McAldo
Member
- Messages
- 76
- Location
- Carshalton
Interesting. There are parallels with maqam (middle East system) in which Penta/hexa etc chords are the fundamental unit - and probably closer to the early medieval Western tradition.
Essentially his theory is that the medieval tradition, which is generally assumed to have disappeared after the middle ages, carried on instead as the most standard pedagogical tool for many centuries after that.
We do not have much evidence of it because it was so diffused and basic, and also because in the italian tradition maestri did not write much at all. It was an aural teaching passed through generations and paper was darn expensive, so pupils used little blackboards instead. And apparently they started with typical medieval 4 lines, rather than the pentagram.
The little we have left are mostly more advanced topics meant for advanced students, progressing from singing to instruments and composition, and perspective maestri, which do not elaborate on basic pedagogy. Not more than some advanced book about chord substitutions in Jazz would spend on the very basics.
Things changed after the Napoleonic wars, because the whole educational system (and the music business) collapsed. Maestri found themselves without a job, and some started teaching to amateurs from the rising middle class.
Amateurs did not have that extensive practise with hexachordal solfeggio, neither they had spent their early years singing 30 hours per week in churches, learning a ton of patterns and relative basses from real music.
So the maestri had to be more explicit about the basics and some of that survived in a written form.
Before we only have occasional transcriptions from rare amateurs who attended conservatory and had the cash to write things down (most students in conservatories were orphans, and conservatories were in origin not musical institutions, but rather charitable institutions meant to protect young orphans and provide them with work skills, such as musical skills, which were cheap to teach, much in demand and profitable for the church).
Also we have a bit of pedagogical materials written by famous musicians as a gift to kings and other patrons, and these would sometimes talk more about the basics and the intervals. Tartini for instance wrote a very interesting one for his patron.
After, we do still have some evidence of the system being used still in the 19th century, for instance in conservatories in Paris and in the Philippines.
But by that time it was truly very rare and a less creative approach was common, more descriptive and suitable for verbatim performance of compositions. Which is essentially what we have now. A young learner will be taught static chords, scales and pieces. Why these sound good, and how to come up with variations and improvise, have become advanced topic which children are generally deprived of.
The video you linked is actually the best explanation I know of, besides the cycle of lessons I have taken.
The book is very expensive, I agree. As you can imagine, that is because it is a very specialized academic text and a small volume print. Funnily, as it is often the case with academic writings, the author gets a very negligible amount per copy, but I have to say that professor Baragwanath does not seem to care much at all about that. He just wanted it published and he even distributed for free the few chapters which contains actual learning material.
If you use facebook at all you can find them in the first posts of The Art of Solfeggio, a facebook group he created:
If you do not use facebook but still would like to read them just give me a shout and I will send them to you, I am quite sure Nick would not mind.
But to be frank, in terms of understanding the very basics, the video you linked is the best option. It is all so much clearer when he sings things (his lessons were really enjoyable too, I never watched music theory lessons as entertaining).
The rest of the book is very pleasant to read, and full of interesting anedoctes and historical details, but it is essentially a scientific dissertation with a thesis he works hard at demonstrating, rather than a pedagogical text for contemporary musicians to learn from.
I understand he is working on a more applied text, and the lessons I attended online were part of his research for that, but it might be a few years before anything comes out.
Last edited:
