Playing the saxophone Tenor or Alto for populair covers

Jacque

Member
Messages
12
Location
Germany
I have a question for you whether I should start on tenor or alto for the music I like.
I'm an adult so the size of the instrument does not matter.

The deep tenor sound is something I love in jazz songs. And generally in all comparison video's the tenor sax speaks to me.
However I also like to start playing pop covers and play along with a dj. Is this also possible with a tenor. And I understand that everything is possible but is it logically to do so?
Or is the alto just much better suited for this genre. I cannot find any examples on YouTube.
This is a pop cover I like:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HUJ1EpSFrnA


And this deep house:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GhpXgQ8TOUA


Looking forward to your thoughts!

Michael
 
Just for my own education... Seems to me both those players tend to sit in the second register if the tenor so overlap with the alto range. No?

It also overlays with the sop in that range.

It really comes down to what voice you prefer to hear, what voice best represents the sounds in your head.
 
Well, everyone hears alto in this kind of thing ever since Sanborn. But before him there were folks like King Curtis, Lenny Pickett, etc. doing very similar things on tenor.

I am reminded of the old line:

"Those who like this sort of thing, will find this the sort of thing they like." If those first two videos had been made by old fat bald guys would you be as interested?
 
For the beginner:

Alto saxophones and alto saxophone specific accessories are cheaper than other saxophones.

Worth bearing in mind a lot of the DJ videos make use of recording effects that won't reflect the true sound of the saxophone.

As others have said though either Alto or Tenor would be fine to start on and it doesn't take much to adjust from one to the other. I enjoy playing both as they are different enough from eachother to maintain my interest. I've also recently got a soprano as well.
 
I find that for that kind of music, alto seems to sit in the mix better for me. Tenor can definitely work, but there's much more alto in that scene nowadays.
 
Sure. But the OP asked about auto - and, to my crappy ears, it sounded like the tenors in the post it Saxlicker where playing in much the same rage as The altos in the OP.
Yes the overlap is there and the Tenor is in that range but offering a bit of a different energy and vibe than the alto.
So that should confirm what you were thinking.
But Dr G simply explained on the extent of the overlap gets into soprano territory too which is additional education especially if you can tell me when 😳:rofl:.
I'm not going to try,
 
It is important to know that the range of each saxophone is about 2.5 octaves and the diference between the adjecent types of sax (like tenor and alto, or alto and soprano) is about 1/2 octave.
So there is an very large overlap between these saxes as far as dynamic range is concerned.
It is quite clearly illustrated in this picture. You should look at the right side of the picture (sounding range)
even between the baritone and the soprano you have about an octave overlap.
So I would think that your choice should be more driven by what kind of sound you like, the sonority of the diferent saxes is quite different.
And in the long term, once you have learnt how to play a proper sax, you could perhaps use that knowledge to play an electronic sax to play along with electronic music. I would not recomend starting on such an instrument because you would miss out on some important aspects of playing the saxophone.
 
I hate to say it but the videos that you posted are of advanced players. You are probably gonna put in a lot of hours / years to play like those two. I have only been at it for a year but it is not just the genre but keys. Some songs will be easier on a Bb and some on an Eb sax. The really good sax players that I have watched use both depending upon what they are playing. It is something that you will have to do every day, day in and day out, year after year if you want to play like those two ladies, with the foreknowledge that you many never be that good.
 
Last edited:
Depends a bit on what you want to play. I had for a few months lessons with a teacher who is doing this professionally with a DJ using exclusively alto. For his type of party music alto is the only fitting size, at least to my ears. There are a few examples on his homepage. Really cool for effect is the led lit transparent vibratosax. He has been doing it for years. Don't expect it to be easy.

Saxobeatz
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,610
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom