Saxophones Selmer SBA vs Trevor James Signature Custom XS

flat7

Member
Messages
44
Location
Sweden
This clip that I recorded (in random order) has the first horn being played followed by a break and then the next horn follows in the same clip. Can you hear the difference? What difference can you notice and wich horn do you prefer? The SBA is from 1953 in original condition. sba vs raw 2.mp3 There is no fancy playing, the oposite actually cause I am just trying the horns out and what I play is just crap.

To get the discussion going i will start. To me, the first horn has a big,warm character with edge, slightly smoother tone. Second horn has a colder tone but centered, still big sound but less warm.
 
That's interesting - because in the first two tracks I felt that horn one was the most precise (and hence the RAW), but in the second two I reckoned they'd been reversed and the second track was the RAW.
It's particularly interesting for me as I chose the RAW for my own horn because it had some elements of the Selmer tonescape but without too much of the midrange blur, and some of the cut and thrust of a Yamaha.

But coming back to that 'materials' thread I guess I'd say that "It ain't what you play, it's the way that you play it!"
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Listening back to these clips a few days later I start to hear some interesting differences between the horns. The SBA has this round almost wooly sound but great focus and edge. Sound is a bit less pronounced in the mids i think. The Trevor James on the other hand is a wide sound but compact..., A bit more open sound with more mids , tad more complex tone actually. It lacks the very top end of the selmer wich has the impact that the tone seems more single layered so to speak.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Did you set out to decide, once and for all, which of the two to keep?
Or, like me, do you just have a collection which you'll whittle down one day... of course you will.

I used to try and keep just one alto, my "keeper" sax until something better came along and beat it.
Now I think I have a dozen, and half a dozen tenors which I don't play that often - and I added to that number again today with something unusual which just caught my eye. :doh:

I'm not a great TJ fan, having bought a RAW new but disliking it immediately. I'd struggle to sell an iconic SBA although I guess you'd get far more for it over the TJ, not that you're thinking of selling either perhaps?

Anyhow, listening to you tracks I'd be hard pressed to choose between them. I guess ergonomics and other subjective factors only you can feel will make you decide which you prefer.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
They are different and both top level horns and they both have their strong and weaker sides. I have been playing the SBA for at least 9years as my main tenor but many others have been bought and sold during that time. I had a couple of mk6, a few 10ms.. I like trying out new gear and record them. Its my hobby! I have confidence in the SBA cause I owned it for a long time and it will stay with me. It has this meaty solid selmer core to it.

The TJSCRAW is my favourite among modern tenors. It has a complex tone and great feel. @DavidUK What did you dislike about it?
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
The TJSCRAW is my favourite among modern tenors. It has a complex tone and great feel. @DavidUK What did you dislike about it?
It was an alto. I think I was playing a 62 purple logo when I bought the TJ, only because the RAW was cheap as chips (from a European Selmer distributor I know) and I thought that a no risk price to try it.

This was many years ago but it just did nothing for me at that stage as a beginner. I've since thought that it's probably my non-expert playing which didn't extract the finer nuances of the TJ, but then when I tried an SA80II I was smitten by it and sold the 62 in favour of the Selmer.

I'd tried another used TJ RAW alto prior to this, on sale at a retailer and "fully serviced" but that was unplayable so I handed it back and thought it unfair to judge it by that poor example.
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
It was an alto. I think I was playing a 62 purple logo when I bought the TJ, only because the RAW was cheap as chips (from a European Selmer distributor I know) and I thought that a no risk price to try it.

This was many years ago but it just did nothing for me at that stage as a beginner. I've since thought that it's probably my non-expert playing which didn't extract the finer nuances of the TJ, but then when I tried an SA80II I was smitten by it and sold the 62 in favour of the Selmer.

I'd tried another used TJ RAW alto prior to this, on sale at a retailer and "fully serviced" but that was unplayable so I handed it back and thought it unfair to judge it by that poor example.
Ok, I have never played the Alto version of the TJSCRAW so i have no idea how it plays. Ofcourse you need a certain level of experience to hear the difference and get the best out of the saxophone. But as you like the selmer I dint think a lack of experience is your problem. Maybe it did not tick your boxes simple as that? I have read that the tenors is on a different level than the altos but as i mentioned, I have not tried the alto version.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,584
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom