Miscellaneous What effect does music have on you?

..... To my ears the years from 1700 to 1900 produced absolutely nothing of any interest. I know a lot of it is very worthy and well loved by some. But not by me - it bores me. .....

You must be a very hard man to please, Nick! 200 years of the greatest music dismissed as boring!:shocked:

I think, in a way, you may have demonstrated a point that I was, perhaps clumsily, attempting to make. I do believe that the first impression of any piece of music certainly can cause you either to like it or dislike it. If you dislike it and don't give it further hearings you may be losing an opportunity to be amazed - whether you are a musician or not. Equally, of course, it may be rubbish (as so much today actually is). Perhaps you have not experienced a live concert by a great orchestra, or listened to some of the greatest music played on a great cathedral organ. It takes a very unmusical person not to be moved. Some of the greatest jazz performers are actually classically trained musicians. Have you heard André Previn, a classical conductor, play jazz on the piano. Definitely not boring!

Some of the excellent popular music of the last 30 years was composed or arranged by an old school-mate of mine (and he is still making records!). He, of course, trained as a classical musician.

I am left wondering what it is that you DO like.......:confused:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As I learn more about music, I hear more in pieces I listen to. I think the point about musicians getting the most out of music is more directed at the technical aspects, and also learning to distinguish finer points like counter melodies, but I'd say that on an emotional level (where we started), being a musician is unimportant. But being able to tune into the emotions written into the music is essential, and can be done without technical knowledge. Kids and nursery rhymes/lullabies are a good example of this.
 
You must be a very hard man to please, Nick! 200 years of the greatest music dismissed as boring!:shocked:

I think, in a way, you may have demonstrated a point that I was, perhaps clumsily, attempting to make. I do believe that the first impression of any piece of music certainly can cause you either to like it or dislike it. If you dislike it and don't give it further hearings you may be losing an opportunity to be amazed - whether you are a musician or not. Equally, of course, it may be rubbish (as so much today actually is). Perhaps you have not experienced a live concert by a great orchestra, or listened to some of the greatest music played on a great cathedral organ. It takes a very unmusical person not to be moved. Some of the greatest jazz performers are actually classically trained musicians. Have you heard André Previn, a classical conductor, play jazz on the piano. Definitely not boring!

Why the heck should I listen to music I don't like? I've listened to and played enough of the classical and romantic composers to realise that they didn't write anything I want to listen to. What amazes me is that anybody would want to listen to Brahms or Schumann fer gawds sake.

Sorry, Andrew Preview is dull.

I am left wondering what it is that you DO like.......:confused:

Well, you may find it difficult to believe but quite a lot of music was made before 1700 and after 1900. There's actually quite a lot to choose from.
 
Why the heck should I listen to music I don't like? I've listened to and played enough of the classical and romantic composers to realise that they didn't write anything I want to listen to. What amazes me is that anybody would want to listen to Brahms or Schumann fer gawds sake.
Can't help you with Schumann, but Brahms 4 (esp the last mvement)? And the Tragic Overture. They just sweep me away every time.

Sorry, Andrew Preview is dull.

Have to agree there.

But for me it's incomprehensible that anyone can love music but not love Mozart. It almost seems like a contradiction in terms. Just goes to show it takes all types...

Cheers,

Martin
 
Ah, music. What is it to me?

In short, I don't think I could get through my life without it. Worries about elderly parents gradually falling apart? Listen to music and it feels a bit better. Hassles from the crap service which seems to be the norm? It evaporates with a bit of music. Work stress? Go and listen to the MP3 player in the corner, and it goes away. Knackered from a long, long day? A bit of music (raucous stuff for me) and I'm soothed into a calm place.

Jon
Very much the same as you. I'm reminded of a quote form Matt Dillon in the movie 'Drugstore Cowboy'- "...most folks are stressed not knowing how they're going to feel in the morning, I just have to look at the label on the bottle....".
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,576
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom