Saxophones What's the difference?

Damflask

Member
Messages
364
Location
United Kingdom
Selmer Super Action 80 Series II Bass on eBay.
It's lovely of course, but it looks identical to my Thomann .
Is a good copy as good as the original?
s-l1600 (21).webp
s-l1600 (20).webp
 
Frankly, if you are happy with your Thomann, stop looking at other instruments. Seriously.

I was slow to take my own advice, but since committing to my current tenor (I have owned dozens over the decades), I have found tremendous calm. I am not even interested in playing other horns. They just don't matter.
Hi, I was only looking at it because I was struck by the similarity.
Hence my question 🙂
 
It's an odd feeling when you own and play a cheap copy.
It plays great and it looks great but you have a sneaking feeling that you may have missed something and the world is looking down its nose at you.
Of course it looks like a Selmer. Why copy anything else?
I used to get all sorts of questions what my G4m alto might be.
A very nice saxophone is what it was, and will be again come spring.

I didn't get where I am today by not knowing Thomann stuff is good stuff.

Sorry...I've been watching Reggie Perrin reruns.
 
It's an odd feeling when you own and play a cheap copy.
It plays great and it looks great but you have a sneaking feeling that you may have missed something and the world is looking down its nose at you.
Of course it looks like a Selmer. Why copy anything else?
I used to get all sorts of questions what my G4m alto might be.
A very nice saxophone is what it was, and will be again come spring.

I didn't get where I am today by not knowing Thomann stuff is good stuff.

Sorry...I've been watching Reggie Perrin reruns.
Hah!
I suppose what I really need here, is someone who has played both of the instruments in question.
I wonder if I will find anyone?
 
Hi, I was only looking at it because I was struck by the similarity.
Hence my question 🙂
FWIW, if you want to refine your instrument, take it apart and refit it with attention to tone hole leveling, pad seating, and adjustments (including the selection of soft materials). You won't be able to easily improve the compliance of the long keys in the mechanism, nor make great changes in the bore geometry, but if you like your horn, know that there are opportunities to improve it. Ensuring that the horn is leak-free (including neck tenon and bow-body joint) should be a given, but I've learned that such assumptions are not always valid.
 
Hah!
I suppose what I really need here, is someone who has played both of the instruments in question.
I wonder if I will find anyone?
User Platner on SOTW has a Selmer bass. I don’t know if he’s ever played the Thomann, but very unlikely. Somebody with that kind of money would never even consider a Chinese copy.
 
Thanks very much for this Stephen.
I'd love to see a review of this by you...
If one comes in...

From what I've seen of the Chinese basses the Selmer copies tend to be better built than the vintage ones - but I wouldn't be at all surprised if some remedial action work was necessary along with some attention to the toneholes.
Such work doesn't come cheap, but even taking the cost into account it's still way cheaper than buying a Selmer.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom