Miscellaneous Talent/Time

There are a couple of mathematicians here.....>:) 🙂)) :w00t:

A friend who's an engineer, and a friend who's an actuary both told me there was a strong link/affinity between maths and music. Both had to decide whether to pursue a career in music, or otherwise.... One took a degree in maths and music, the other chose a technical career.:mrcool


Agreed - two groups that are often good musicians are mathematicians and medics (choral society has 3 GPs, 5 consultant surgeons and numerous nurses; MD of chamber choir is a professor of medicine; conductor of a local amateur orchestra is a transplant surgeon)
 
But what is 'talent' ?
I have a good memory and an ear for pitch, and can remember tunes after only a few playings(but only if I like them, and find them 'tuneful'!).
OTOH, I do not have 'nimble fingers'....especially at my advanced age!.... so have difficulty with playing quickly.
And I find musical theory to be like learning Japanese .... my eyes glaze after a few pages of every theory book I have picked-up.
Also, I do not have the patience, discipline and motivation to practise assiduously every day.
So I conclude that I am never going to be much of a player, even if I live to be 100!!

I believe that 'talent' is a mixture of all these things ..... first, IMO, one needs an interest in learning this instrument. There is some experimental evidence that probably the most important factor in becoming an excellent player is the quantity, but even more so, the QUALITY of your practice. I really think this is, in most cases, the difference between the 'good' and the 'excellent' ....the 'talented' player, destined for 'stardom, practises a LOT, but, he/she practises 'intelligently', concentrating on ironing-out weak spots, rather than just 'going through the motions'. And he/she doesn't stop until he has perfected whatever he set out to achieve.

So the 2 apparently identical players who both start from scratch and practise the same number of hours will never at the end be exactly the same, because one WANTS IT more than the other and his practice is more analytical and productive.

I am sure that the 'dexterity' required can, for young, healthy, well-coordinated players, be developed to nearly the same level.
And I do think that some of us have a better 'ear' for pitch, sense of timing, and ability to remember tunes: these, and other small physical and mental differences may make the difference between a top-class player and a 'vituoso'.....but I think the route to being 'really good', is being really good at PRACTICE....it's the quality more than the quantity.
 
I often say that playing speed is not (only) a function of your body but (mainly) one of the mind.

Try this. Can you play a quick sequence of sounds on any given instrument? Most people can.
Can they play a quick (even simple) scale at the same speed?

A lot of the less capable players will have problems. . The reason being that as long as the movements are not in a special order which you need to know and interiorise, most people have fingers nimble enough to do even very fast things movements.

When you need to attach the brain to the fingers things turn difficult. It is not only a matter of co-ordination. It is a matter of the mind taking control of a feature of our body. By repetition you teach the brain to activate a more or less unconscious muscular memory and so you can get a higher and higher speed in playing a piece that you know well.
 
I still believe that all of us have a number of latent capacities which may or may not have had expression, and which may be a mixture of conscious, sub-conscious and deeply unconscious in terms of our awareness. Certain foci may lead to those forming some sort of chain reaction/connection/linkeage which may result in something that several people may describe as "talent". The idea that someone is born with an innate ability to play the bassoon should one actually come into that individual's experience just seems a little far fetched. Finding our vocation is maybe another way of thinking about such things, be they music or anything else which seems to have some artistic/sublime quality to it. I would think that when such expression has a particularly unconscious quality to it - i.e. just seems to happen naturally, like my daughter who could do perfect one handed cartwheels from the age of 5 onwards with no training etc.etc.

Maybe "talent" is a word that has a quasi meta-physical quality to it, and is ultimately the simplifying of many diverse and complex concepts which would result in an unwieldy pseudo scientific definition/summary/concept and consequent loss of magic/mystery.
Anyway off to put my talents to better use.................
 
I think that people need to be matched with an instrument, for example I play the saxophone, but I also used to play the flute. Now I only played flute for five or six months, but when I stopped, I was better than most of the flute players in the band at my high school that had been playing for four years. Maybe flute is my match, but who knows. I also ran into matching instruments to a student when I was helping the band director at my high school instruct the beginning band students. We had this one girl that started out on trumpet, then moved to tenor saxophone, then to baritone horn. The baritone horn was her match and she started to get better at playing. Do each of us have an instrument that clicks with us over other instruments, maybe, but I think that if you put in the time practicing and you love your instrument, I think anyone can excel at playing.
 
I thought that the OP was comparing the degree to which certain musical ability is more the result of time spent learning and practising or more the result of possessing certain certain inner aptitude or "natural talent" Given that I would imagine that people who "can't sing" are not necessarily a major focus of the above discussion, especially if we are using the word "talent" in this particular context. I am not likely to suggest that people who can do something well are just as "talented" as people who can't do said thing at all. but it is a different use of the word "talent". With regards to singing it would depend on whether a person has any interest in singing, motivation to sing etc. alongside any other factors that contribute to their "inability" to sing, real and perceived.

In terms of your statement above I would imagine that someone who can sing is likely to be thought of as better at singing than someone who can't sing!

Regards
"Tom"
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm a believer in 'natural talent' and i also believe that we all have a talent, but whether that talent is used depends if the talent has been tapped into.
As an example, when i was a nipper i loved running (sprint) and excelled in the school team and running for the Liverpool Harriers i was also very good at swimming and torn between the 2 sports. Eventually chose swimming as my no'1 sport but admit i never had the dedication needed to excell, but was told i could have achieved a lot, how far i will never know.
People who have 'natural talent' and nurture (practiced, dedicated) that talent will achieve all they wish to achieve imho, examples such as Tiger Woods who has a 'talent' for golf and Jackie Stewart who had a 'talent' for racing (he was also a champion at clay pigeon shooting), are prime examples of people with 'talent'. Now i'm not saying they have a talent for hitting a golf club or driving a car as such, but believe that their talent which could be hand eye co-ordination and may have excelled in other sports they tried !!, they have then nurtured (practiced, dedicated) their talent to achieve the goals they have set themselves.

It's a hard one to call about 'natural talent' and defining what the talent is ?, as said in other posts it could be a combination of things, but as said i do believe in 'natural talent'.
 
....but I think the route to being 'really good', is being really good at PRACTICE....it's the quality more than the quantity.

I agree that the quality of the practice is extremely important. Exactly what to practice, and why I'm practicing it, is extremely high on my priority list when setting up my practices sessions. You really need to have specific goals in mind. Otherwise you're just practicing aimlessly.
 
I think that people need to be matched with an instrument, for example I play the saxophone, but I also used to play the flute. Now I only played flute for five or six months, but when I stopped, I was better than most of the flute players in the band at my high school that had been playing for four years. Maybe flute is my match, but who knows. I also ran into matching instruments to a student when I was helping the band director at my high school instruct the beginning band students. We had this one girl that started out on trumpet, then moved to tenor saxophone, then to baritone horn. The baritone horn was her match and she started to get better at playing. Do each of us have an instrument that clicks with us over other instruments, maybe, but I think that if you put in the time practicing and you love your instrument, I think anyone can excel at playing.

Yes, agree fully, we let our kids choose their instruments and it's been interesting to see how all three prefer the sounds of different instruments - and music for their chosen instrument.
 
I thought that the OP was comparing the degree to which certain musical ability is more the result of time spent learning and practising or more the result of possessing certain certain inner aptitude or "natural talent" Given that I would imagine that people who "can't sing" are not necessarily a major focus of the above discussion, especially if we are using the word "talent" in this particular context. I am not likely to suggest that people who can do something well are just as "talented" as people who can't do said thing at all. but it is a different use of the word "talent". With regards to singing it would depend on whether a person has any interest in singing, motivation to sing etc. alongside any other factors that contribute to their "inability" to sing, real and perceived.

In terms of your statement above I would imagine that someone who can sing is likely to be thought of as better at singing than someone who can't sing!

Regards
"Tom"

IT's interesting to see that some people, after head injuries, lose part of all their musical talent, and that others suddenly develop a talent... (quite a few examples in Musicophilia, Sachs).
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,675
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom