Saxophone beginners Struggling to sound certain notes

Not sure that I was ever suggesting a change of mouthpiece from a Yamaha 4C..........................


I wouldn't.................................................................................;}

It does also depend on whether the same reed is used every single time, without a break, in which case it may wear out quite quickly. reeds are best rotated, and good to have a few on the go (I usually have 4 which I rotate so no reed gets played more than once every 4 days

I am very wary of starting ALL beginners on the same set-up as it is not actually possible to know in advance what is suitable for each beginner. Many trumpet teachers start their beginners on a Bach 7C (16.2mm) mouthpiece. Trouble is I found it far too small and found the Bach 1.5C (17.00mm) much better to start on. I now play a 17.5mm inner diameter mpc - much better.

The reed may not be an issue but I would always caution against making blanket assumptions...........

Kind regards
Tom

I think the part in bold is where I picked up the assumption - my apologies if that wasn't what you meant.... :doh::thumb:
 
Just remember that miss-saxophone has a teacher, and rather than issuing too much advice remotely, the teacher would be best placed to recommend when a change of reed is needed. Even worse if our advice is conflicting.

Of course...but then that's what we do on forums if someone asks for advice isn't it?!;}
 
No problem! I am aware that what I wrote was about mouthpieces, and it was true that I have started on a larger mouthpiece for Alto Sax, like several people that I know - equivalent of a Yamaha 8C if it were made. At the same time I was aware that Fi had just got a Yamaha 4C and seemed to be getting on well with it.

Wishing you well!
Tom
 
Just remember that miss-saxophone has a teacher, and rather than issuing too much advice remotely, the teacher would be best placed to recommend when a change of reed is needed. Even worse if our advice is conflicting.

Hi Kev!

As long as you do not give teachers too much credit. I have had various lessons from approximately 13 music teachers. Only two had given me any helpful advice on mouthpieces, reeds etc. The vast majority new very little about equipment, reeds, mouthpieces etc. and five bought new equipment on my recommendation. Most teachers that I have seen know a lot about music, a lot about good teaching methods, much less about equipment, and usually have a very narrow knowledge of what is available today.

The reality is that truth and insight does not belong to those who may teach musical instruments, and can often be lacking.
I have learnt more online than I have done from my 13 teachers, though have very much enjoyed their input too!
 
As suggested earlier, it is well worth rotating a few reeds. You will soon learn some reeds are easy to play and sound great, others are not so flash. Use the good ones at your lessons, so you aren't wasting time fighting a bad reed.
 
Hi Kev!

As long as you do not give teachers too much credit. I have had various lessons from approximately 13 music teachers. Only two had given me any helpful advice on mouthpieces, reeds etc. The vast majority new very little about equipment, reeds, mouthpieces etc. and five bought new equipment on my recommendation. Most teachers that I have seen know a lot about music, a lot about good teaching methods, much less about equipment, and usually have a very narrow knowledge of what is available today.

The reality is that truth and insight does not belong to those who may teach musical instruments, and can often be lacking.
I have learnt more online than I have done from my 13 teachers, though have very much enjoyed their input too!

Let's discuss that somewhere else >:) :

http://cafesaxophone.com/showthread.php?6640-Music-teachers
 
hi miss saxophone
I thought I would put my thoughts and observations to you as a relative begginer
I have had the same problems as you are describing
I have recently found that they come and go
the reason is usually the reed or my tension through the embouchure
I find that the reeds vary alot
I can play in tune with some reeds and not with others.
Some squark easier than others.
sometimes I can stop the squark by adjusting my embouchure.
I have one reed that I can guarantee is my best reed anytime so I save that one for concerts etc.
some of my reeds are different strenghts than others .
so as you can see its all a learning curve that only time and experience will solve.
Im now, after nearly 12 months of playing, able to recognize and solve my problems.
keep practicing youll get there
if one reed is no good try another and dont tense up your embouchure.
ps dont thrw out the reeds that you dont like they will probably become playable later on
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom