compound
Member
- Messages
- 401
- Location
- Manchester.
Nice one zannad, glad you got sorted, lets hope no more dints in your horns as well.
Rob.
Rob.
I'm surprised too....I guess is a temporary glitch (nearly 10 months by now?) due to personal problems - still for the last job I paid £190 for having all the key of a Yani T901 tenor sax replaced (as he had another one in store completely trashed but brand new and with most keys intact) - when I went to the shop to collect it I found out there where only 5 new keys?! 3 of these are the top palm key which are easy peasy (anyone could do it) and effectively he replaced only 2 at the bottom of the horn. I have to mention that I myself have dismantled and cleaned my Yani and old keys (so he had only to put the new keys) oh, and I gave him the old keys too...now that isn't just a botched job but a complete insult to his profession. There was a clear verbal agreement - all new keys had to be replaced...then he changed his mind halfway?!
Time to go elsewhere - my 15 odd saxes need better hands....in fact I've also noticed some tiny poke marks (tiny dings) appearing mysteriously here and there in a couple of saxes...something is wrong with his bench I suppose.
Hi Zannad
I'm very sorry to hear you have not been pleased with John Clarks work for you,and before I say anything I would like to say that John is not a personal friend of mine so I have no reason to defefend him, and only have my own personal experience to go on.Some time ago I purchased an old italian tenor sax on ebay that was somewhat dilapidated,being quite new to saxes and interested in the technical aspects I thought it would be nice to strip it down and delacquer it and polish it and have it rebuilt I consulted john and he was happy to take all the bits in a box after I had finished my polishing, and he would re-assemble it with the pads of my choice, these being black roo pads supplied by him and all new blue springs and corks and set up to play to it's best,for this work he would charge me £400 which I considered was a fair price for the work involved.I have to say that I was in no hurry to get it back and he said it would have to wait it's turn in the queue but would probably be about 4 weeks, now to my mind that in itself is a good way to gauge if a tech is any good,as in all walks of life if someones got lots of work he can't possibly be a bad tradesman,After the 4 weeks the sax was ready to be picked up and I found it in it's case wrapped in new paper.The sax was in perfect order and played extremely well with a light action and lovelly tone, I was very pleased with the result and so would still be pepared to recommend John's services to any body,now at this point I would like to say that I am not a sax tech myself even though for some reason in one of your posts you have listed me as one, when in fact Kev only pionted you in my direction because my tutor is also a sax tech as well.
I like you have stripped down a number of saxes and cleaned them and re-built them with some success but would never consider myself to be an expert and I am somewhat surprised by your remarks that you think that changing the keys from one sax to another would in your opinion just be a case of unscrewing them off one sax and screwing them on the new sax,for goodness sake get real, if you honestly think that then it's no wonder that you have very little appreciation of the tech's skill.
It seems to me to be an absolute bargain for a tech to suply and fit and regulate a whole set of keys for £190 I dread to think what it would cost buy a complete set of keys for your Yanni but perhaps john should just give them away for nothing to you because he happens to have them,the other thought that comes to mind is that john with all his years of experience may have considered that it would be better to correct the original keys than replace them with cannibalised parts.
I find it very disapointing that people can set about trashing someones reputation because of their own misguided ideas.
Glad, you should read my messages...
The guy only changed 5 keys!! - I repeat: 5 KEYS! you get it now? 3 of these were the palm keys on top which are very easy to set as they aren't linked.
Since he left the job halfway (for his own reasons and this alone isn't very professional) - I myself have fitted all other keys!! Not to mention that I have stripped and cleaned most keys from both saxes (do you get it now?) - and the guy got all my keys (from my older Yani) for the shinier keys of his broken but newer Yani - in other words I swapped all my keys for shinier ones and got 5 keys mounted by him on my Yani...all that for £180!! It's a rip off.
Guys, is this going anywhere? Looks like two different opinions chasing each other round in circles to me
Absolutely Kev but in the meantime a very well respected tech with years of experience and like I said before one of the most obliging blokes I have met is getting his reputation trashed on this forum,If you read between the lines Zannad admits to being allowed to use the facilities of john's workshop to work on his own saxes,and then when something hasn't gone as he would have liked has decided to have a go at him and maybe I'm wrong but I just don't think that is fair...john
