Saxophones Selmer SBA vs Trevor James Signature Custom XS

flat7

Member
Messages
44
Location
Sweden
This clip that I recorded (in random order) has the first horn being played followed by a break and then the next horn follows in the same clip. Can you hear the difference? What difference can you notice and wich horn do you prefer? The SBA is from 1953 in original condition. sba vs raw 2.mp3 There is no fancy playing, the oposite actually cause I am just trying the horns out and what I play is just crap.

To get the discussion going i will start. To me, the first horn has a big,warm character with edge, slightly smoother tone. Second horn has a colder tone but centered, still big sound but less warm.
 
To me the first horn is the brighter of the two, the second the warmer. But only just.
The first horn is more percussive; the note separation is more distinct - the second is slightly smoother with perhaps a little smearing. You sound more confident on the first horn.
In terms of tone there's really so little difference between them (to my ears anyway).

I could be wrong but I'm gonna plump for the first track being the RAW.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
To me the first horn is the brighter of the two, the second the warmer. But only just.
The first horn is more percussive; the note separation is more distinct - the second is slightly smoother with perhaps a little smearing. You sound more confident on the first horn.
In terms of tone there's really so little difference between them (to my ears anyway).

I could be wrong but I'm gonna plump for the first track being the RAW.
I agree on that horn 1 is more percussive, its an important quality actually and I have my thoughts on why its more percussive but more on that later (if I show my thoughts it may reveal the answer on this little drill). 🙂
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
I've listened to your track with my highly trained ear and have come to the conclusion that you're wearing non-matching socks!

In all seriousness the playing is a little different between the two clips. I pick up on that more than what I perceive to be the tone of the horn if that makes sense.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Since some of you guys thought that my playing differed too much between the two horns I will make a new recording where I play the horns in the same manner. Should be up soon.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
In your 1st post I preferred tenor 2
in post number 12, I preferred tenor 1.

I think post 12 is a better comparison as pointed out similarity in playing helps.
But in post 1, I liked the body and warmth of tenor 2 In post 12 that got more sluggish in comparison which could just be your confidence around the horn and there was enough warmth and body in tenor 1.

But both are nice to my ears.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
So here goes, two recordings recorded right after eachother on the same reed and mouthpiece. Splash of reverb and thats it.



Well first thing that should be said is you sound fantastic!! Beautiful fat tone, great time and lines.

When it comes to comparing the two recordings it's difficult to describe the differences. Tenor 1 was more focused and a touch brighter, perhaps slightly richer and had greater presence. Tenor 2 was very fat/spread and seemed slightly mellower but had a nice warmth and hollowness to the sound.

Given my forum name I obviously appreciate the choice of tune too - Soul Station by Hank Mobley 🙂
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
This clip that I recorded (in random order) has the first horn being played followed by a break and then the next horn follows in the same clip. Can you hear the difference? What difference can you notice and wich horn do you prefer? The SBA is from 1953 in original condition. sba vs raw 2.mp3 There is no fancy playing, the oposite actually cause I am just trying the horns out and what I play is just crap.

To get the discussion going i will start. To me, the first horn has a big,warm character with edge, slightly smoother tone. Second horn has a colder tone but centered, still big sound but less warm.
I am not hearing any playing that would tease out the nuances in tone. If you, as the player, find that either horn makes it easier to get the sounds you want, then that makes it a candidate.

If they play equally well, you may find that the choice of mouthpiece/sax pairing makes a difference as to which wins the battle. This is why, once I find a great combination of mouthpiece and horn, I stop trying other setups. Once you get there, it's on the player to get everything out of the setup.

What's the point of this comparison? Are you trying to show that a "lesser" horn is capable of matching the other in a contest of tone, or are you trying to sort out your preferences? My "vote" is that either is close enough in the listening tests to work for you. As others have noted, a change of reed selection would swamp the critical differences in this demonstration.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
First of all, this thread is for the fun! Also I love to analyze recordings, my computer is full with recordings of different horn/mouthpiece recordings. I thought I would share some of it if there is more nerds like me out there?

To all of you that have experience with older selmers maybe could recognize the punch nature of horn 1, crisp edge and depth of tone. Horn 1 was the SBA. Horn 2 (TJSC) to me has less core but a nice character and overtones. Its hard to beat the SBA, its one of the most hyped horns out there and for a reason. The Trevor James offers something different, a more free, broad tone but not as punch and less complex? Thanks for participation and jazz on!
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,611
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom