Theory & Impro The benefits of using one tension at a time. Here's the #11

Messages
513
Location
rome
Hi, a very valuable tool in improvisation is creating "tension and release" effect.
You can start to understand this mechanism in phraing by altering the V7 and resolving to the I.
There are many altered tensions that you can use, so I like practicing them one at a time, to figure out the color that every tension has.
Here I discussed about the #11.
Hope you enjoy the video, bye.
Fabrizio
P.S. Turn on English subtitles in the menu

View: https://youtu.be/OtSZmWAeyic?si=dT6Anmi4PyfdvWVB
 
I think it's a great idea to work on each altered extension at a time instead of through yourself into a whole sea of them. This way you can understand the melodic tendencies of each and how to best to resolve any specific tension - after all, a big part of music is about tension and release.

Sure you get people learning the so-called altered scale and throw it over a dominant because it sounds like jazz. It's a shortcut to playing those clever notes but not necessarily to understand each one's character and how they can be used melodically to create more of the tension/release thing.

However I think it's worth thinking about whether a #11 is the same as a #4. Or rather is a #4 the same as a ♭5?

So for example (rightly or wrongly) I like to think of a #11 as a note that leads up a semitone, and a ♭5 is one that leads down a semitone. ie each has a different melodic tendency for a resolution (not that notes have to resolve, just that it's always good to be aware of how they might out might not resolve.
 
Thanks for your interesting reply @Pete Thomas
The key element, in my opinion is getting used to the sound of tension by repeating just one of them.
In this way we train our ears and become aware of the color of each tension, as you stated.

You wrote "Sure you get people learning the so-called altered scale and throw it over a dominant because it sounds like jazz. It's a shortcut to playing those clever notes but not necessarily to understand each one's character and how they can be used melodically to create more of the tension/release thing."
However I think it's worth thinking about whether a #11 is the same as a #4. Or rather is a #4 the same as a ♭5?

I dont know, I personally think a b5 resolving up a semintone to the 3rd of a major chord as more usual, but it depends on the situation. I think it's worth naming the same tension differently when composing, but maybe it's just me...
Personally i reckon that a lot of "hearing and resolving" tension aspect is created between the interaction between soloist and comping of piano/guitar player. In this way practicing on a backing track and playing with real musicians can be very different!
 
I think that you’re making the spelling of the chord symbols functional then. This could be a good thing and aid sight reading but if you get pretty “stacked-up” with extensions I’m not sure it would be too easy to adhere to it.

It’s only a guideline though, and various chord players will interpret changes differently.

Take Am7b5:

A, C, Eb, G.

A typical Am7b5 for Bill Evans was:

A, Eb, G, B, D

Quite different in colour. What is it, Am11b5? I dunno, but I’ve never seen the chord I just wrote. This is where chords get ambiguous and can no longer adequately describe in full what is wanted.
 
Yes, from a wider, more sophisticated musical perspective you are right @Pete Effamy but in this video I discussed something more basic.
If you want to start improvising, rather than just use a scale that contains all altered tensions, you can start by using just one of them.
In this way you also train your ears to that particular tension, its sound and ho to resolve it.

Then you can start thinking about chord voicings, like the nice one by Bill Evans you wrote!
 
Yes, from a wider, more sophisticated musical perspective you are right @Pete Effamy but in this video I discussed something more basic.
If you want to start improvising, rather than just use a scale that contains all altered tensions, you can start by using just one of them.
In this way you also train your ears to that particular tension, its sound and ho to resolve it.

Then you can start thinking about chord voicings, like the nice one by Bill Evans you wrote!
Yes sorry, I got carried away.
It’s a good way to approach this, and fortunately in these digital days we can create many bars of a vamp dedicated to one chord so that we can get a hold of it before it moves somewhere else.
 
I dont know, I personally think a b5 resolving up a semintone to the 3rd of a major chord as more usual,
Put that in context, e.g. G7 ♭5 is G B D♭ F. To me, the D♭ resolves down a semitone to the root of a C (major or minor). It is the F that resolves down to the E of a C major or the E♭ of a C minor.
 
Yes, Pete, but generally speaking I rarely resolve on the root of a major 7th chord.
So I personally consider more Db to D, the 9th.
Of course it depends on the tune, sometimes Db to C can be ok.
On a minor chord resolving on the root is always a fine option.
The F can resolve down to E or up to F#, the #11 on a Cmaj7.
 
With Gm7b5 - C (C6/9 or C7) - if you resolve the b5 to a C you most likely end up doubling the root in the C chord rather than a more useful 9th?
 
Oh yes! Now there’s a thing - I read it as m7b5 as I’m not used to seeing 7b5 and I don’t think that way.

Not that it matters. But with it being G7b5 - I still wouldn’t want to dip to C. I don’t like too many roots
 
A conundrum for me is when there is a fair amount of harmonic movement, finding the right time to spell enharmonically for ease of reading. Then there are the transposing instruments - some might be in # keys and some in flat, which could be nicer to read but confusing to talk about with one another.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,431
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom