dabble in the background on a reasonable setup that doesn't need changing for some time.
Soprano: Yamaha 4C is a very good starter and, for dabbling in the background, good for years of playing.

Tenor: It depends. Tenor needs more air. Some find this a challenge. Others not. For an experienced Alto player, a Tone Edge 6 should be fine. For less experienced, some time on a Yamaha 4C can help transition to using more air.

Players often have different favourites on the separate horns. Sopranos tend to favour a narrower tip opening (for intonation control and a pure tone). Altos favour Meyer. Tenors favour Links. So the same player may prefer a classical tip opening on Sop, a 6 on Alto and an 8 on Tenor.

YMMV.
 
It depends a bit on how long you have been playing. I don‘t think you have to start on a 4C. It will play well and serve you for some time but if your mind is set for a different tone and tip size pick something different.
On tenor I dislike a Tone Edge as they sound dull to me. Others call them warm I just don‘t like them. The D‘Addario tenor piece is well made, sounds good and is still affordable. Same goes for Vandoren V16.
Soprano, my choice for dabbling around would be a used Yanagisawa. They are notoriously undervalued and pop up in the used market for little money.
 
Looking for advice or the established wisdom on where to start with mouthpiece selection when moving to a new type of horn. Ie. From Alto to Tenor or Soprano.

Is a starter piece like a Yamaha 4C the way to go to start with or can most dive in a little closer to something likely more suitable and more likely to last ?

For example, I'm an Alto player playing on a Tone Edge 6 or a Selmer D. So starting out an Tenor would a Link 6 be a safe bet and similar Soprano a Selmer D ? Or does it depend, really need to try etc.

My intention isn't to move away from Alto but dabble in the background on a reasonable setup that doesn't need changing for some time.
If you're reasonably happy with a Link and a Selmer (S-80?) on alto, then yes, a Link of the the same number on tenor and a Selmer of the same letter on soprano are very reasonable starting points. Neither of these is in the least extreme, they're both good reasonable middle of the road designs in good reasonable middle of the road facings, so the feel on the different voices will be somewhat familiar and help you to get the tenor and/or soprano under control. And you could certainly play a Link 6 hard rubber on tenor and a Selmer D on soprano the rest of your life.
 
I have found that the smaller the instrument the wider the tip opening needed.
My current,
Bari. Selmer S80 C*
Tenor Selmer soloist C**
Alto Selmer soloist D
Sop Selmer S80 G
Clarinet Rico Metalite 11.

Hope this helps, but it's all very personal and much experimentation is needed.
 
Most people I know just keep changing mouthpieces but have an underdeveloped embouchure / breath support / consistent tone from top to bottom. In case you have a teacher and a solid sound concept ( pop / classical / trad. jazz ) he can suggest what is best for you. A 4C has been a great started for me on alto, soprano & tenor.
My advice is to "build" on a solid not too open mouthpiece and when you're sure ( ask an experienced 3rd person if you don't have a teacher ) move on to whatever you want. By then you will know for sure what is lacking in your current setup.

Now about jumping from one to another, I find my self having really different tonal concept from on instrument to another. I aim for a fat-traditional sound on tenor , a pronounced on alto, and a very conservative on soprano ... so i have different mouthpiece preferences and "tonal strategies" for each instrument. Try to respect each saxophone size as a totally different instrument.

And also try to stay out of the temptation of switching mouthpieces all the time. Unless they are of radically different design ... you are going always to try to achieve the sound that's in your head, or if you don't have one yet ... swim in an ocean of options ... away from the safe land 🙂
 
I have found that the smaller the instrument the wider the tip opening needed.
My current,
Bari. Selmer S80 C*
Tenor Selmer soloist C**
Alto Selmer soloist D
Sop Selmer S80 G
Clarinet Rico Metalite 11.

Hope this helps, but it's all very personal and much experimentation is needed.
Definitely NOT my experience.

Soprano Selmer S-80 C*
Alto Meyer 7
Tenor Meyer 8
Baritone Meyer 8
Bass Selmer C*

At any rate, OP, a good bet for you is what you already suggested - for tenor, HR Link in same number as your existing HR Link alto; for soprano, Selmer in the same number as your existing Selmer alto. Me, I'd start out with the same brand and numerical strength of reeds, as well.
 
I have found that the smaller the instrument the wider the tip opening needed.
My current,
Bari. Selmer S80 C*
Tenor Selmer soloist C**
Alto Selmer soloist D
Sop Selmer S80 G
Clarinet Rico Metalite 11.

Hope this helps, but it's all very personal and much experimentation is needed.
This is the opposite of me - and most players I know. I would say that generally, alto and soprano should be at the same level, tenor and bari a bit more.

I play a Link 6 on soprano (equivalent), a Meyer 6 on alto (ditto) and a 7* or 8 on tenor. A good friend who is much smaller than me plays a Meyer 5 on alto and a Link 6 on tenor. Another friend, also smaller, plays a Meyer 7 on alto and 8* or 9 on tenor.
 
I hear that a lot. However, whatever works, works. :confused2:

The S80 G was a revelation and really got me going on sop.

Sop tip openings are so small that a big one is minute and Bari openings are so large a small one is massive.

I've been a small tip hard reed player most of my playing life on alto and baritone. The bigger sizes on small horns corrected intonation and volume problems that I'd had a long time struggle with.
 
Now about jumping from one to another, I find my self having really different tonal concept from on instrument to another. I aim for a fat-traditional sound on tenor , a pronounced on alto, and a very conservative on soprano ... so i have different mouthpiece preferences and "tonal strategies" for each instrument. Try to respect each saxophone size as a totally different instrument.
+1
 
I have found that the smaller the instrument the wider the tip opening needed.

Definitely NOT my experience.

I'm both on Soprano. I use a Selmer Concept (narrow tip) and an Aizen 9 (wide tip) for different tonal concepts as better suits different songs.

On Tenor, I mainly use an 8* GetaSax Slant or a PhilTone Sapphire 8. But I vary between a 6 tip opening and a 9, depending on reed attributes, horn, song, my mood and whim and my perceived audience preference.
 
It very much depends on the individual but logic dictates not going too large anywhere, especially as you are a medium tip on your main horn.

Me -

Sop - Selmer C*
Alto - Lakey 4*3
Tenor - JJ 7*
 
Thanks all ! You didn't dissuade me from getting a Tenor (I did wonder if this would cool my GAS flames), even tho it does sound like there's no getting away from there being no real shortcut to landing on the right setup.

I ordered some Vandoren blue 2s and will start with the stock mouthpiece and at least get to a point where I feel competent enough to evaluate some options in a shop - and now have some idea about starting points.
 
My mildly mannered tenor sax mouthpieces are looking a little ratty. I use these for community band and for church, other indoor venues, as I don't need the projection and volume as in say, a rock band. Ability to play soft and balance with the flutes and clarinets is more important.

Taking a few gentle suggestions in this forum and considering cost, I opted for:

Sweetwater: Bari ESKTSP Esprit Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece Kit- Polished

Description: Composite Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece with 0.073" Tip Opening, Round Chamber, Ligature, and Cap - Polished.
 
I do like the Aizen ls 6* on tenor..HR or link 6,,* but metal. Ivehad a few links and foud them stuffy butthe Aizen is an easier blow and sounds as good. I use 2 plasticovers to give some volue but it still has a lovelly warm tone..
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom