Playing the saxophone What's the hardest thing for you in practicing?

The hardest thing for me in practising is stopping .....even though my wife says I always sound like a car and cannot play all day.When I said a car is better than a truck she said ...why can t u sound like a bicycle !? I gave a long lingering look of deep sadness and said.....Cos a good bicycle costs more than my sax....
 
...why can t u sound like a bicycle !? I gave a long lingering look of deep sadness and said.....Cos a good bicycle costs more than my sax....
Maybe you can learn from Pete, he put a bicycle bell on the neck of his tenor during a performance that he posted a few months ago.....
That would make you sound like a bicycle....
 
For me it's to practice the right thing the right way as there are so many things you can practice and so many ways to practice.
This is a big problem when you have a lot of music in your head already. The first time I picked up a saxophone, I had over 50 years of listening and playing other instruments. I hear music in my head all day, everyday. It's impossibly for me to focus on one thing for any length of time when practicing. Most of my practicing is just playing with short intervals of practicing some particular thing that is hard to execute, or adjusting tone, or rhythm.
 
That's part of the problem🙂 But if you want to learn the saxophone you normally have one teacher and there are no other pupils around. A good teacher would focus on you and try to help you with your problems. There is no curriculum which works for every student.
 
That's part of the problem🙂 But if you want to learn the saxophone you normally have one teacher and there are no other pupils around. A good teacher would focus on you and try to help you with your problems. There is no curriculum which works for every student.
This is exactly why I stopped lessons from a local teacher who came to my home. He had his little rote thing and barely answered questions. When I switched to online courses, it worked much better. You can work on what you think you need to improve.

My philosophy is simple.

To play a new instrument, you need to find out the basic things like how to stand or sit, how to hold it or approach it, if it's a keyboard or some other intrument not held. Next, you need to find out how to make the sound on it. Then you need to spend time working on controlling that sound. All of this is helped by an in person teacher. Once you can play Happy Birthday or Three Blind Mice, you have to decide what music you want to play and with whom:
1. Symphonic, big band or other formal setting
2. Rock tribute band, or singer backing band
3. Jazz band
4. Jazz jams for pleasure
5. Recording your own music or busking
etc.

There are certainly better and more detailed lists, but the point is, from 1 to 5 the level of discipline required starts high and goes down. For number one, you need to be a good sight reader and have a high level of facility and accuracy. Stability of sound and complete mastery of everything needed. (Big band may have solos, etc)

For number two, it's a show, you'll need accuracy, quick understanding and probably reading, but with a good ear and memory, maybe not perfect sight reading. The details depend on the music, which is probably not requiring much or any improvisation.

3. Depends on the band, its size and subgenre. It's plaing "free", you need to be able to play "free" and be inventive, yet feel the spirit and intent of the leader or the group. If it's wedding and standards, good reading and hearing and steeped in the standards culture. If it's playing jazz for people who like jazz (clubs and shows) the usual good reading and understanding.

4. Jams for pleasure, less discipline won't usually be a problem. Reading or knowing the chords and improvisation are needed elements. Pick your co-players carefully.

5. To play and record your own music, as rock bands used to do back in the day when music was less industrialized, you only need to be able to play at the level of the music.

Once you make the decision (always reversable) on the above goals, the work needed varies. The least discipline path is just playing as much as possible. Learning where the notes are and being able to play them with the sound your music requires. Many of the people on the Café forum play for pleasure. (Hopefully all of them get pleasure from playing!) I think they find music and either play it by ear or from the charts.

The simplest way to practice, once you know the basics of your instrument and of the music you want to play, is just to play it. Focus practice on what you feel needs work. If you have trusted people who make suggestions, you might consider working on those things. All the best players agree that you need to listen to as much music as you can. Determine what you like about your favorite music, and try to incorporate that concept or feeling into your own music. It's also great to continue to search for new ideas and ways to understand music better.
 
Also, it's very important to transcribe, learn what you transcribed and play it with the original. Especially if you want to learn improvisation. I know, it's hard to transcribe a Coltrane solo for example but it's definitively worth it to spent hours to transcribe it even if you don't practice your instrument during this time. Then write it down, analyse it and check out the phrasing, timing, notes and so on.

Many musician hesitate when it comes to transcribing because they believe that they can't do it or they want to practice their instrument and then there is no time left to transcribe but I think that's a mistake.
 
Many musician hesitate when it comes to transcribing because they believe that they can't do it or they want to practice their instrument and then there is no time left to transcribe but I think that's a mistake.
It's much easier today, because a free tool like Audacity can slow down the lines so you can hear them clearly. You can also purchase and study transcriptions and many free ones are available on YouTube that even follow the music.

However, I haven't transcribed abnything since about 1972, when I transcribed some McCoy Tyner solo lines. Now, I listen and if I can't hear what it is, I'll pick up a guitar and find out what it is. I don't want to learn phrases from the greats, I want to create my own.
 
The word 'Transcribe' was quite intimidating when I first started playing the Saxophone. The phrase always seemed to be connected with serious musicians learning seriously complicated Jazz solos. When I realised that it can just as easily be used to describe learning by listening to a simple Pop or Rock motif or solo, or the vocal melody of a song you like, the word seemed a lot less exclusive.
 
Yes @Halfers, writing the notes down is grunt work and not the most important thing. What counts is identifying the notes and the rhythm and hearing them in the context. Once you have that, if you want to play them, you will be able to find it on the instrument.
 
Mine is staying on any one thing for any significant length of time. For example, one day I might want to start by playing soft for a while. After a minute or less, I hear something in my head I want to work on and forget to play softly. Same with long tones. I think the only thing I can stay on is ideas that need work. I don't do much with exercises, but I would guess that by its very nature, an exercise needs to be played all the way through and possiby, three whole times through. In the rare moments where I do these, I do go through the whole exercise, with a major exception: the set of 50 "finger busters" from Eric Marienthal. I can get through about 5 before I either forget the next one or get an idea for a tune. They are a perfect example of why it would be better to be able to read.

Anyone that has seen my lessons knows that I am a big fan of combining the repetitive analytical part of the brain with the creative part of the brain. Every exercise I do I try to find ways to use both. A big weakness to many players is they only use one of those because it is their strength. I find that if I can involve both, I can stay on track and focused for hours because the creative side is feeding my brain the excitement it craves from creating while still practicing repetitive ideas over and over. Without the creative side, I quickly get bored or burnout.

Any improv concept I practice, I practice with a playalong track so I train my ears while practicing. If I am playing a very repetitive concept to master it I add creativity by varying the direction of the line, changing the line, or messing around with the rhythm of the line. If I continue to play around with those elements I am working out the analytical part of my brain as well as the creative and I can do that for 8 hours straight. If I just do boring repetitive practice I burnout from boredom in 10 minutes.

I can just do all creative for a long time but I know that I need focus and specific direction on a concept to gain mastery. I could just play for 8 hours and not really master anything. For me, it has to be a combination of those things for the best results for me.
 
The other habit that really helps me stay on track is to write everything down. I have graph paper and I write the keys along the top and all the exercises I want to work on down the left hand column. I then set up a system of memorization. If I am practicing an improv concept like my Approach Note Velocity materials I will put the numbers of the exercises down the left hand side of the paper but I will also break down the lines.

Line one might have 4 distinct parts in it so I will label 1A, 1B, 1C, 1D and 1(for the whole line). My usual system is that when I feel I have something mastered by memory I put a /. This means I can play it relatively fast in 16th notes over and over again without looking and without much thinking involved. (If you think of your brain as a CPU that is working from 1-100%, I try to get my brain down to 1% while playing the concept) It just flows out and through my fingers. The next day I try again. If I can still do it as easily I then put a \ which makes an X. The next 5 days I do the same thing each day but each day I put a dot in each space around the X. On the last day I put a circle around the whole thing meaning it is mastered completely.

Then I move on to the next line 1B and do the same. The important part is that as I am mastering 1B I am also working on combining it with 1A which I have already mastered so it shouldn't be that big a deal. I'm focusing on 1B, 1A is already mastered.

I do this going down the list in all 12 keys. Sometimes I move across the sheet with the different keys and sometimes I feel like moving down the sheet through different exercises in one key. The direction isn't as important as the goal, to make progress filling up that sheet with X's with circles and dots around them.

I keep this sheet on my desk all the time. It keeps me focused but also motivated. I know that if I master this sheet, then for the rest of my life, I can tell people about the concept that I mastered in 2021. I see huge benefits for me with this system. It is not for everyone though and I understand that, but for me it works.

I do all this while playing to a play along and training my ears as well as creatively also messing with the rhythmic ideas so that I am engaging my creative side of the brain like I wrote above in my previous post.
 
The other habit that really helps me stay on track is to write everything down. I have graph paper and I write the keys along the top and all the exercises I want to work on
I used to have a notebook when I was learning guitar. It had different sections. For chords, for example I had chords built on seconds going up and down that major scale. Another on symmetric scales. Another on rhythmic patterns and another on odd time sigs. Pages and pages. I still have it somewhere.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom