Mouthpieces Sick of UK Prices

.......If more people learnt languages (in general) there would be a significant improvement ..........

I can only agree with this and that is as true of the English speaking population of the world as it is of the rest whichever their mother tongue might be !

I speak at a fluent level 3 languages and have a decent understanding and practical use of a few more. I did study languages when I was at university and studied at the time next to English, which was my major, two minor subjects, Hebrew and Norwegian too (don’t ask, it’s complicated!) which are long forgotten .......I am ashamed to say!

Anyway, learning a language is not only useful for communication purposes but clearly opens up one’s mind and keeps it flexible.

There are studies which prove that people who speak several languages are less prone to the scourge of Alzheimer's Disease
http://www.foxnews.com/health/2011/02/21/learning-second-language-protects-alzheimers/
http://www.livescience.com/3497-bilingual-babies-early-edge.html


Learning Latin (I only took three years of the stuff!) has certainly a purpose although it might not be the one of conversing in Latin with other people. Latin requires the use logic and discipline and it certainly teaches to apply these abilities to a very high level.

It might not be of any practical use but so are many things we do in life when we are growing up, they serve the purpose to teach us to learn.
 
As one who was forced to learn latin for two years(and hated it), I can only agree with the sentiments of excluding it from general use in english.

As for nouns having gender - pointless in most cases. It's only really useful for subjects which have a gender - like man and woman, or dog and bitch, or actor and actress - but why should a car or a rock have a gender? Does the fact that policeman in german is feminine mean anything?

And as I've found as I learnt German, did French at school I found that many nouns do not have the same gender in different languages...

I'd agree that latin is useful - for students of modern languages, especially the romance ones and for historians, scholars who'll study old manuscripts. But that's it.

But there's a different issue - the unwillingness of English speakers to learn other languages, even at school. I'm getting used to it now, but most of my colleagues speak at least two languages fluently and usually three or more. Due to excellent schooling that's lacking in Britain. The exceptions who can only speak one language are mostly the ones with English as their home language, and I count myself in that category.
 
If more people learnt languages (in general) there would be a significant improvement in the standard of written and spoken English (and I'm not referring to artificial constructs such as "split infinitives" which is a Victorian fable). A major issue, in my opinion, is the lack of undertsanding of how language is constructed or works.

Now there I agree with you. I speak French, although not very well, but I seem to be in a small minority among UK born people. There is this all pervading sense of arrogance about English speakers not learning other languages, and expecting others to learn English. I don't really agree that Latin has ever been a ligua franca (it has never been spoken by more than a small minority of the population of most trading nations) but now, undoubtedly the predominant international language is English. I think this is, if anything, tending to get worse, as English is the business language of a significant proprtion of the globe. Even the increasing dominance of the global economy by China doesn't seem to affect this - on the contrary, a friend who works in business in Shangai reports that, increasingly, English is spoken as the dominant business language among Chinese entrepreneurs. Similar trends are appearing in the other 'BRIC' countries.

One thing I would add is that, whatever my views on Latin, it's good to be able to hold differing opinions without falling out.:thumb:
 
Now there I agree with you. I speak French, although not very well, but I seem to be in a small minority among UK born people. There is this all pervading sense of arrogance about English speakers not learning other languages, and expecting others to learn English. I don't really agree that Latin has ever been a ligua franca (it has never been spoken by more than a small minority of the population of most trading nations) but now, undoubtedly the predominant international language is English. I think this is, if anything, tending to get worse, as English is the business language of a significant proprtion of the globe. Even the increasing dominance of the global economy by China doesn't seem to affect this - on the contrary, a friend who works in business in Shangai reports that, increasingly, English is spoken as the dominant business language among Chinese entrepreneurs. Similar trends are appearing in the other 'BRIC' countries.

One thing I would add is that, whatever my views on Latin, it's good to be able to hold differing opinions without falling out.:thumb:

It's probably a literacy thing. The ony people who were literate until about C18th were clerics, lawyers, academics, governing classes etc. The standard language of communication (spoken and written) well into C17th for all of these was Latin. Isaac Newton writing at the end of C17th was doing so in Latin.

Latin is a useful base for learning languages since it is logical, relatively uncomplex, and being an inflected language, you don't have to worry about word order too much. This is unlike English where it can be critical in which order you place subject, object, and verb. Compare: "the dog bit the man" with "the man bit the dog". Usually in English the word order is subject, verb object where the subject is the 'thing' doing the action of the verb (biting in this case) and the object is the thing on which the action is perfromed (i.e. being bitten). With an inflected language, the ending of the word tells you if you are dealing with the subject or the object, so word order doesn't matter and the word order in Latin is usually subject, object, rubbish heap, verb, where the rubbish heap are all of the other words in the sentence.

We'll leave deponent verbs and absolute ablatives for another day >:)
 
I think, as seems often to be the case, that a thread often achieves a more-or-less settled "resolution" of its initial purpose relatively quickly (usually within the first 20,000 or 30,000 posts). Then some chance component of a reply intiates its own secondary thread which then has its own life.

If it's any consolation, my Latin teacher would be shocked (proud?) that I extol its virtues these days. I have a vivid memory of being in 4th form and said Latin teach bellowing across the classroom **** (name changed to protect the guilty) that sentence was so bad that if I was over over there.... (suggested activity expunged, but would result in criminal prosecution in the modern world).
 
I think, as seems often to be the case, that a thread often achieves a more-or-less settled "resolution" of its initial purpose relatively quickly (usually within the first 20,000 or 30,000 posts). Then some chance component of a reply intiates its own secondary thread which then has its own life.

De facto, UK prices are quite high indeed.
Cave canem, cave canem....
Biscuit.
 
Sarcasm?
You should know that going off topic is almost compulsory.

You mean it isn't actually a condition of membership? To my mind such diversionary excursions are (a) educational and (b) entertaining- the odd touch of surrealism of Pythonesque proportions doesn't go amiss either. Taking things too seriously can cause one to age prematurely. I even suspect that Old Git is actually a teenager.

Dave
 
Sick of UK prices?

Check out these prices in New Zealand. This is from one of my local music stores.

The current exchange rates are as follows:- 1 New Zealand Dollar = approx. 50p; approx. 60 Euro Cents or approx. 80 US cents.

http://www.shearersmusic.co.nz/index.asp?PageID=2145867883

Scroll down and check out the price of the silver plated Selmer (Paris) Super Action 80 Series III tenor sax that equates to about GBP8,000.00 and I know full well that particular sax has been in the store for about close to a decade - it was originally listed at approx. NZD8,000.00 (approx. GBP2,700.00) back in the day when the exhange rate was NZD1.00 = GBP0.30p. Every time the exchange rate has fluctuated the price has changed and not for the better. Another thing that is interesting the basic pro Yamaha soprano sax is over NZD9,000.00 and the Custom Soprano is cheaper (what are the!?) Note the Vivace saxophones, in the UK they are sold as John Packer instruments. Also the majority of the instruments (Yamaha 475 series and above, 62, 82Z, 875 etc) are not in store but will have to ordered from overseas (Australia or Japan), except for the over priced Selmer which appears to have taken up permanent residence in the shop (no wonder at that price). Apparently a world famous sax player has played the Selmer, a couple of years ago while visiting his son and grandson who live locally, John Anthony Helliwell from Supertramp no less popped into the store and played it - so it is probably one of those magical Selmers...

so if anybody does eventually buy the Selmer they'll be playing Supertramp sax solos until the cows come home...( I can here the pulsating Wurlitzer EP200 electric piano in the distance)

So while you are complaining about prices in the UK think of us poor New Zealanders with overpriced instruments and bugger all range to choose from...

Regards,

Greg S.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,684
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom