Miscellaneous The alto sax, as it relates to the ear.

I have studiously listened to all the supplied tracks, youtubes, references etc. yes, I actually have.

My verdict:

Still pretty foghorn-like but there are some good players out there who can take the edge off it. The comment on the post with the trumpet and the alto sax is spot-on in that the trumpet walks all over the alto. In my band the brass (we decided long ago that the fact that the sax is a woodwind was too boring to differentiate) consists of me on tenor and another on trumpet and it works well. Have a listen and a bit of applause goes to the clever person who remarks on the instrumentation that occurs during the tenor sax solo about half-way through that is relevant to this thread.

http://martin-j.webs.com/TVA_Tracks/Going%20to%20the%20Shops.mp3

I do play alto as well as tenor -- but not so much -- and will continue to do so but I wonder if I am trying to make it like a higher-pitched tenor and am doomed to failure from the start because the instruments are too different.

I like debate, keep it going.

I still wonder if, because I like the lower-toned instruments, the baritone is the one for me -- it's an expensive trial though.

Martin
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I just cannot agree with the foghorn analogy. I have lived by seas and waterways; practically all the foghorns I have heard have sounded more like a tenor than an alto .... maybe the bottom few notes of the alto.

As someone said 'honky' I can understand ... but it is a style of playing rather than the inherent sound of the instrument, and equally applicable to the tenor ....personally, I find the squawky, honky, screechy way in which all saxes CAN be played to be hideous.
Just listen to a good 'altoist' playing classical music ... it is beautiful 🙂
 
That was a point I was making earlier, so feel that you are not being flippant, OG. On the Forum the majority of folks cut their teeth on Alto and many move on to Tenor, by which time their playing & motivation has probably developed. So they start on a harder instrument to produce a good sound on, then move on to one which is more forgiving sound wise - Simples! When I started on Tenor after Alto I must admit I played it like a large Alto to start with.

I must admit I have not personally experienced the Alto as a Foghorn like implement - I started on a Selmer Super Session mouthpiece which had more of a Tenor quality to it, and have only just added a Jumbo Java A55 to the mix, out of curiosity.
 
I find the foghorn description a bit puzzling too. Most of the issues I have with alto are due to the large number of players who take Charlie Parker as a role model - but that's to do with what they play rather than the sound. I was turned on to sax playing by an alto/sop player (Elton Dean) and probably listen most to the funk trinity Sanborn/Parker/Dulfer. My own playing of alto is a bit more problematic since I still don't have a well defined sense of what I'm trying to achieve with it in terms of sound (unlike sop/tenor/bari). Although, having said that, I'm quite happy with my current set up of Keilwerth SX90R and an ebonite Lawton 7*B.
 
The comment on the post with the trumpet and the alto sax is spot-on in that the trumpet walks all over the alto.

It does if you try to play the alto like a trumpet (or, as you said, like a tenor). Seems to me the opposite is going on here: the trumpet(s) trying to pay like saxophone(s). I can't hear any foghorns, though.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
It does if you try to play the alto like a trumpet (or, as you said, like a tenor). Seems to me the opposite is going on here: the trumpet(s) trying to pay like saxophone(s). I can't hear any foghorns, though.


I take back some of what I have said, just a little. This is a nice sound, I think it is because the attack on each note is extremely well controlled, there is no hint of 'honk' in it. Also there is some beautifully controlled vibrato.

At 1'34 he jumps up an octave and I have heard many players really hammer the second note when doing this but this guy has it down delightfully.

It's good, I like it. It reminds me of smokey nights at the Cotton Club (not that I was there but I did see the film).

Cheers for that

Martin
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That was a point I was making earlier, so feel that you are not being flippant, OG.

Kev,
Willingly hold out my wrist for slapping for winding up young rawr but as Tom is agreeing without any further limitations, that I am a crap player, my honour has been impugned.

Would you please act as my second in a lava bread and wimberry tart duel at dawn under CaSLM rules, providing Mapfumo accepts the challenge?

Apologies for being serious.
 
Remember that Benny Carter also played trumpet and even if he is not himself doubling on trumpet on that track - perhaps unlikely -he probably wrote the chart and wanted it to sound that way. But a great example of a beautiful tone.

Hodges too of course. I think it was Alyn Shipton who spoke of him as "raking the audience with his ravishing tone".

Thank you OG for the comments on the Mauriat's low notes. Strangely I hear the C2 and C#2 as rather sour tones on that particular horn, but I think it is just me as no-one else does.

I am disturbed by this talk of more duelling. At least it's not me who's seconding this time; I just can't be bothered to get out of bed at dawn for that anymore. But Tom, if you accept, please mind his fingers. It's nothing to do with sax playing, it's that he's got to get into his wallet to buy me and Griff a drink soon.
YC
 
Kev,
Willingly hold out my wrist for slapping for winding up young rawr but as Tom is agreeing without any further limitations, that I am a crap player, my honour has been impugned.

Would you please act as my second in a lava bread and wimberry tart duel at dawn under CaSLM rules, providing Mapfumo accepts the challenge?

Apologies for being serious.

I couldn't possibly do that. You backed out of giving me satisfaction with blunderbusses and hot air balloons, remember? :shocked:

There'd be no justice for Tom under CaSLM rules, as I'm sure you'd make up and change as needed during the event. :headscratch:

Besides which, you're old enough to sort out Tom, without resorting to duelling. The pen is mightier than the sword - or in this case keyboard and wimberry tart. :popcorn:
 
yes there is that horrible recording of Bird palying Loverman when he was off his head, being forced to fulfill some recording contract as I understand it.


Hey !...I love that take of Loverman. I am sure Bird would have rather it had gone in the bin. But I have always been somewhat mesmorised buy some of the phrases.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oNL30u1jbDM
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,653
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom