Saxophones Thomann sopranino: how does it play ?

dexdex

Member
Messages
548
Location
Switzerland
Hi All,

Never say never. The other day I stumbled over a Thomann sopranino for sale on local classified adds. The basic version, made who knows where. Used, but almost unused. No mouthpiece, lost by the band it belonged to. The price though was low enough no make it a cool buy anyhow.
Did a brief test with a soprano mouthpiece, just to make sure it roughly worked. Funny, it plays in concert D and post-modern intonation with that setup.
What I did NOT anticipate, is that any nino mouthpiece would cost MORE than what I paid for the horn. Well, almost.
No big choice on the market, even worse if you consider actual availability.
I eventually went for a Yanagisawa 7 and a Légère Signature 2.5 reed I could order from a German online store. Untested.
Voilà.
This thingy is terrifying to play, rather shrill with very wild intonation. Although I'm used to Eb horns, I notice how I'm constantly surprised by the pitch. The keywork is challenging, specially the palm keys you keep hitting and opening by accident.
You are allowed NOT to click below, but after an hour of noodling, I tried a small video, on a Jobim standard. Tom, perdoe-me.

Nino esta Triste
 
Last edited:
I bought one. I really like it. Bought a Vandoren sopranino mouthpiece.
It bounds around like a puppy and is a first class hoot to play. Keeping the thing under control takes work, but it is a sopranino and you knew that before you bought it!
Would be intrigued to try a Yanagisawa, the Selmer would have to be full-on whizzo brilliant to tempt me at that price!
(My 1925 Selmer soprano is excellent so who knows? Happily it would mean a trip to London, a journey I feel disinclined to make)
 
We have many discussions/threads about whether we can hear the difference between this, that and the other.

If you transposed to soprano would it sound any different at all?

Also, apart from a handful of notes, you play right at the bottom of the instrument - that’s soprano territory.

You make a nice sound on it.

But I don’t understand the fascination with the horn if not being used for the upper register - like Baby Elephant Walk and Sanborn’s version of Ain’t No Sunshine with Sting.
 
……´

But I don’t understand the fascination with the horn if not being used for the upper register - like Baby Elephant Walk and Sanborn’s version of Ain’t No Sunshine with Sting.
Thanks for the comment and the observation. I very cautiously remained in the low register simply because the upper is obviously more demanding, at least for the untrained player.
I recorded literally 1 hour after unpacking the mouthpiece and reed.
I’ll need to spend some time playing long notes and scales all over the range, to get better control.
I still suspect that you can embrace most of the sopranino range with good technique on soprano. This only gives your question above more sense. Why play a sopranino ?
I don’t have the answer. And, btw, no fascination on my side. Just a mix of fun and curiosity. The horn could well just remain a rather uncommon object without (almost) any real use.
Speaking of David Sanborn, I’m sure he could play the common soprano range on alto. Why bother with a soprano ?
 
Speaking of David Sanborn, I’m sure he could play the common soprano range on alto. Why bother with a soprano ?
They sound different. He rarely played soprano. And to my knowledge only played sopranino on the track I mentioned.

I have to quantify my comments with the fact that I know little of the sopranino…
 
Sopranino doesn't sound soprano in the same wsy that alto doesn't sound like tenor.
My only point is that if it were not played in the upper reaches of the soprano, could you tell the difference pretty much every time - like you can between the other horns?

Again: @dexdex is having fun on it and making a lovely sound - so that’s justification in itself
 
My only point is that if it were not played in the upper reaches of the soprano, could you tell the difference pretty much every time - like you can between the other horns?
Dunno. Can't say I've tried. Certainly sounds different when i play it and on the few recordings I've done. There's not really an awful lot out there to compare.
 
My only point is that if it were not played in the upper reaches of the soprano, could you tell the difference pretty much every time - like you can between the other horns?

Again: @dexdex is having fun on it and making a lovely sound - so that’s justification in itself
Some of us work better in Eb. It ook me ages, I mean decades, to be comfortable on tenor and quite some time, though not as long to get soprano to work for me.

The lower register on nino is pitched the same as upper register on alto and I suspect an alto player may be more comfortable starting there.
I've heard that as our ears get older they lose sensitivity to the upper frequencies. Getting used to playing those high frequencies, in tune, may take some work. They're so very close together.

I assume the price of nino mouthpieces reflects the volume of sales and the fineness of production. If there's only a few thousandths between alto tip openings, I suppose only one or two on a nino piece.
Tiny reeds too.🔍🔎
 
@Wade Cornell plays head turning nino...

Wade?
Hi Ivan! Yes I'm here (sort of) just got back to New Zealand from Europe... jet lag!!!

I've played some pretty good Chinese ninos, which was a surprise to me at the time, I guess some of the makers I tried took the time to get it right, or just copy a good one. I personally prefer the Selmer sopranino HR mouthpieces, which are a lot less expensive than the Vandoren. I know of players who prefer the Vandoren, which is fairly bright and (I guess) suits what they want from a nino. My style of nino playing is mellow and certainly needs to be going into the high register. Sopraninos "cut" easily enough as it is, so playing too brightly can be... well, annoying.

Dexdex has played his nino really well for a nino novice. The trick with all the high pitch horns is to hear the note you're playing in order to get the embouchure right, especially the higher register. Dexdex is obviously an experienced ear player and knew the tune he was playing well, so could give the concentration necessary to hearing what he was playing. Where players get in trouble is reading and thinking the key pressed = having the note come out always in tune. With experience that can certainly happen, but will happen more quickly if you're using your ear and developing nino chops for the horn you have. The mellowest nino I've had/played was an old Buescher. The Selmers are also very mellow. Most of the newer horns are fairly bright, which can be mellowed (somewhat) by the right mouthpiece, and is my personal recommendation.

Reeds are always a personal preference and I'm a big fan of synthetics, but not (so far) on soprano and higher pitch horns. My personal preference is to use cane for the high pitch instruments although I've tried most all of the synthetics on soprano and higher. The tone of the Legere was not to my taste, which was very disappointing at the cost.

Off topic (slightly): The larger the reed the more inconsistencies one finds in the cross section of cane. The smaller cross section reeds (soprano and sopranino) have fewer anomolies, so you get a lot more consistency and playability from those smaller cane reeds. The tone is definitely better on these high pitch istruments using cane. However one can get used to anything and probably play passibly. Tenor and alto saxes are (for me) where the synthetics shine, but once again not using Legere. I prefer the Hartmann fiberreeds for tonal quality. The Legere only has an advantage in making more defined grades of hardness, and of course their customer policies are hard to beat. Legere are OK, but to my taste not a great sound. Of course there are also some fine cane reeds made for alto and tenor, yet they inherently lack the consistency and longevity I get from synthetics.

A soprnino definitely has a different timbre to a soprano. As others have said, it's nothing to do with the range, but just another distinctive voice. Played mellowly it can sing beautifully.

Here's some examples of variious ways a sopranino can play:
 
I was wondering what's the difference between the two Ninos?
The 350 and the Custom.
I just have the old VI Alto, but might like a budget Nino, if it will hold up to two or more hours of everyday playing.
Hate to waste $$$$.

Sold the Clarinets and Oboe long ago.
No regrets.
Nice to have a small size horn.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,443
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom