Saxophones Tenor for player with small hands.

mpjbiker

Member
Messages
240
Location
Hastings, East Sussex
My partner has very small hands, and physically can't reach the left hand table on my 66R. My series 111 Selmer is not much better, so what she needs is a tenor with really low palm keys and a really close left hand table. Any suggestions gratefully received, cheers!
 
In my experience Yamaha saxophones are comfortable for players with smaller hands.
I know that most school districts in my area use Yamaha tenors and baris in their middle school programs for this reason.
If you have a shop nearby that carries Yamaha it might be worth a visit and quick test play.
 
Thinking outloud - would there be any options for customisation if you know of a decent tech:

Customise the octave key touch piece -extend to the left to rotate the hand position round more more.

Or perhaps remove the palm keys and see if she can reach the table keys otherwise and then see if there is enough room to cut down the palm key heights.
 
Yamaha re-positioned the lefthand table some years ago as far as I remember. It is a bit closer to the other keys in their current models. If you have a shop around let her try and be aware of potential differences of older series of the same model when going used. Another manufacturers would be Yanagisawa.

Alphorn
 
Thanks for all replies-yes, she's tried my old Pan-Am tenor. The palm keys are lower, but the American style left hand table confuses her, and the additional pressure to depress the C sharp in particular is difficult for her. A new horn is out of the question, really, so it may just be a question of seeing what comes up.
 
Would she happen to be your partner?
e5fceb93157f065cea2ccce49b844b29.jpg


But seriously, when I was in school, seems like the smallest girl in the band always played bari, and she managed to play it just fine. So I'm with @Colin the Bear , it's probably just a matter of hand position rather than key position. Any sax should work fine for even very small hands with the proper technique.
 
Would she happen to be your partner?
e5fceb93157f065cea2ccce49b844b29.jpg


But seriously, when I was in school, seems like the smallest girl in the band always played bari, and she managed to play it just fine. So I'm with @Colin the Bear , it's probably just a matter of hand position rather than key position. Any sax should work fine for even very small hands with the proper technique.
I second that. Otherwise, try a c-mel, they are smaller than tenors >:)
 
The rods and levers connecting up the keywork make the finger buttons more or less the same distance apart, relative to eachother, on most horns.
The bigger the horn, the further apart left hand and right hand are but fingers maintain the same relative position.

Switching from an old Corton to a modern G4m presented no problems but picking up the old Corton for a nostalgic blow, I was surprised to find my pinky completely missing the table. Even for G#.
I'd never noticed the hand acrobatics needed when playing it daily.
Playing yas 25 and yts 25 currently and the Thomann 580. No problems.
Big hands but short fingers. (I think it's a baboon gene.)

Sling position helps too. So many beginners play so low.
 
The rods and levers connecting up the keywork make the finger buttons more or less the same distance apart, relative to eachother, on most horns.
The bigger the horn, the further apart left hand and right hand are but fingers maintain the same relative position.

Switching from an old Corton to a modern G4m presented no problems but picking up the old Corton for a nostalgic blow, I was surprised to find my pinky completely missing the table. Even for G#.
I'd never noticed the hand acrobatics needed when playing it daily.
Playing yas 25 and yts 25 currently and the Thomann 580. No problems.
Big hands but short fingers. (I think it's a baboon gene.)

Sling position helps too. So many beginners play so low.
I thought it was Ursula, I mean ursa minor
 
but the American style left hand table confuses her, and the additional pressure to depress the C sharp in particular is difficult for her.

The pinky of my left hand just reaches the line between second and third finger joint of the ring finger. I find the pinky tables with the C#,B and Bflat keys in line more comfortable than the tables where the B flat key is below the C# and B.

It is possible to lower the treshold pressure of the C# key by adjustment of the springs for low C# and G# but there are two or three pitfals. Both C# and G# become more sensitive to sticky pads and when the C# spring is set too soft the low C# can start to oscilate on its own when playing the low C, low B and low Bflat.
 
Thanks for all replies-yes, she's tried my old Pan-Am tenor. The palm keys are lower, but the American style left hand table confuses her, and the additional pressure to depress the C sharp in particular is difficult for her. A new horn is out of the question, really, so it may just be a question of seeing what comes up.

OK. That was just a test for palm key heights. FWIW, the “American” table varies widely. The tables of Buescher TH&C and Aristocrats made in the same era are vastly different to me (I owned one of each at the same time).

That’s the good news then, for the trend of high palm keys started much later in the evolution of tenors. The horn that so many companies tried to copy, the Selmer Mk VI, had low(er) palm keys and the now-ubiquitous tilting pinky table.
 
I've done a couple of palm key reductions for women with smaller hands. It's not too difficult to chop them down a bit and solder them back together.
Yamaha is the stock answer for smaller hands. They usually work for children so ... ...
Older horns do have smaller palm keys. Martins etc are good - but if the different keywork is such a problem then you might have to go for chopping the keys.
Do check her hand postions though. I've seen some players struggle and when I watch their hands - they're not holding the hand in a good position so they won't get round the keys.
To some extent you can bend the keys to make things easier, but it's best to let a repair have a look so they can do it so nothing breaks.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,676
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom