Saxophone beginners warming up your alto

I'm gonna assume @wakyct is a coder or has coding experience... because * is typically used to represent multiplication in a programming language.

Yes, from a purely mathematical standpoint, * may not be the correct symbol... but eh, it's second nature for many coders. I have seen similar arguments online not just on * but also ^, !=, >=, <=, etc... but eh, we're on the Internet, this is the digital age, so it's fine by me (even though I know others may not agree).

It's not the * symbol that's wrong - it's the "equation" !

Rhys
 
The equation as written is dimensionally incorrect and wrong. Multiplying frequency by wavelength is dimensionally correct and has units of metres per second. If you then multiply by T ( temperature, unit is K (kelvin) you end up with K.metre per second which is clearly not a velocity.

Instead of multiplying by temperature you need to multiply by a dimensionless number. For the velocity of sound this is sqrt(T/273K). The warmer the air the higher the speed of sound.

Now we see why a saxophone, or any wind instrument becomes sharp when warm. The wavelength is determined by the length of the air column between the mouthpiece and the tone holes and is effectively fixed (neglecting thermal expansion of the brass). Thus if temperature of the air increases and consequently the velocity of sound then so must the frequency, or pitch. We compensate by pulling the mouthpiece out a little, thus increasing the wavelength so as to maintain a constant frequency.
 
As your linked source says:
  • [Equation 17.2.1] The relationship of the speed of sound, its frequency, and wavelength is the same as for all waves:
    • vw =f x λ
    • Where: vw is speed of sound, f is its frequency and λ is its wavelength
This is always true by definition and you can see that by dimensional analysis: Speed (distance per time unit) = 1/time units x distance.

Then to understand how the speed of sound in a given substance will change with temperature we can use a second equation from that source.
  • [Equation 17.2.2] The speed of sound is affected by temperature in a given medium. For air at sea level, the speed of sound is given by:
    • vw = (331m/s) x Square Root of [Temperature in Kelvin / 273 in Kelvin]
    • Noting that 331m/s is the speed of sound in air at 0 degrees Celsius, which is approximately 273 Kelvin.
Again, looking at the units may help: Speed of sound (at one temperature) = Speed of sound at a standard temperature x a dimensionless factor which happens to be the square root of two temperatures in absolute units.

So the last term in the equation is not Temperature (in any units, Celsius, Fahrenheit or Kelvin). Kelvin is the absolute temperature scale that physicists love. That last term is not even the ratio of one temperature to another, it's the square root of actual temperature to a standard temperature at which the speed of sound for a certain substance is known.

You don't really combine these two equations, but they help us to understand that when the temperature changes, the speed of sound in that medium changes and then for a given wavelength (e.g. relating to a fixed length of a wind instrument tube) the frequency (pitch) of the note will change slightly as temperature changes.

Hope that helps !

Rhys
 
Last edited:
So, yeah.
It'd be fine to say "as I understand it, warmer air means higher pitch". No problem.

You're not the first to mix imagination, "science" and rhetoric in this context - try asking about the affect on sound of heavy weight screws, different alloys etc.
 
For a period of time my Bari played with great instability for the first five minutes and then settled into playing like a dream

I discovered that accretions were keeping the water key fractionally open. Five minutes of breathy condensation running to the bottom of the pig tail was enough to cover the water key orifice and my notes danced muscically out of the other perforations further along the tube (I am not being acoustically scientific)
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,402
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom