Saxophone beginners Taking a breath and songs

As an experienced choral singer... there are no absolute answers as to where to take breaths. Some are easy and obvious, some are not. Some phrases are just too long to be realistically sung in one breath and you have to work out a solution. Bach is particularly challenging in that respect as his vocal lines are often very 'instrumental'.

In choirs, you can cheat as you can use what is known as staggered breathing where people on the same part breath in different places to give the sense of continuous sound. Not an option for one to a part.
 
I have no idea what he means in this context, can you explain.

it-dont-mean-a-thing-breath-marks-png.23632

Jazz articulation is to do with tonguing and I have never seen those comma or apostrophe marks to denote any kind of tonguing or other articulation.


This also seems to make no sense in the context:


So there is a half-note Dnatural slurred to the C# with no accents visible (swing or otherwise). I can understand how the commas could be used to denote a gap between the notes though (but it could probably be done in more conventional ways to be clearer)
Staccatissimo “witches hats” with staccato dots?
 
I’m not an advocate of having to phrase as the song was written. That’s all part of interpretation and why some songs have dozens of great versions. Songs that are quite wordy for example, often have lots of repeated notes which often doesn’t sound the best on a horn without the words to help. An instrument-specific interpretation might be far better.
If you do want to remain true to the original then this can be tricky without it sounding lumpy as it will usually require a really good legato tonguing technique - the listener can hear separation of notes but not the act of doing so. It will probably be helped with Grace notes and extra inflections too.

If in doubt though, do follow the phrasing of the original song - and see how it works.
 
Hope this is relevent to this thread.
Playing baritone on pre 1800 instrumental tunes and the part is way different to all other parts and uses the full range of the sax, high d down to bottom a, what would you do?
Not sure there is much to be done other than the obvious practice of long notes and taking of “snatch breaths”.
Also trying to help with setup: small tip opening and relatively soft reed.

Also: you may need to edit the part, leaving out notes. This is done, and is sometimes unavoidable if playing pieces not written for wind instruments especially.
Identify notes less important and cut them in order to take a breath. The only other option is for the whole group to play rubato and slow sufficiently to breathe with a well-timed “comma”. Can work really well, but not always.
 
Last edited:
Not sure there is much to be done other than the obvious practice of long notes and taking of “snatch breaths”.
Also trying to help with setup: small tip opening and relatively soft reed.

Also: you may need to edit the part, leaving out notes. This is done, and is sometimes unavoidable if playing pieces not written for wind instruments especially.
Identify notes less important and cut them in order to take a breath. The only other option is for the whole group to play rubato and slow sufficiently to breathe with a well-timed “comma”. Can work really well, but not always.
If you’re reading this, this was a rogue errant finger post.
 
I was told to " Sjung på utandningen"! Don't focus too much where and how you should breath. You will find places in the music where you can make room for "mini breath". Less is more.

Concentrate on singing the lyrics instead of where to breath.

@mizmar I'm not sure what you want with this thread. Use your voice to learn new songs? To be a singing saxophonist? Or just to sing?

There are many good singers, in the music I listen to, that also plays(ed) tenor sax. King Curtis, Jr Walker, Red Prysock ..... to John Fogerty, Jimmy Hall ...... . I don't mean good or bad. Just the fact that playing the tenor sax and singing was pretty common in R&R and R&B. Ray Charles was a sax player as well.
 
Use your voice to learn new songs? To be a singing saxophonist? Or just to sing?
It seems the question was more about whether it's a good idea when playing instrumentals of songs to breathe where the lyric phrases imply there should/could be a breath. I think it may well be a good idea but doesn't necessarily mean you have to learn to sing.
 
@mizmar I'm not sure what you want with this thread
Actually, I don't ask for specific advice, only for points of view, experiences, personal habits and such.
I'm sure it's a "tools for the job" issue. Different techniques to achieve different results; and that is reflected in many of the interesting replies.

For the specific song that motivated the thread; it's a traditional song, probably with the audience deeply engaged; maybe singing along to themselves or such like... A breath break at the wrong time would be, well, noticed.
Probably, with a familiar song, one just falls into line without noticing. In this case the song wasn't familiar or even in English or western common practice. And that context often raises interesting things to think about which we might take for granted.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,569
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom