Reeds The life and care of cane reeds

"during a practice or performance day"

I meant if the day has two or more sets or practice sessions spread out. For example, practice at 10 AM, then again at 5PM. Would you take off the reed, wipe it and clean the mouthpiece and/or the whole sax?

Ah, okay. In that case I always take the reed off, wipe it and put it back in the case. If you leave it on the 'piece you have no idea what shape it's going to be in by the time the show starts.
 
- how long a cane reed typically lasts for you
Variable dependant upon the quantity of rehearsal and performances on the agenda, but with rehearsal once per week, some ad-hoc home practise and 2.5 hr gigs every two weeks, 2-3 months tends to be the norm.

- what you do with it during a practice or performance day
take it out, dampen it in mouth for 30-60 seconds then attach.

- what you do overnight or between practice days
remove reed and return to reed case. It's a standard 4 reed holder but I like what I've heard about keeping them in vodka (I would prefer a nice single malt with a slightly peaty edge but I'm going off topic)

- how to see if a reed is in bad shape by looking at it
difficult to determine by sight, I've had the odd "wrinkled" tip reed that has had great playability and others that look perfect which are definitely dull and need a real push.

I tend to go back and forth with Vandoren Java ZZ and Java Green box and have found these to be pretty consistent. I do play them in at first by damping them for 1-2 mins, then smooth down the filed top of the reed with my thumb/finger nail (to press down and close the fibres) but after that it's just 30-60 seconds in the mouth before playing each time.

Seems to work OK for me, now where is the vodka?
 
Here's a link to the bible of obsessive reed adjustment.


here is a link on a simple and effective system


Having gone down both those rabbit holes including a year and a half study of the first one (including dial gauge, measuring platform multiple tools) and a few years on the second.....

There is no specific answer to how long, depends on how hard you play how hard the reed and how well adjusted is.

Cane expands and contracts.

I have played Legere Signature for several years now.
 
I invested heavily in Legere synthetics earlier, but rarely use them now. I do use Plasticovers occasionally, a 3 instead of the 2 1/2 I play in cane.
 
My process is quite simple. For alto I have a holder with three single Rico Reed Guards glued together that hold six reeds. For tenor and clarinet I have one that holds four reeds. The new ones all hold four reeds and only come in black.

I go through my reeds to find enough reeds that play well enough to perform on and put them in the reed guard. Each slot in the reed guard is given a number (harder when they only come in black).

Before playing the reeds are soaked in a prescription bottle with fresh water for no longer than 30 - 45 seconds and then put directly from the water into the reed guard. After a minute or two the reed has absorbed the correct amount of moisture, is perfectly flat on the end, and is ready to play.

As I play the reeds rotating them each practice session, I begin choose a hierarchy of reeds I like the most and eventually put them in order in the numbered slots. For practice I will rotate reeds 2 through 6 or 2 through 4 putting the reeds away in the reed guard when I am finished. For performing I go with reed 1. As my embouchure gets stronger with practice the reed selected as #1 can change.

After a time I will use my "reed geek" to flatten the back of each reed as the fibers swell. Wetting and rotating the reeds in this manner I find the reeds last a very long time. Of course if I were playing a gig every night the reeds would be rotated so I don't play #1 to death. This routine has served me well for many years.
 
I keep a bunch of them in a small plastic container with vodka. I guess they last a year or two.
I was chatting about this today with a guitar playing friend of mine. There is a very similar spread of opinions amongst guitarists concerning when to replace strings. I know ones who change the lot after a couple of gigs and ones who only change them when they break.
Anyway, back to reeds.
I bought some new reeds during lockdown cos I thought the ones I’d been playing might be nearing the end of their lives. I haven’t opened the boxes yet.
 
I have about 20 reeds scattered on the table in front of me, they will all play, some better than others, some not so well, but they all have some life in them so I don't throw them. For general day to day practice none of them deserve the bin, for serious playing in public I might be a bit wary, but some of them that were dogs may suddenly blossom.

So they last as long as I can get an acceptable sound out of them or they don't suddenly reveal their charms or they haven't gone so soft that they might discourage my embouchure. If I am practicing then as long as it plays well enough I'll use it unless I want to work on my sound, if it's something public I'll look for a new reed that I'm happy with.

I don't recommend anybody follow my reed management practice, it stinks.
 
This has been really interesting reading the differing views. Shame those who go for alcohol advocate Vodka, can't stand it myself much prefer Jack Daniels, would that be ok? 😉.
Total newbie barely two weeks in so still full of questions. My mouthpiece is an unknown make, came with the sax. reeds are Reco. I notice that the curve across the tip of the reed does not match the curve of the tip of the mouthpiece and wonder if this is important? Excellent posting very useful
 
Reco? Rico no longer exists. D'Addario took them over.
It is important that the mouthpiece and reed fit. The interaction between the reed tip and the mouthpiece tip rail is crucial.
Ditch the mouthpiece that came with the saxophone and invest in a Yamaha in a 4c or 5c opening or a Bari esprit. Both are cheap but well made pieces and will get you going in the right direction.
 
Reco? Rico no longer exists. D'Addario took them over.
It is important that the mouthpiece and reed fit. The interaction between the reed tip and the mouthpiece tip rail is crucial.
Ditch the mouthpiece that came with the saxophone and invest in a Yamaha in a 4c or 5c opening or a Bari esprit. Both are cheap but well made pieces and will get you going in the right direction.
IMG_2563.JPG

This is what arrived this week so is this old stock do you think?? I do agree I need a new mouthpiece but I'm on a bit of a budget so Teacher comes first.🙂
 
New reed: take out of box, soak, try. Adjust as needed. When done practicing, wipe off on pants, put in reed guard.

Old reed: take out of reed guard, wet in mouth or under faucet, play, when done, wipe off on pants, put in reed guard.

Old reed that's getting a bit soft: clip as needed, then possibly adjust as needed.
Old reed that warps to be convex on the back and no longer seals: scrape the back with a small knife, checking with a straightedge, till flat.

I throw them away when they split, when they get so tired that clipping and re-scraping won't do, when they get a chip on the tip deep enough I can't clip it away.

With regular playing (several practice sessions a week, plus say a gig every week or two, plus at least one rehearsal every week) they typically last me at least 6 months. When I'm regularly playing, I've probably got 8 reeds ready to go at any time.

When I get to the gig, I pull one out and play on it. It's quite rare that I'll change a reed in the course of a gig. Generally, if all the reeds play OK, the fact that they're a little different from each other is just something you adapt to in the first 5 minutes of playing.

Now if you like throwing away 9 out of 10 $7-$10 baritone reeds, you just go right ahead. Me, I'm not made of money, so I learned how to clip and scrape reeds. If you're sufficiently dextrous to play saxophone you're sufficiently dextrous to adjust a reed.

I don't subscribe to all the voodoo with humidifiers, mold-generating sealed containers, keeping them in a bath of vodka, Listerine, hydrogen peroxide, or unobtanium. I take the reed out of the reed guard, get it wet, play it, when I'm done I wipe it off, put into reed guard.

But what do I know? I've only been following this "routine" for 44 years now. if you even want to call it a "routine". By comparison with the incantations, exhortations, special baths, humidification and dehumidification, etc., etc.,e tc., protocols some folks follow, I think it hardly even rises to the level of a "routine",

Just one more possibly inflammatory comment:

Over the 44 years I've been playing saxophone, I have found that the times I have the most reed and horn and mouthpiece issues, are the times when I haven't been practicing regularly. Somehow when I start putting in the woodshed time several hours a week (or, best, several hours a day), magically all my reeds start playing, the mouthpiece doesn't need refacing, I don't need a new or different MP, the horn plays well from top to bottom. I wonder, is there possibly, just possibly, some relationship there?
 
Pretty much agree with @turf3 . I generally flatten the back with a lathe tool bit (cheap) or a reed geek (very expensive) or the edge of a machinists ruler (also cheap) after the first soak in water. I repeat as needed…

Regarding adjustment, I do test for side to side balance to guide my adjustment. (Newbies, don’t bother with this - wait until you have about 4-6 months of playing before “working on reeds”. ) Adjustment is done right away, i don’t believe in any break-in procedure. Usually the first adjustment is all that’s needed. maybe a small tweak the second or third time I play it. As it gets older, it might meet Mr. Clipper, but usually not.

I make no distinction between “practice reeds” and “gig reeds”. I will try a few in the venue for a performance, reeds do play differently in different environments, or maybe my level of anxiety makes ME play differently. My thinking on this is - why practice on a bad reed? Why play on a bad reed at all? Using my procedure. I usually get all reeds in a box to play well, maybe one in 20 won’t make the cut, usually because of some obvious defect, like bark up one side of the vamp. Slight differences reed to reed are gone within a few minutes, as I adjust to make “my sound”.
 
Just to add I did something, no one has mentioned, when I started; acknowledged that I'd probably sacrifice a good few reeds as I learned what routine suited me while sloshing through the variety of advice available.

No one got to the "this is what I do as an experienced player" stage without earning that experience.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,584
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom