Tech/maintenance Saxophone maintenance and unstable notes

MonkeyBaby

Member
Messages
23
Location
Philadelphia
As my embouchure seems to improve and my fingering and in-tune-ness seems to get better with practice I’m having more problems with an unstable G. Both with and without the octave key (but especially with).
I started lessons at beginning of February and bought a used YAS-23 back in April (it had some pads replaced etc then).
I’m thinking maybe the general temperature/humidity has affected it and I’m wondering what I can do to mitigate that or perform some maintenance to help.
I practice in an unairconditioned basement and it’s pretty hot and humid here in Philadelphia.
 
Is it just G or G# also? I've come across this, kind of a warbling? Try pushing your mouthpiece on slightly (so that it seems a bit sharp) and relax your embouchure so that it no longer sounds sharp.
 
In my experience this is a voicing problem and very common. Vary the tongue shape/position until you get a stable tone. Try expanding the inside of the throat and mouth as you would when yawning. Approach note from above and below while trying to maintain good tone.

Put the idea that this might be humidity related out of your mind. It isn’t.
 
Is it just G or G# also? I've come across this, kind of a warbling? Try pushing your mouthpiece on slightly (so that it seems a bit sharp) and relax your embouchure so that it no longer sounds sharp.
It’s mostly just G. I have heard G was often unstable. I can get it to sound correct, but it requires extra effort. I think Lydian is right. I need to adjust my voicing in general.
The only oddity for me is that G didn’t used to be such an issue, but as other aspects of playing have improved, this one thing has gotten worse!
 
I think Lydian is right. I need to adjust my voicing in general.
If that is the case (and not solved by my method) then you really should discuss with a teacher. If you don't have one it sounds like you have got into some bad habits. When I used to teach I would get students come in and have that problem. When I asked what their teacher at school tried, I would get answers like "oh he was actually a trumpet player..."

Most of them were putting way too much mouthpiece in their mouth and squeezing too hard - this is the sort of thing only a teacher in the room can diagnose, all we can do is suggest different things to try. Those things are both embouchure related.
 
I do have a teacher, but he took the summer off (I don’t blame him!). Not sure about the too-much-mouthpiece, but if by squeezing too hard you mean being too tense with my jaw etc, then, yes, I know I need to relax more and I do consciously try to. Hard though.
 
A diagnostic that works for me in my teaching is to have the student play the mouthpiece and neck without the saxophone and see what pitch sounds. On alto sax, if the pitch is above Ab concert (F2 on the saxophone) the embouchure is too tight. The solution is to open the teeth more and bring the pitch down to Ab concert.

A technique that helps to "dial in" the correct voicing for a note is to first hear the pitch, hum the pitch, blow that pitch as loud as possible on an "air whistle", and finally play the note on the saxophone using the same shape inside the mouth and airstream that produced the "air whistle.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,572
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom