- Messages
- 2,526
- Location
- Breakfast room since '06 UK
My word!
So much of this has me going round in circles.
I'm not gullible to manufacturers claims for many reasons that @Stephen Howard points out. I also know that one major factor here is about what translates to the listener will be so much less than what the player feels and hears. The player can't seperate the feel from the final produced tone impartially.
I bow to superior knowledge and experience on this forum but my opinion follows.
Casing the point regarding player vs listener, I believe if you lined up 6 Yani AW01's (brass) and 6 Yani AW02's (Bronze) and back to back tested them with the same player mouthpiece, reed room, session etc, the player would pick a discernible difference between the brass and the bronze as a whole as well as the differences across the 6 AW01's and across the 6 AW02's but hold on to that similarity of all the brass instruments vs all the bronze instruments.
Blindfold the listener and they have probably had it...they'll be clueless about the 2 different line I'm sure.
Then strip back that test for the blindfolded listener to 1 of the brass ones and 1 of the bronze ones and suddenly they stand more of a chance of picking one from the other repeatedly and consistently.
Is this fun or hell?
I definitely feel the difference in sound by changing ligatures so I hand the same ligatures to another player who says the same when he plays....but when I listen to him? nothing, it's just him playing sounding the same.
I guess hard rubber mouthpieces, plastic, sterling silver, bronze, stainless steel are widely different materials and when you play them (yep ok! we have baffles, chambers and rails to throw in on another whole subject) but now give an accomplished player the same horn and reed and have them play to similar style mouthpieces of different material to you and they will likely dig one much more than the other. Blind fold the listener and again its going to be so much harder.
Move the reed on the mouthpiece and now you have a different thing going on than 2 minutes earlier that nobody else knows about when you play again.
So I believe those discernible differences are there and those differences don't make a difference! 😵 only sometimes they do.
That must have cleared it up beyond further debate?
Seriously though forget it and do what floats your boat because but the Holy Grail will remain elusive for so many. Some people have a monogamous nature and decide they found it but many others won't.
Just to add,
In an earlier post S.H. said a different time changes things. Yep !!!
Only weeks ago I took out my Otto Link STM's and played them all (5 of them from Florida to modern) with the intention of buying the 100th anniversary FL mode just because!
But they were all so good I had to think why am I doing this? I bought it anyway (procrastinating never sorts me out) and 2 days later it arrived. I played the others again with the intention to add it straight afterwards. But I didn't get on nearly as well with the others as I did 2 days before and thats before the new one was out of its box.
So much of this has me going round in circles.
I'm not gullible to manufacturers claims for many reasons that @Stephen Howard points out. I also know that one major factor here is about what translates to the listener will be so much less than what the player feels and hears. The player can't seperate the feel from the final produced tone impartially.
I bow to superior knowledge and experience on this forum but my opinion follows.
Casing the point regarding player vs listener, I believe if you lined up 6 Yani AW01's (brass) and 6 Yani AW02's (Bronze) and back to back tested them with the same player mouthpiece, reed room, session etc, the player would pick a discernible difference between the brass and the bronze as a whole as well as the differences across the 6 AW01's and across the 6 AW02's but hold on to that similarity of all the brass instruments vs all the bronze instruments.
Blindfold the listener and they have probably had it...they'll be clueless about the 2 different line I'm sure.
Then strip back that test for the blindfolded listener to 1 of the brass ones and 1 of the bronze ones and suddenly they stand more of a chance of picking one from the other repeatedly and consistently.
Is this fun or hell?
I definitely feel the difference in sound by changing ligatures so I hand the same ligatures to another player who says the same when he plays....but when I listen to him? nothing, it's just him playing sounding the same.
I guess hard rubber mouthpieces, plastic, sterling silver, bronze, stainless steel are widely different materials and when you play them (yep ok! we have baffles, chambers and rails to throw in on another whole subject) but now give an accomplished player the same horn and reed and have them play to similar style mouthpieces of different material to you and they will likely dig one much more than the other. Blind fold the listener and again its going to be so much harder.
Move the reed on the mouthpiece and now you have a different thing going on than 2 minutes earlier that nobody else knows about when you play again.
So I believe those discernible differences are there and those differences don't make a difference! 😵 only sometimes they do.
That must have cleared it up beyond further debate?

Seriously though forget it and do what floats your boat because but the Holy Grail will remain elusive for so many. Some people have a monogamous nature and decide they found it but many others won't.
Just to add,
In an earlier post S.H. said a different time changes things. Yep !!!
Only weeks ago I took out my Otto Link STM's and played them all (5 of them from Florida to modern) with the intention of buying the 100th anniversary FL mode just because!
But they were all so good I had to think why am I doing this? I bought it anyway (procrastinating never sorts me out) and 2 days later it arrived. I played the others again with the intention to add it straight afterwards. But I didn't get on nearly as well with the others as I did 2 days before and thats before the new one was out of its box.
Last edited:
