Playing the saxophone The clarinet has changed my tenor reed strength!

How much quieter is the sax than the clarinet?

Is it possible to play real pianissimo on the sax (ie about the level of somebody speaking quietly) on the sax?

It’s very important learning to control any horn from pianissimo (pp) right through to fortissimo (ff). But bear in mind that a saxophone is going to be much louder than a clarinet. Not a problem for most but I have some issues.

As I mentioned in a previous thread, a harder reed helps attain the higher register easily whilst a softer reed will struggle more and visa versa on the lower register, in particular the bell notes. The reed strength also effects the dynamics as well.

This is my current problem. With such a wide tip opening (which in fact increases volume) a lower strength reed such as a Medium soft enabled me to play from pp to ff throughout the range of the horn. However, increasing the reed strength to Medium has changed that slightly. I can blow the horn easily at ff throughout the range but playing a pp on the bell notes is proving difficult. At the best I can get mezzo-forte (mf). However, practice should sort that out.

Hi Paul, not surprised playing clari has altered your tenor embouchure. I always get a beneficial effect from playing either sop or alto. Pete

Thanks Pete 😀
 
Took my Velo sporting chair in the early sixties, so the instructions were, "Pull back a bit, then accelerate like hell up those two steep planks and turn right at the top.".

Wonder what Elf and Safety would say about it?

Even better was the year Sidecar Champion Max Deubel's van broke down. They stuck trade plates on the Beemer and drove through the Mersey Tunnel on it. Real music.
 
🙂))🙂))..The thought of Paul with Clarinet and bowler hat, playing trad jazz to a load of bikers..🙂))🙂)

You would be suprised to see how many motorbike fans are jazz lovers ;}

( I already know four personally, myself not included )
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've just starting playing Bb clarinet and after a whole week playing solely clarinet everyday for a few hours when I picked up my sax today I was a wee bit tentative - had I undone some sax skills with all thing clarinet malarky...?

I blew the poor sax's ar$e off!

Man, I was blasting air through that thing! My SML is loud as it is, especially if I'm playing my Bergs, but with clarinet chops I'm bloody dangerous! 😀
And I had stamina like never before. My embouchure didn't weaken at all after 2 solid hours. I generally wear out after an hour and half (I'm only new to this horn game).

My current alto sax reed is usually a Java Red 2.5 and Rico Jazz Select 2H on my Link 7 and Berg 100 respectively.
I think I'll move up to a 3 and 3S! :mrcool

I also think my fingers were more nimble and much more precise on the pinky keys.
Great all-round work out the ol' clarinet! :thumb:
 
Remember the cranes at Douglas? Only happened to me once and I was lucky, but the guys just after me watched their bikes get smashed together...
Bloody hell Kev, how can you remember that? Your only a bit older than me, what year was that? we did it in 93 on mountain bikes, did the course on the Thursday as the racing doesn't happen then, and enjoyed the rest of the time sight seeing and getting sozzled! did 94 & 95 on sports bikes, once from Heysham, once from Liverpool (my mate split his tyre on the loading ramp at Liverpool and Steam packet paid for it to be replaced) ahh, fond memories......
 
I've just starting playing Bb clarinet and after a whole week playing solely clarinet everyday for a few hours when I picked up my sax today I was a wee bit tentative - had I undone some sax skills with all thing clarinet malarky...?

I blew the poor sax's ar$e off!

Man, I was blasting air through that thing! My SML is loud as it is, especially if I'm playing my Bergs, but with clarinet chops I'm bloody dangerous! 😀
And I had stamina like never before. My embouchure didn't weaken at all after 2 solid hours. I generally wear out after an hour and half (I'm only new to this horn game).

My current alto sax reed is usually a Java Red 2.5 and Rico Jazz Select 2H on my Link 7 and Berg 100 respectively.
I think I'll move up to a 3 and 3S! :mrcool

I also think my fingers were more nimble and much more precise on the pinky keys.
Great all-round work out the ol' clarinet! :thumb:

There’s no doubt playing the clarinet improves one’s dexterity :w00t:

Your experiences seem to mirror my own. :thumb: Alternating between the two every ten minutes is proving very hard work but I am steadily improving though. On the sax I can get a decent pianissimo on D4 now. From C3 to Bb3 I’m blowing an even mezzo-forte. It’s getting quieter each day. With the clarinet I’m struggling more with the Lower Altissimo Register mainly from E6 to G6. However, this has made playing the Upper Altissimo on the saxophone much easier. I’m play F#7 to C8 but I am biting a smidge. Some notes are speaking more clearly than others and I’m seem to be playing them all at fortissimo!!

Doubling on the clarinet and tenor saxophone is quite challenging as one is affecting the other. I’m hoping my perseverance will make me a solid player on both in the long run!

I'm currently playing both from a scores written in C it is tasking the grey matter as I’m constantly thinking a Bb Clarinet is a major second lower than written (two semitones) whilst the Tenor Saxophone is a major ninth (an octave and a major second) lower than written :w00t:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
How much quieter is the sax than the clarinet?

Is it possible to play real pianissimo on the sax (ie about the level of somebody speaking quietly) on the sax?

The sax is not quieter than the clarinet. Although you can certainly play ppp on the sax, it's not nearly as easily controllable at minimum volume than the clarinet. Bell notes are v v difficult on the sax at low volumes, whereas the clarinet's a doddle. That said, that may be the only thing that's easier on the clarinet!
 
There’s no doubt playing the clarinet improves one’s dexterity :w00t:

Your experiences seem to mirror my own. :thumb: Alternating between the two every ten minutes is proving very hard work but I am steadily improving though. On the sax I can get a decent pianissimo on D4 now. From C3 to Bb3 I’m blowing an even mezzo-forte. It’s getting quieter each day. With the clarinet I’m struggling more with the Lower Altissimo Register mainly from E6 to G6. However, this has made playing the Upper Altissimo on the saxophone much easier. I’m play F#7 to C8 but I am biting a smidge. Some notes are speaking more clearly than others and I’m seem to be playing them all at fortissimo!!

Doubling on the clarinet and tenor saxophone is quite challenging as one is affecting the other. I’m hoping my perseverance will make me a solid player on both in the long run!

I'm currently playing both from a scores written in C it is tasking the grey matter as I’m constantly thinking a Bb Clarinet is a major second lower than written (two semitones) whilst the Tenor Saxophone is a major ninth (an octave and a major second) lower than written :w00t:

The three instruments I play are mainly bari (natch), soprano sax and, increasingly, clarinet. I find that switching between clarinet and bari is significantly easier in terms of maintaining intonation than switching between soprano and bari.

The clarinet always sounds relatively rather mute after having put the bari down, but the adjustment to soprano is trickier. In fact, I find that it's best to have a cup of tea between playing bari and picking up the soprano - if I go straight to it my intonation is very wayward for the first few minutes.

No shame in that, though. I read somewhere that Coltrane eventually decided not to switch between horns on gigs. Either he was playing tenor, or soprano, but not both.
 
The only thing the clarinet changed for me was my will to live...................................:crying:

Ha! I know what you mean - but I'm taking a perverse pleasure from playing clarinet. When it's done right (I'm not saying that I do) it's such a beautiful instrument. Somebody posted a link on another thread to Paquito d'Riveira playing "I remember Diz" on Youtube - that kind of playing is very inspirational.

Bill
 
The three instruments I play are mainly bari (natch), soprano sax and, increasingly, clarinet. I find that switching between clarinet and bari is significantly easier in terms of maintaining intonation than switching between soprano and bari.

The clarinet always sounds relatively rather mute after having put the bari down, but the adjustment to soprano is trickier. In fact, I find that it's best to have a cup of tea between playing bari and picking up the soprano - if I go straight to it my intonation is very wayward for the first few minutes.

No shame in that, though. I read somewhere that Coltrane eventually decided not to switch between horns on gigs. Either he was playing tenor, or soprano, but not both.

Good morning Baritonesax! I was thinking of you.

In theory I agree with Coltrane, but unfortunately we are often required to switch horn for just a few bars (Vince Mendoza is one of the worst offenders).
And often the bari chair requires: flute, Bb clarinet, bass clarinet and, if you are really lucky, alto sax.

Switching instrument is a skill that need to be achieved: my worst sound ever is the one that comes out of my flute after I played soprano.

And saxophone hasn't been created to play softly. It is supposed to cover the voice of those American girls sitting at the table near the toilet door.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,684
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom