There’s definitely a strong element of this Mike - it’s an insightful comment. I play so much classical Bari and alto that I know exactly what I want / expect to hear from either myself or others. Hearing something classical romp down a tenor just feels wrong at times.
Ah, thanks for your response, @SaxBySW! It's always great to hear that my 'maybe completely bonkers' comments may not (always) be so bonkers after all
🙂
FWIW, I play in a couple of Big Bands that don't exclusively play traditional 1940's-50's Big Band (swing) music but also more modern pop and rock arrangements and even relatively 'classic-sounding' film music themes. Throughout any concerts, pretty much all instrument groups get the opportunity to solo on various tunes: trumpets, trombones, guitar, keyboards, bass, drums and also the various sax players (alt, tenor and bari). Personally, I find that each instrument group has its own unique 'sound and vibe'. The same applies to the various sax players. After so many years of playing tenor, my ears are - 'attuned' to the tenor sax range. So some alt and bari solos sound really great to me. Others (alt) sound a bit 'shrill/thin' or (bari) a bit 'down in the depths'.
I assume that you play both alt and bari much better than my 'very amateur' colleagues! The main thing I like about tenor sax is that I IMHO can get pretty much the best of both (alt +bari) worlds for solos. I haven't worked out the frequency ranges but to my (tenor-attuned) ears, I can get reasonably close to the 'high notes' that my alt sax colleagues typically play. I can also play 'low notes' that my bari sax colleagues often play on solos. This may well be a reflection on the tonal ranges that my 'alt and bari' colleagues typically play on solos. But (again just offering a thought that maybe be bonkers), my impression is that our typical audiences recognize when soloists play 'high notes' and 'low notes' and the range covered in any solo. They probably don't (subjectively) recognize 'how high' or 'how low' the notes actually are. To be perfectly honest, the types of audiences that we - as an amateur Big Band - play to probably don't discriminate too much on solo's as long as they sound 'musical' and 'competent'. Our main aim is to get the 'timing' and 'dynamics' (=expressiveness) right.
However it goes on tenor sax, I wish you the very best. If it turns out that the tenor is just not for you, then at least you've given it a go. The tenor may encourage you to branch out into other music genres.
Mike
PS Long ago, my initial sax practices were on 'etudes' and classical pieces. For which I'm still very grateful! Last week, our current Big Band trombone player mentioned that he was doing the same at his music lessons. So again, classical players can learn a lot from playing jazz/blues. Jazz/blues players can also learn from playing classical pieces. IMHO (as a onetime beginner), classical pieces are 'less forgiving' in terms of laziness in timing, articulation and dynamics than some jazz/blues pieces (where some subjective interpretation is common)