Playing the saxophone Sound isolation for a practice room

<SNIP>
I'm about to move to Oostende from Antwerp. In Antwerp I put a lot of time and money into building a well isolated shed and then sticking a used Esmono practice cabin inside. In the end, I had a great practice room where I could practice at 6 am without bothering anyone. (not that I did... I was in there before 8 a couple times though).

<SNIP>
Aside from wondering if the floor can handle the weight, I'm also starting to wonder if it's really necessary. The sound booth doesn't isolate through the floor unless I buy flooring which is extra, and I'll need to do some work to isolate the floor of the house as well anyway. The walls to the left and right are brick and supposedly very solid so I don't need to isolate those, or not so much. One wall faces to the street, so I only have to isolate it if neighbours complain. So the main isolation I need, is just the floor, the wall entering to the house, and the part of the ceiling with a loft bed above it.

So, I'm thinking to isolate the floor between the joists with rockwool or similar, then replace the wood planks with big sheets of particle board or something similar, dense, heavy flooring. Then cover that with thick rubber. Above that I can build a room within a room but possibly skip the wall facing the street? The walls would be sheetrock over a wood frame with rockwool inside then two layers of sheetrock separated by green glue. Would need to install a fire door.

For the outside wall I think the main obvious issue is the window but maybe I can just make a sort of removeable panel i can take on and off. Or some kind of door.

OK, I'm not exactly sure what the question is so much as... what do you think? Any suggestions, things I didn't think about?
You are moving to the town where I was born, nice!

First of all, I don't have a lot of experience in sound-proofing practice rooms. But I did take a course in Noise polution about 25 years ago, so I have some theorethical knowledge I want to share with you.

I would not try and put a sound booth in that room, seems not very feasible.

First, look for "gaps", you need to fix those first. even small gaps (between the wall and floor for instance) could leak a huge amount of sound. Maybe use some king of leak light. When the room downstairs is dark, use a stong light and walk arround the top room with it while sombody looks for leaks in the bottom room. Just thinking out loud here ......

I would start by isolating the floor, that will make a huge difference.
Your idea of putting a rubber mat on the floor as a base layer seems very sound.

Some general principles to keep in mind:
  • make sure there are no contact points between te inner layer (where the sound is) and the outer layer (where you want it to be quiet). Use some kind of buffer between them.
    Contact noise is the hardest to get rid of, and this transmits the bas-sounds the best
    That's what the rubber layer would do quite well I think
  • you want an isolation material that has a lot of mass, but also some air in between, that is what you need to dampen the sound waves. Compressed rock wool or sand are very effective for this. Sand is of course less handy here because of the weight (works well for speakers though)
  • Using wood and carpets can help, but they do more for creating a comfortable sound within the room rather than isolating noise pollution towards the neighbouring rooms.
 
Hey Wonko,

Thanks for the tips! Where are you living now? I'm quite curious about life in Oostende, only been there a couple times. It's definitely cheaper than Antwerp. And the North Sea is a 6 minute walk from our new front door. Then again I hate the sea. The snotgreen sea, the scrotum tightening sea....

I was also maybe not quite clear enough about what I planned for the floor. I'm going to take the wood floor that is there away. Then fill the gaps between the joists underneath with rockwool or something similar. Then instead of reinstalling that wood floor I'd put MDF or OSB plates to make a new floor. I'd be sure to seal the gaps between plates, which would be far easier than sealing up every crack in the wood floor that is there now. Then on top of that I'd put the thick rubber mat and build the room in a room on top of that.

That process would mostly solve the issues you mentioned, no? At least with the floor.

Anyway, another thought that's come to mind is ... there is a basement. Right now, it's not tall enough for me to stand up in. However, the people we're buying the house from did mention that it could be possible to lower the floor there. I think the owner said some neighbours nearby did that. I'm sure it would be some work and expense, but in the basement at least 3 walls would be totally fine, the floor and two side walls. I think sound proofing from there would be much easier. Plus, we'd have an extra room to use in the house not filled with my mess. In it's current state, it's a very clean, and dry basement.

So the potential options at this point are:

3 rd floor, do some kind of serious support work for the floor and put an Esmono cabin in it.
3rd floor, try to "sound proof" it myself. I realize if I build a room in a room I might still need to support the floor a little bit, ie sister the joists.

Use the ground floor front room for the Esmono unit. Not ideal as normally this would be the living room.

Dig up the basement big enough to turn into a practice space.

We don't move in till October 12 actually so I'm still very much in the brainstorming, trying to consider everything mode....
I'm still trying to see if I can find a structural engineer to come look at the place.

The final awkward thing, I already paid a big deposit on the Esmono unit before I realized the new house may not be able to support it. So soon I may need to contact them and beg for my deposit back. I guess they'll most likely keep some of it.
 
Hey Wonko,

Thanks for the tips! Where are you living now? I'm quite curious about life in Oostende, only been there a couple times. It's definitely cheaper than Antwerp. And the North Sea is a 6 minute walk from our new front door. Then again I hate the sea. The snotgreen sea, the scrotum tightening sea....

I was also maybe not quite clear enough about what I planned for the floor. I'm going to take the wood floor that is there away. Then fill the gaps between the joists underneath with rockwool or something similar. Then instead of reinstalling that wood floor I'd put MDF or OSB plates to make a new floor. I'd be sure to seal the gaps between plates, which would be far easier than sealing up every crack in the wood floor that is there now. Then on top of that I'd put the thick rubber mat and build the room in a room on top of that.

That process would mostly solve the issues you mentioned, no? At least with the floor.

Anyway, another thought that's come to mind is ... there is a basement. Right now, it's not tall enough for me to stand up in. However, the people we're buying the house from did mention that it could be possible to lower the floor there. I think the owner said some neighbours nearby did that. I'm sure it would be some work and expense, but in the basement at least 3 walls would be totally fine, the floor and two side walls. I think sound proofing from there would be much easier. Plus, we'd have an extra room to use in the house not filled with my mess. In it's current state, it's a very clean, and dry basement.

So the potential options at this point are:

3 rd floor, do some kind of serious support work for the floor and put an Esmono cabin in it.
3rd floor, try to "sound proof" it myself. I realize if I build a room in a room I might still need to support the floor a little bit, ie sister the joists.

Use the ground floor front room for the Esmono unit. Not ideal as normally this would be the living room.

Dig up the basement big enough to turn into a practice space.

We don't move in till October 12 actually so I'm still very much in the brainstorming, trying to consider everything mode....
I'm still trying to see if I can find a structural engineer to come look at the place.

The final awkward thing, I already paid a big deposit on the Esmono unit before I realized the new house may not be able to support it. So soon I may need to contact them and beg for my deposit back. I guess they'll most likely keep some of it.
Hey John,

I now live in Zulte (between Gent and Kortrijk), no sea to see arround here.
Sory to hear that you hate the sea. Maybe, in time you will learn to appreciate the seaside?

Oostende is a rather lively town, of course smaller and less (cultural) activities than Antwerp, but still quite a bussy cultural life. The casino for instance has a very good concert hall, I saw Lionell hampton there, and more recently Toots Tielemans, and lots of others ....

At one time (1981) Marvin Gaye lived in Oostende for about 1.5 years. He wrote Sexual Healing there.
As for the soundproofing, I would keep the present floor (no need to seal all the small crannies if you are going to put a rubber layer on top of that). You would only need to take care of the gaps between the floor and the walls (IMHO).
If you would put the rubber layer directly on the joists, with a floor on top of that. You would compress the rubber in that area, efectively anihilating the absorbing capacitiy of the rubber layer. Spreading the weight over the whole surface of the floor would work much better.

A basement is of course a good place to build a practice room. Chances are that the neigbours won't be bothered if they get noise in their basement.
Before you start digging up the basement I would look into the level of the groundwater there, and if the floor of the basement might be needed to keep the groundwater out of your basement .....

Depending on where your house stands, and how deep your basement is, you might have to deal with an groundwater-pressure from the see pushing the water up, even on the land-side. If your house stands higher than the high-water level of the sea, you might be safe......
 
Just an update for anyone who might be interested.

I finally had a meeting with a structural engineer. She said my best bet is to add at least two metal beams which would go directly under the long walls of the unit. She still needs to do all the calculations and send it to me, but it seems like that's what is going to happen. Shouldn't be that hard actually as I was planning to take out the floor anyway and put something better for sound isolation.

She also confirmed my suspicions that if I tried to soundproof the room myself, the amount of weight I'd add to the room building a room within a room would also be too much for the current floor, so I think I'd might as well buy this Esmono unit. Then I know at least all walls and ceiling are good. I just need to think about the floor some more.

The option of digging out the basement would be much more expensive, she thought. Of course, if I dig out the basement maybe I wouldn't need to buy the Esmono sound booth. Either way I guess the next step is to contact a contractor to get an estimate to install the beams and I could also ask them about the basement.

PS Wonko, no I was kidding about hating the seaside. Actually I'm very much enjoying Oostende and being by the sea so far. It's funny, I was in Antwerp for 2 years and somehow this feels more active to me as I was living in a residential area there, and here I'm 50 meters from Petite Paris. In a 15 minute walk I can go to one of 5 bio shops, the Asian market, more clothes shopping than I will ever take advantage of, etc. Just haven't found a truly good espresso. I guess I'll stick to local beer....
 
I just note that the OP and the responses are about 'practical solutions' towards creating a relatively sound-proofed practice space. I just wonder whether a sound-proofed practice space is absolutely necessary and if so, how good the sound-proofing needs to be.

I live in an appartment block and if my neighbours are around, I usually use a communal bike shed as a 'practice space'. But they're not always around so knowing their social and work habits, I can quite happily practice in my own appartment (without sound-proofing) without disturbing anyone.

When my eldest daughter (now 35, then 17) decided that she wanted to practice drumminng, she dropped a note in neighbours' houses explaning that she would practice for 2 hours a day between certain hours and asking those who experienced any discomfort to get in touch with her. None did.

IHMO, there are probably certain times of the day (for example late afternoons but before dinner) in which forwarned neighbours have less problems with practicing musicians than at other times. It;s not always possible to adjust your practice schedule to neighbours' work and social habits. But where I live (NL) it's not uncommon to hear practicing musicians (trompets, saxes, drums) from the street.

Let's be honest: the majority of student musicians (and their parents) simply don't have either the space or the financial resources to build a 'sound-proofed studio'.

As a last point, a lot depends on what you're practicing. For lessons/orchestral/band practice, 'the notes' can often be practiced at a much lower volume than indicated with the 'full dynamics' being practiced at rehearsals. To some extent, this also applies to solo recordings. The 'notes' can often first be practiced at a lower volume than that eventually required for the recording.

So to summarise, I just wonder when and how often you really need a 'sound-proofed studio' for practice, and whether there are any practical alternatives to building one at home.

I fully realize that you have your 'personal requirements' and I don't in any way want to question these.

Mike
 
Hey Mike,

Yes I guess I didn't say much about my situation.
I'm a full time, professional musician. So I need to be able to practice basically as much as I want...!

Sometimes I get called for a gig and need to memorize 2 sets worth of music in a couple days and just have to be in the shed as long as it takes. For the most part, I'm not expecting to be able to play at 3 am. But during the entire daytime, yes. Also it's not just my neighbours, but my girlfriend who works from home a couple days a week. And whenever possible, I practice every day, so weekends as well.

I also have a set up with my studio monitors, subwoofer, all that.... If I had the dough, I'd definitely go for a complete, professional sound studio. I don't so I'm just trying to get as close as possible.
 
Hi @john_dikeman,

I completely understand. And many thanks for your additional comment. I should have looked you up before responding!
Good luck in sorting out your home studio!

I'm sometimes guilty of mentally 'fillling in' my own understanding of posts in this and other forums (with my best intentions). This one was a case in point!

Mike
Hey Mike,

Yes I guess I didn't say much about my situation.
I'm a full time, professional musician. So I need to be able to practice basically as much as I want...!

Sometimes I get called for a gig and need to memorize 2 sets worth of music in a couple days and just have to be in the shed as long as it takes. For the most part, I'm not expecting to be able to play at 3 am. But during the entire daytime, yes. Also it's not just my neighbours, but my girlfriend who works from home a couple days a week. And whenever possible, I practice every day, so weekends as well.

I also have a set up with my studio monitors, subwoofer, all that.... If I had the dough, I'd definitely go for a complete, professional sound studio. I don't so I'm just trying to get as close as possible.
 
Last edited:
Funny anecdote (to me anyway). The other day while moving in I saw a guy entering the house 4 doors down with a sax on his back. I ran over and said hello, I see you're a saxophonist. Then I asked how he practices. He said "I never practice". I laughed and made some joke about, right you did all that **** when you were young. And he said, "Yeah, I'm a professional." I just stood there for a second and eventually had to say, yeah me too. But I still practice....
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,676
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom