Saxophones the obscure, the overlooked

You make sweeping claims regarding the difference between clarinets made of differing materials while failing to notice the difference in their internal geometries, hence your assertions are false.
When I was younger, I might get upset with such statements.

For one, I shared an opinion. It is simply discussion. I don't claim to be any expert. And, I am not interested in getting into detailed academic discussions or splitting hairs between verbiage.

Therefore, I could really care less about what you think.
 
When I was younger, I might get upset with such statements.

For one, I shared an opinion. It is simply discussion. I don't claim to be any expert. And, I am not interested in getting into detailed academic discussions or splitting hairs between verbiage.

Therefore, I could really care less about what you think.

Geometry is not a detailed academic discussion - you were able to notice why some instruments sound different than others. There are no hairs to split. Wrong is wrong.

If you really don't care, then why did you ask?
 
Geometry is not a detailed academic discussion - you were able to notice why some instruments sound different than others. There are no hairs to split. Wrong is wrong.

If you really don't care, then why did you ask?
Very simply, I don't appreciate your fault finding. This is the last of my replies to you.
 
When one makes extraordinary assertions about technical matters, the burden is on the person making the extraordinary assertion to provide evidence.

In this case the assertion is that the thick rigid material of a clarinet somehow "resonates" in ways that make clarinets of different materials sound different, a) even when those playing and hearing them do NOT know which is which; and b) without any effects from the dimensions of the interior. This assertion is contrary to everything that's known about how single reed woodwinds produce sound. This is a technical asssertion, thus it is available for testing using the methods and evidence we use to test technical assertions (what is the melting point of silver? Is a mixture of 20% hydrogen and 80% air inflammable at atmospheric pressure? How many pounds can Mary Smith of Dubuque, Iowa bench press?)

Suitable evidence would be the testing of clarinets of different materials but identical (within normal tolerances) interior dimensions, where both player and listener are unaware of which material is involved. If it turns out that players or listeners are able to distinguish between the two materials more reliably than random chance, this would be an extraordinary result that would merit considerable further investigation.

I'm not going to trawl through the literature yet again, but every single time I've ever read a study of this type, the results have been "material doesn't matter". Coltman's concrete flutes, Backun's various clarinets, etc., etc., etc.

Vaporings about artistry and the meaning of life and music are just deflections from the fact that the people who swear up and down that material matters, when it comes to data - they ain't got NUTHIN'. In God we trust, all others bring data. Advertising claims, Youtube recordings where everyone already knows what's being played, statements from highly skilled professional musicians whose last exposure to science and testing was in eighth grade; none of these are data.
 
but please do it in a respectful and considerate way.
I agree, the Cafe seems to have evolved into somewhere that people can disagree while retaining respect for other people (in what they write) even when the argument isn’t apparently always backed up by facts.

As people may be aware, I’ve always argued that internal bore/shape etc makes the difference not the resonating of the material. Yet in spite of believing the science I still have a sneaky feeling that material can make a difference in other ways. E.g. the way it might form or bend slightly differently in the manufacturing process, or in the case of wood how rough or smooth the surface of the bore is.
 
Yet in spite of believing the science I still have a sneaky feeling that material can make a difference in other ways. E.g. the way it might form or bend slightly differently in the manufacturing process, or in the case of wood how rough or smooth the surface of the bore is.
I'm pretty sure The Science hasn't a problem with details of geometry nor, indeed, smooth/rough surfaces being significant. I'm pretty sure I've seen discussions of laminar flow in this context, for the latter.

For the other "materials" issues; what the art of doing science says is that you have to consider how strong the influence of one thing is compared to all the other factors.
For example; one might ask how quickly changes in bore and angle change acoustic properties and how fast surface hardness does.... And, indeed, whether variations in one would drown out variations in the other etc. Let alone variations in piles of other factors.

In short; maybe everything matters; but what can be neglected?

And the problem is that, sometimes, estimating what to consider and what to ignore is down to rough, back of envelope, calculations and experience.

Dr.G is an engineer so probably less inclined to neglect factors (to avoid things like buildings falling down etc) then, say, a theoretical physicist, who are happy to be with a factor of pi.

Personally, I'm quite prepared to believe that differences in hardness of metals and some plastics or wood make a negligible different in this context.
 
If science can't measure a difference it is only that, nothing more. People might interprete this differently on their own risk, as its a field with too much vaiables to make projections based on measurements.

Such a situation only becomes intresting to me when science can't measure anything and a significant number of people with a documented good hearing can hear a difference, I don't tink that anything intresting happened yet.
 
If science can't measure a difference it is only that, nothing more. People might interprete this differently on their own risk, as its a field with too much vaiables to make projections based on measurements.

Such a situation only becomes intresting to me when science can't measure anything and a significant number of people with a documented good hearing can hear a difference, I don't tink that anything intresting happened yet.
Well, there are perfectly valid scientific methods for dealing with sound that are not measurements. I've done many hundreds of jury tests of sound. An experiment with a skilled clarinetist who doesn't know what he's playing, and an audience of skilled musicians who don't know what's being played, asking them to judge first "same, or different?" and then "Better, equal, or worse?" is a perfectly valid experiment. In fact, given the extreme difficulty of looking at spectra and determining which differences are significant and which are not, a listening jury like I just described, a double-blind test, is probably the best way to assess the actual impact of different constructions. (It's not truly a double blind test if the experimenter knows what's being tested; shall we call it a single and a half blind test?)

Just a little anecdote: my wife recently tried out two different violas. To make her decision, I would play each one - same sequence of notes, short and simple - while switching randomly between the two. Sometimes "first viola" and "second viola" were actually the same instrument. Sometimes A was first in the pair; sometimes B was first in the pair. If I did B or A twice, I'd actually make sure to set the instrument down and then pick it up again so there wouldn't be cues from the amount of time or extraneous noises. She was sitting across the room with her back turned. So this wasn't a double blind experiment because I knew which one I was playing. And I didn't truly randomize the sampling, just made some patterns that looked "kind of" random. But it was a heck of a lot more controlled and random than the usual kind of test where everyone knows what's being played and then they - surprise, surprise - get exactly the results they're expecting.

And the interesting thing is that for two completely different instruments - different makers, slightly different dimensions, different strings, completely different violas - even then, she sometimes was not able to tell when two successive instruments were the same or different, or to identify which was which. Where with total random chance it would be 50% misidentification, I'd say her results were something like 15-20%.

The point is that even in a controlled experiment, the ability to discriminate between things, even things with major differences, is far from 100%. No one would argue that two violas made to different dimensions by different makers wouldn't be expected to sound repeatably different. Now if you take a factor that is inherently going to be have at MOST a tiny effect compared to the variation in other factors, you can pretty much guarantee that the ability of listeners (and players, in this case) to distinguish it will be very close to that of random chance, at BEST.

And yet players and manufacturers continue to make blanket, positive assertions about these supposed effects, and they NEVER NEVER NEVER attach any data. Why is that, do you think?
 
Now if you take a factor that is inherently going to be have at MOST a tiny effect compared to the variation in other factors, you can pretty much guarantee that the ability of listeners (and players, in this case) to distinguish it will be very close to that of random chance, at BEST.
I also did some technical triangle test as a chocolatier in a tomato ketchup imperium. It makes a lot of difference how skilled the testers are. Therefore it is essential to use documented capable testers.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,418
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom