Playing the saxophone Simple or complex soloing? This is the question

Yes Colin, serving the music seems the best explanation. Easier said than done! I discussed some points in the video to improvise in a more simple and "direct" approach, or to phrase more vertically, in a more "bebop" way. I think that we can also choose to play simple but adding some more complex ideas at some points, to add more variety to our solo. Sometimes we can also do the opposite, it depends on the gig context.
 
First I would like to thank you for the great videos you are up-loading. Even a woodshed honker, like me, that is into blues and rock&roll music can enjoy and pick up some ideas from your videos.

Slow and simple for me! I'm a slow person. The music I play is often just based on the major pentatonic scale. I try to play the key words on my sax. So lyrics is important. I also use to throw in some major 6ths, 3rds, 9ths ...... Instead of speed I try to play with a big and full tone. And the keys concert A, - E, - D - G, - B are important to get use to. Here is a sample. Bobby Forte is playing a solo in Charles Brown's (R&B piano man and singer) song "I Want To Go Home". Concert E and Forte is using the F" major pentatonic scale as "ground" for his solo. Perhaps more info than necessary, but maybe interesting for you to know who watching your videos? The solo starts 1:15.


View: https://youtu.be/iK0Lz24yoG0


































































B
 
I enjoyed the video and it had some great ideas.

My initial reaction is that this presents an "intellectual" / "jazz" analytical approach. Maybe that can result in a solo that has less feeling.

I enjoyed the live performance but wonder whether the solo really fitted with the song and the rest of the band. Perhaps you were trying to fit in too much in the way of ideas and technique into a relatively short solo spot. Or maybe that is what the band wanted and expected when they asked you to play. Great chops anyway !

Perhaps the use of complexity in a solo works best in a longer solo, where the player can have a plan for how to build up from a simple start and take the audience on a journey. I always think that Benny Golson is great at structuring a solo, in fact he often seems to follow a similar plan for how to build up, often from a simple or dramatic entrance. For example:

View: https://youtu.be/ZxjqAsPtT60


Keep the VLogs coming !

Rhys
 
@thomsax Thanks for your comment and your link. I didn't know Bobby Forte. Such a beautiful sound and soulful approach.

@rhysonsax The solo that I played is pretty simple. I played 90% major and minor pentatonics adding some "chromatic" lines at some spots.
Golson is one of my favorite players. He is a great improviser and maybe even a great composer. He has the ability to play beautiful melodies over really complex changes and song forms.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom