Saxophones and Silver Plating

freddysilk

Member
Messages
99
Location
Cleveland, Ohio
I've just gotten my alto serviced and there were several leaks in the bottom keys, along with a few keys that was adjusted too tight from poor maintenance from a prior service person.

Anyway, while my sax was being fixed I was allowed to test out a few tenors that was rebuilt and silver plated. The silver plating looked flawless and the tone was even nicer. My question is does silver, brass, or bronze plating affect the tone?

I know there's a debate about relacquering and I don't want to start it back up but I'm wondering if plating affects the tone before I buy another tenor.

BTW, it was a King Zephyr tenor that was silver plated with the following:
Gold plated keys
Gold plating inside the bell
silver plated body, bell, amd neck(w/ new cork)
Brand new pads with metal resonators
Engraving on the horn was redone perfectly
Key heights adjusted and the key action is slick
 
freddysilk wrote:
My question is does silver, brass, or bronze plating affect the tone?

I know there's a debate about relacquering and I don't want to start it back up but I'm wondering if plating affects the tone before I buy another tenor.

No, the plating itself will not affect the tone, but the necessary stripping down and rebuilding will mean your horn should be in much better condition than before so will probably sound better.

Anyone who says their horn sounds better/worse after plating or lacquer stripping or whatever is probably noticing the difference between pre and post overhaul - and even then it's after not playing that horn for a few days/weeks so an extremely unscientific comparison.

Besides, all the acoustic theory suggests that material/finish does not affect sound.
 
Not really wanting to cross swords with my new guitar hero:w00t: (see latest webcam shot), and being aware of a flute test where the testers literally played blind, three flutes of different material whilst also deprived of tactile feedback, got all the identities wrong.
Despite this, my sax vibrates when played and surely the vibrations of the metal and its coatings must 'colour', even slightly, the resulting sound. If you doubt this, have a blow and feel the bell at the same time.
 
I agree that when playing you feel something that can only be described as "resonance". But I don't think it is. Very often you can love a horn that feels good to you and seems to resonate, but once recorded it doesn't seem to be able to capture that feeling.
 
good heavens lads, it's the column of air that's oscillating on it's way through the sax, after that it goes out into the room and those air waves "can" cause other objects to resonate and vibrate, it can even cause voluptuous blond amazonian women to shudder, but it doesn't vibrate the saxophone's tube unless maybe you have a few screws or rods loose, are of a nervous disposition and a tendency to believe in obscure sectarian doctrines. "I've got a voodoo women and she's alright . . ."
 
old git wrote:
Not really wanting to cross swords with my new guitar hero:w00t: (see latest webcam shot)

...who bears a passing resemblance to Robert Fripp on my screen.


Actually Pete, you may have a point there - it's possible some perceived improvements are as a result of being separated from your baby for a while, so psychologically you will believe it's improved partly because you want it to be. On the other hand, who really knows? Scientific explanations may be all well and good but don't take into account human responses, meaning if your horn is not actually improved by relacquering, delacquering or silver plating, and you believe it to be improved by same, then it will in effect be improved because the improvement may be due to your increased enjoyment in playing what you believe to be an improved instrument.

I've just read that back, it's psychobabble blether really, isn't it :erm:
 
Back in my HiFi days, it was proven to hear very slight differences in sound when a telephone or similar inductive appliance was present in the same room as the speakers whilst listening to a steady tone. This was also displayable on oscilloscope as an increase of grass and small spikes not visible in the steady state.
As I can feel the bell resonating on notes not requiring right hand usage, a slight, probably very small, colouration must be present.
Of course playing a loud instrument for long periods will result in increasing deafness. >:) >:)
Roberta,
How did the sex change go?
I think you might have upset Pete as the webcam seems to have taken a walk.
 
spike wrote:
it can even cause voluptuous blond amazonian women to shudder

If anyone has a voluptuous blonde Amazonian woman to hand (so to speak) I have a couple of days off coming up and I'd be willing to test this theory in the interests of science.

Extensively! :whistle:


To address the original question, I believe there are in fact three distinct schools of thought -

a) Yes
b) No
c) Don't know (sometimes with the sub-class, "Don't care")

The debate rages on...!

To test the theory of instrument resonance affecting the tone, set a recorder running and play a one-handed note while intermittently clasping and releasing the sax in various places with your free hand - the bell, the bow, the neck, etc. If the theory is correct then you should be able to hear a difference on playback.

I couldn't, but that may be because I'm a rotten player with cloth ears. YMMV.

Bottom line, I agree with Pete, but am pretty unqualified to hold any opinion on the subject at all!
 
FrankB wrote:
To test the theory of instrument resonance affecting the tone, set a recorder running and play a one-handed note while intermittently clasping and releasing the sax in various places with your free hand - the bell, the bow, the neck, etc. If the theory is correct then you should be able to hear a difference on playback.

I couldn't, but that may be because I'm a rotten player with cloth ears. YMMV.

Bottom line, I agree with Pete, but am pretty unqualified to hold any opinion on the subject at all!

And then, to magnify the effect, clasp and release the player. Position of clasp is your choice...

regards, Phil
 
Phil Edwards wrote:
FrankB wrote:
To test the theory of instrument resonance affecting the tone, set a recorder running and play a one-handed note while intermittently clasping and releasing the sax in various places with your free hand - the bell, the bow, the neck, etc. If the theory is correct then you should be able to hear a difference on playback.

I couldn't, but that may be because I'm a rotten player with cloth ears. YMMV.

Bottom line, I agree with Pete, but am pretty unqualified to hold any opinion on the subject at all!

And then, to magnify the effect, clasp and release the player. Position of clasp is your choice...

regards, Phil



I had a friend try that and it caused me to squeak. Must try it with the sax sometime...
 
I know I've rambled on at great length about some of these issues, but there is another factor I realised that just helps to muddy the issue.

Sometimes my horn just sounds different on different days, when there's nothing different about it. Apart from... temperature, ambient moisture, reed and pad dryness, dust, tiredness, muscle tension, breathing, posture, mood, furniture proximity, and on and on. It drives me mad on days where it just sounds -well.. rubbish. I've learned to live with it and look forward to the times when it sounds ok.
 
Sometimes mine sounds good and bad from one minute to the next, so I suppose that's just me then.

The silver/lacquer/no lacquer debate rages on, there will always be those who claim improvements or differences in tone whether they are real or not. Even if it can be scientifically proved beyond doubt that finish or lack of it makes no difference (vibrating column of air, sax not resonating etc etc), the debate comes down to subjective vs objective. Or as Doreen's old granma used to say "I don't care if it is true, I don't believe it".

Happy blowing, whatever your choice of horn and finish.
 
I have noticed one major difference between silver plated and non-plated saxophones: I just like the look of silver plated saxes 🙂

Can't point to any other significant difference. I attribute all stuffiness/resonance/x-factor to my mouthpiece, reed, embouchure and amount of practice.

🙂
 
Okay Guys, I don't mind you taking the mickey, saves some other poor person.
Just try this. Play a G and with the spare right hand, grasp the bell in various places, you might notice some of the higher partials drop out. Also try grasping only the outside of the bell so that it cannot be attributed to 'Horn stopping'.
Enjoy and explain.
 
old git wrote:
Okay Guys, I don't mind you taking the mickey, saves some other poor person.
Just try this. Play a G and with the spare right hand, grasp the bell in various places, you might notice some of the higher partials drop out.

I imagine that could be because you are now hearing some of the sound, not purely as airborne through your ears, but as vibrations travelling directly up the bones in your arm to your brain.
 
Good point Pete but you have a shorter connection through your mouth, so you already have 'head tone'.
The other point is that my fingers are able to detect the bell resonating, presumably excited by air column vibration. That must 'colour', however slightly, the resultant tone, unless of course, I am unknowingly suffering from St. Vitus. :?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,509
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom